Game of Thrones
Return of the new fantasy king: “A Dance With Dragons”
Fans of "Game of Thrones" can rejoice: George R.R. Martin is back with "A Dance with Dragons," and he's scary good
A detail from the cover of "A Dance With Dragons" It’s been almost six years since the publication of “A Feast for Crows,” the fourth volume in George R.R. Martin’s epic fantasy saga, “A Song of Ice and Fire.” It’s been a whopping 11 years since the arrival of the third volume, “A Storm of Swords” — the last truly satisfying installment in the series. But once again, with anticipation driven to new heights after the successful first season of HBO’s adaptation, “Game of Thrones,” the waiting is finally over. Volume five, “A Dance with Dragons,” arrives in bookstores on July 12. It is a triumphant return to form: everything a Martin fan could want from a fantasy novel.
Which is both a promise … and a threat.
I cracked open the pages of this 1,016-page monster with no small dose of trepidation. When high expectations are combined with years of deferred gratification, readers are thrust onto a vulnerable precipice. Like many early-adopting fans of “A Song of Ice and Fire,” I had been disappointed by “A Feast for Crows,” a reaction that was all the more painful after so many years spent in a state of increasingly feverish anticipation. I did not want to repeat that experience.
But there was still hope, because an obvious part of the problem with “A Feast for Crows” was structural. One of the great attractions of “A Song of Ice and Fire” is the multiplicity of internal story lines involving dozens of major characters that play out simultaneously in real time. But as Martin explained, he reached a point at which the writing process had become so unwieldy that, in the interest of finally getting some product onto bookshelves, he and his publisher decided to strip out the narrative lines of several key characters and save them for the next volume. Unfortunately, the characters who vanished from the stage — for the time being — were, at least by my measure, Martin’s most compelling creations: Tyrion, the coarse, misshapen and yet brilliant dwarf whom nearly the entire world believes to be irredeemably evil but who is in fact a truer knight than most of his more able-bodied peers; Jon Snow, the bastard son of the Lord of Winterfell who has left behind a realm devolving into squabbling feudal chaos to commit himself to war against an enemy that most of his countrymen don’t even believe exists; and Daenerys, the dragon queen, liberator of slaves, born both to rule men — and tantalize them.
I don’t care how good a writer you are: If you subtract your three strongest characters from your tale, you severely undermine the basis for why readers fell under your spell in the first place. It didn’t work. It was like watching “The Sopranos” without Tony, or the original “Star Trek” without Spock. What’s the point?
After a prologue, the first three chapters of “A Dance with Dragons” are devoted, in succession, to Tyrion, Daenerys and Jon. Problem, solved.
But there was also a sense in “A Feast of Crows” that Martin had lost his way. The characters whose stories he did tell wandered back and forth across a landscape devastated by war and oncoming winter, but didn’t seem to be headed anywhere in particular. As Laura Miller noted in her terrific New Yorker article exploring the relationship between Martin and his fans, some readers began to suspect that Martin might not have the firmest grip on his own narrative. He was making it up as he went along! They accused him of perpetrating the greatest bait-and-switch in the history of epic fantasy — amassing a readership of millions via his first three tremendous novels but then leaving them high and dry while he partied at conventions and counted his royalty checks.
We won’t know until the end of the saga whether Martin will succeed in weaving every thread in his extraordinarily complex tapestry into a neat and fully satisfying conclusion. But for now, that doesn’t matter. “A Dance with Dragons” delivers what readers really crave from Martin — not closure, but instead, a sense of total immersion in a world in which the lines between good and evil, chivalry and betrayal, success and failure are blurred and morally ambiguous. It isn’t easy being a hero in “A Song of Ice and Fire.” It may be impossible. But that’s what makes “A Song of Ice and Fire” great.
It would be a disservice to dedicated readers of “A Song of Ice and Fire” — the kind of people who would be interested in a review of the fifth volume of an ongoing saga, to reveal any details that could be construed as spoilers. But here’s what I can tell you: I wanted to savor this book slowly. Knowing that it would be years before Martin delivered volume six, I wanted to sip “A Song of Ice and Fire” as if it was the finest wine, instead of chugging it like cheap beer. Most fantasy novels are the stuff of easily disposable escape, but — and this was especially true once I was convinced of its quality — “A Dance with Dragons” felt like serious business, not to be trifled with.
I failed. All the cliches apply. I couldn’t put it down. Late at night, into the wee hours, I would tell myself: just one more chapter, and then, again and again, break my own vow. I was like a hospital patient who keeps clicking on the morphine feed, a binge reader addicted to Martin crack. I was lucky my children were out of town, or I would have been feeding them stale potato chips and allowing them unlimited screen time. I was Martin’s bitch.
Those who can still remember the experience of reading the first few volumes of “A Song of Ice and Fire” for the first time may understand what I’m talking about. He’s baaaack.
But make no mistake, “A Dance with Dragons” is no joy ride. Daenerys discovers that it is far more difficult to rule than conquer — and that dragons are not to be trifled with. Tyrion plumbs new depths in personal humiliation. The challenges Jon Snow faces attempting to hold together an unlikely coalition at the mighty Wall that is the first and last line of defense against the unworldly marauders from the far North are fraught with peril. Betrayal piles upon betrayal like logs thrown onto a bonfire, itching to burst into a conflagration of death and treachery. The deeper one penetrates into the plot, the more an eerie sense of tension starts to build. The reader begins to realize, hey, maybe things aren’t going to work out so great for everybody. Maybe the return of Jon, Tyrion and Daenerys is a mixed blessing. Do I really want to see this through?
And therein lies another key to Martin’s greatness, to what separates him from all his peers. By the fifth volume of “A Song of Ice and Fire,” Martin has unimpeachably established his street cred as the most ruthless writer of popular fantasy alive. Martin, we know, with a sick feeling in our stomachs, has no qualms about killing off major characters, or twisting narrative arcs from glory into degradation. Every character has their own sword of Damocles hanging over them. Turn the page and watch it fall.
The result is foreboding. I couldn’t stop reading Martin because my desire to know what was going to happen combined with my absolute inability to guess what would happen and left me helpless before his sorcery. At the end, I felt shaken and exhausted.
I can’t recall the last time a work of science fiction or fantasy had that kind of effect on me. I’m almost glad that it will be years before I have to do this all over again. Because it will take me years to recover.
Andrew Leonard is a staff writer at Salon. On Twitter, @koxinga21. More Andrew Leonard.
TV’s best villain
"Game of Thrones'" teen ruler Joffrey Baratheon is the rare bad guy who can make you viscerally, physically angry
Jack Gleeson in "Game of Thrones" “Game of Thrones’” Joffrey Baratheon (Jack Gleeson) looks like he could be in a boy band. His blond hair is brushed forward over his forehead, in the current Justin Bieber-inspired, fear-of-the-forehead style. His deep-set, hooded eyes and fair skin give him that sleepy, growing-is-exhausting, pillowcase-still-imprinted-on-the-cheek look of late adolescence. His anodyne features, bunched a little too closely around his snub nose, could easily make him the third-cutest member of a group featured in a Tiger Beat poster. Except Joffrey Baratheon is TV’s most noxious, unredeemable villain, and if he belongs on any poster, it’s a Most Wanted one, preferably defaced with devil’s horns, an eye patch, nasty scars, boogers, fangs, drool, and then — why stop there — ripped to shreds.
Continue Reading Close
Willa Paskin is Salon's staff TV writer. More Willa Paskin.
TV’s best show about women
"Game of Thrones" is filled with strong female characters that -- surprise! -- have lots to say about modern sexism
Emilia Clarke in "Game of Thrones" The second season of HBO’s “Game of Thrones,” which premiered last Sunday, is based on a novel — the second in an ongoing saga — called “A Clash of Kings.” But fans of the bloody, battle-scarred show know that’s a misnomer: There are more than a few queens throwing down in this brawl — not to mention a passel of noblewomen, priestesses, grizzly mamas, and badass, sword-wielding soldiers of the distaff variety.
This may be the Year of the Sitcom Woman, but the biggest, most vibrant group of women on TV today can be found in a brutal, self-serious war drama set in a made-up medieval world — just the kind of story, it so happens, that’s often assumed to be the sole dominion of dudes.
Continue Reading CloseNina Shen Rastogi is a writer whose work has appeared in Slate, the Washington Post, the International Herald Tribune and Vulture, where she recaps "Game of Thrones." She is the head of content at Figment, the online reading and writing community for teens and young adults. More Nina Shen Rastogi.
The real-life inspirations for “Game of Thrones”
Mischief and murder --medieval-style -- inspired the epic series
Lena Headey in "Game of Thrones" Yes, “Game of Thrones” has dragons and ice zombies and giant clairvoyant wolves, but for every viewer (or reader) who climbed onto George R.R. Martin’s epic fantasy bandwagon for the magical stuff, I suspect there are two of us who are in it for the palace intrigue. Velvet sleeves concealing jewel-encrusted daggers, scheming eunuchs with networks of spies, parvenue commoners outwitting the supercilious aristos and totally, utterly ruthless power plays — what’s not to love?
Continue Reading Close
Laura Miller is a senior writer for Salon. She is the author of "The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia" and has a Web site, magiciansbook.com. More Laura Miller.
Is “Game of Thrones” too white?
Fantasy fiction might have racial problems, but they're just a reflection of America's broader battles
Nonso Anozie, Lena Headey and Jason Momoa in "Game of Thrones" Ser Jorah’s face grew thoughtful as their horses trod together down the godsway. “When I first went into exile, I looked at the Dothraki and saw half-naked barbarians, as wild as their horses. If you had asked me then, Princess, I should have told you that a thousand good knights would have no trouble putting to flight a hundred times as many Dothraki.”
“But if I asked you now?”
“Now,” the knight said, “I am less certain.”
Continue Reading CloseSaladin Ahmed has been a finalist for the Nebula Award for Best Short Story and the Campbell Award for Best New Science Fiction or Fantasy Writer. His fantasy novel "Throne of the Crescent Moon" was recently published to wide acclaim. More Saladin Ahmed.
“Game of Thrones” parenting lessons
The HBO show is violent and sexually graphic -- and it's filled with wisdom about being a dad
“Game of Thrones” isn’t the most likely parenting guide: Season 1 is bookended with beheadings and chock-full of incest. But when you’re about to be a dad you can find inspiration in unlikely places, and last April I had already maxed out my library renewals on “Your Baby’s First Year for Dummies.”
I didn’t freak out when I found out my wife and I were going to have a son. But as the day approached, I had a crisis of confidence. We were living in a studio in Los Angeles, sleeping on a mattress that smelled like pumpkin beer from the previous fall, driving a two-door, 30-year-old car. How were we supposed to do this?
Continue Reading CloseNed Vizzini is the author of It's Kind of a Funny Story, Be More Chill, and Teen Angst? Naaah..., as well as a writer on Season 2 of MTV's Teen Wolf. His work has been translated into seven languages. His next novel, The Other Normals, will be published on September 25, 2012. Follow him on Twitter @ned_vizzini or visit his website at www.nedvizzini.com. More Ned Vizzini.
Page 1 of 4 in Game of Thrones