The “Cannibal Cop” debate

Experts disagree on whether today's guilty verdict is an attack on fantasy or the prevention of a gruesome crime

Topics: Sex, Love and Sex, cannibal cop, cannibalism, BDSM, Editor's Picks, ,

The "Cannibal Cop" debate (Credit: Facebook)

When news broke this morning of the conviction of Gilberto Valle, the so-called Cannibal Cop, I didn’t know what to think. Was this verdict a dangerous assault on fantasy or the prevention of a grisly crime? How can we tell the difference between disturbingly realistic role-play and actual criminal plotting? I went to some smart thinkers — in the worlds of psychiatry, civil liberties and BDSM — for clarity on the trial, but what I found was that there are no easy answers.

The facts are as follows: Valle engaged in elaborate conversations online with fellow fetishists about kidnapping and eating real-life women. The former NYPD officer unlawfully accessed a federal law enforcement database to research potential “victims” and did Web searches for everything from chloroform to human meat recipes. The prosecution claimed that he showed up on the street of one of the women he’d talked about kidnapping (although doubts were raised about the reliability of the evidence). But he never met with his online pals in person or committed the talked-about crimes, and the defense says Valle was engaging in make-believe.

The first person I turned to was Dr. Fred Berlin, founder of the National Institute for the Study, Prevention and Treatment of Sexual Trauma and one of the country’s foremost experts on sexual disorders. Although not an expert on cannibalist fantasies, per se, he routinely works with a different population with aberrant desires that are illegal to act upon: pedophiles. He’s familiar with the high-stakes calculation of whether someone is at risk for offending or not. He says that while he respects the decision of the jury, and declined to comment on the specifics of this case, in many instances he would have “a very difficult time concluding beyond a responsible doubt that something was real rather than fantasy.”

He explains, “I’ve read many online discussions where it looked as thought it was absolutely real, they were talking about getting together and bringing a child, and this went on for weeks,” he said. “Then toward the end, someone said, ‘You do realize this isn’t real,’ and another person [in the conversation] acknowledged that it wasn’t.” In other words, he knows firsthand “how easily one can think something is real that isn’t” and, as a result, suspects he would have had “a bit more difficult” time coming to a verdict. Indeed, as I found on DarkFetishNet, one of the fetish role-play sites frequented by Valle, make-believe can seem very real.

More generally, Chris Kraft, co-director of the Clinical Services, Sexual Behaviors Consultation Unit at Johns Hopkins University, tells me, “The legal community frequently assumes attraction and fantasy will lead to contact,” he says. “People can have fantasies that are never acted on and of course there are some people who do pursue sexual behaviors that are connected to fantasy but most people don’t engage in illegal sexual behaviors if their fantasies and behaviors would be harmful to themselves or others.”

I expected First Amendment scholar Clay Calvert, who has written in defense of “the fundamental human right to hold deviant ideas,” to defend Valle — instead, he highlighted the difference between thought and action. ”Had he not had that evidence on his computer, then it’s merely a thought crime and under the First Amendment we have freedom of thought,” he says. But in this case “thought crossed into the realm of conduct and action,” Calvert says. Ultimately, he says, “jurors are the arbiter of where that line is that separates harmless fantasy from the plan to commit a criminal act.” That is reassuring if you have faith in the average juror’s ability to distinguish accurately between fantasy and reality, but perhaps disturbing if you share Dr. Berlin’s view of the complexities involved.

You Might Also Like

On the other hand, Gabe Rottman, legislative counsel for the Washington American Civil Liberties Union, argued in a recent New York Times Op-Ed piece about the case, which was written before the verdict, that “requiring proof of actual intent is probably” the key here. “For violent fantasies like those in the Valle case, there has to be compelling evidence that the speakers actually meant to carry out the crime (and for express threats, courts should, at the very least, require proof that the speaker meant to put the target of the speech in fear of harm),” he wrote. “Otherwise jokes, hyperbole, make-believe and merely offensive speech can easily be criminalized.”

For a perspective from the world of kink, I went to Clarisse Thorn, author of “The S&M Feminist,” who was quick to disown Valle’s actions. ”I’m getting increasingly uncomfortable with how some people are attempting to use media narratives of BDSM to justify non-consensual acts,” she says, pointing to Valle’s unlawful use of a crime database and allegations that Valle showed up on a potential victim’s street. “For everyone’s benefit, we need to be willing to prosecute people who have clearly plotted murder and even broken the law to do it — it doesn’t matter whether there’s a chance that they ‘might’ not actually do it.” She doesn’t worry that the ruling will set an anti-kink precedent because, as she says, “responsible BDSMers promote careful consent above all else.”

Similarly, Kitty Stryker, a BDSM activist who has spoken out about abuse within the kink community, tells me, “I’m sure some kinksters will cry out ‘thought crime,’ but personally? I think it’s about time informed consent was a little more of a blatant priority in the kink community, rather than worries about supposed censorship.”

So, back to my original question: Was this verdict a dangerous assault on fantasy or the prevention of a grisly crime? Clearly, it depends on whom you ask — but the jury went with the latter.

Tracy Clark-Flory
Tracy Clark-Flory is a staff writer at Salon. Follow @tracyclarkflory on Twitter and Facebook.

More Related Stories

Featured Slide Shows

  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Facebook
  • 1 of 13
  • Close
  • Fullscreen
  • Thumbnails

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    DAYA  
    Young Daya has yet to become entirely jaded, but she has the character's trademark skeptical pout down pat. And with a piece-of-work mother like Aleida -- who oscillates between jealousy and scorn for her creatively gifted daughter, chucking out the artwork she brings home from summer camp -- who can blame her?

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    MORELLO   
    With her marriage to prison penpal Vince Muccio, Lorna finally got to wear the white veil she has fantasized about since childhood (even if it was made of toilet paper).

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    CINDY   
    Cindy's embrace of Judaism makes sense when we see her childhood, lived under the fist of a terrifying father who preached a fire-and-brimstone version of Christianity. As she put it: "I was raised in a church where I was told to believe and pray. And if I was bad, I’d go to hell."

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    CAPUTO   
    Joey Caputo has always tried to be a good guy, whether it's offering to fight a disabled wrestler at a high school wrestling event or giving up his musical ambitions to raise another man's child. But trying to be a nice guy never exactly worked out for him -- which might explain why he decides to take the selfish route in the Season 3 finale.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    BOO   
    In one of the season's more moving flashbacks, we see a young Boo -- who rejected the traditional trappings of femininity from a young age -- clashing with her mother over what to wear. Later, she makes the decision not to visit her mother on her deathbed if it means pretending to be something she's not. As she puts it, "I refuse to be invisible, Daddy. Not for you, not for Mom, not for anybody.”

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    SOSO
    We still don't know what landed Brooke Soso in the slammer, but a late-season flashback suggests that some seriously overbearing parenting may have been the impetus for her downward spiral.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    POUSSEY
    We already know a little about Poussey's relationship with her military father, but this season we saw a softer side of the spunky fan-favorite, who still pines for the loving mom that she lost too young.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    PENNSATUCKY
    Pennsatucky had something of a redemption arc this season, and glimpses of her childhood only serve to increase viewer sympathy for the character, whose mother forced her to chug Mountain Dew outside the Social Security Administration office and stripped her of her sexual agency before she was even old enough to comprehend it.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    CHANG
    This season, we got an intense look at the teenage life of one of Litchfield's most isolated and underexplored inmates. Rebuffed and scorned by her suitor at an arranged marriage, the young Chinese immigrant stored up a grudge, and ultimately exacted a merciless revenge.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    HEALY
    It's difficult to sympathize with the racist, misogynist CO Sam Healy, but the snippets we get of his childhood -- raised by a mentally ill mother, vomited on by a homeless man he mistakes for Jesus when he runs to the church for help -- certainly help us understand him better.

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    NORMA
    This season, we learned a lot about one of Litchfield's biggest enigmas, as we saw the roots of Norma's silence (a childhood stutter) and the reason for her incarceration (killing the oppressive cult leader she followed for decades).

    The 12 most incredible pint-size look-alikes in "Orange Is the New Black" season 3

    NICKI
    While Nicki's mother certainly isn't entirely to blame for her daughter's struggles with addiction, an early childhood flashback -- of an adorable young Nicki being rebuffed on Mother's Day -- certainly helps us understand the roots of Nicki's scarred psyche.

  • Recent Slide Shows

Comments

0 Comments

Comment Preview

Your name will appear as username ( settings | log out )

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href=""> <b> <em> <strong> <i> <blockquote>