I still hope the bomber is a white American
The identity of the person behind the Boston bombings will strongly affect our response -- even O'Reilly agrees!
David Sirota FollowTopics: Boston Marathon bombing, Boston Marathon explosion, boston marathon bombing suspect, 9/11, Terrorism, patriot act, Life News, Politics News
I’m not the kind of person who hopes to ever find conservative Fox News host Bill O’Reilly agreeing with me. But with my Salon piece on the Boston bomber now on the front page of Drudge, I think it is worth pointing out that last night O’Reilly effectively agreed with my piece by confirming the very simple self-evident truth that the Boston bomber’s demographic profile will, indeed, dictate how America responds to the atrocity.
O’Reilly starts out by stating something every American almost certainly agrees with: We should all be first and foremost hoping that the perpetrator — whoever he or she is — is apprehended as quickly as possible. Then he moves into an analysis of the future reaction. As O’Reilly put it, “If this is an international terror attack, the repercussions will be severe,” but, he added, “if it’s home-grown” that will just “be another stain on American history.”
In stating such an obvious truth, O’Reilly has (inadvertently) spotlighted the double standard that drives so much of our public policymaking and our cultural attitudes toward national security.
As he said, if the bomber ends up being a foreigner there will be a “severe” response — and if history is any guide, that means potentially a full-scale mobilization of military assets, passage of draconian civil liberties legislation, police surveillance of entire demographic groups and even perhaps a scuttling of the pending immigration bill. By contrast, if the bomber is one of the many “home-grown” — read: white domestic terrorist — attacks we’ve seen in recent years, it will merely be chalked up as “another stain on American history,” but will not necessarily prompt any kind of societal mobilization against any one particular group.
You Might Also Like
The reason, then, to hope that the bomber ends up being a white American is because the double standard may prevent an overreaction to the heinous attacks in Boston. Indeed, if the bomber ends up being a white American, there’s a decent chance we will not see a redux of the post-9/11 period when we (among other things) initiated reckless wars, passed privacy-trampling bills like the Patriot Act, overspent on the Pentagon and targeted wide swaths of the population for surveillance/warrantless wiretapping.
The same cannot be said if the bomber ends up being a Muslim — in that case, the double standard will work in the opposite way, encouraging another post-9/11 redux and all the attendant bad policies that came with it.
By the way, you don’t have to be a person of color or a political liberal to hope the bomber ends up being a white American. You just have to be among the groups of Americans who don’t like stuff like preemptive wars, the Patriot Act, warrantless wiretapping, the drone war, an unsustainable Pentagon budget and a broken immigration system. By their own rhetoric, some of those groups must include many self-described conservatives — after all, they purport to care about civil liberties and say they want to reduce government spending.
That gets back to the original point: The reason to hope that the bomber is a white American is because in a country where white privilege and double standards so obviously affect our national security reactions, that outcome will better guarantee that the reaction to Boston is a bit more measured.
You Might Also Like
More Related Stories
-
Make this your Facebook resolution: The best thing you can do to safeguard your privacy in 2016
-
#blessed? Not a good look. Your 2016 resolution is to ban these "basic" phrases
-
An Oregon teacher’s letter to lawmakers: We don’t need your prayers, we need your courage
-
What nobody told me about small farming: I can't make a living
-
"What a horrible mother": How a call from a "good samaritan" derailed these mothers' lives
-
I have given away my guns: I'm a Texan and a hunter, but I won't be part of gun culture any more
-
I'm tired of suppressing myself to get along with white people
-
Why observing "Dry January" might help you cut back on drinking down the line
-
Netflix's last great gift of 2015: A New Year's Eve for earlybirds
-
5 worst social media fails by politicians this year
-
"In this book, Jennifer Aniston learns that not wanting a baby when you’re female means something’s wrong with you"
-
"It’s just karma" -- Cosby's accusers speak out
-
American privilege in Taiwan: I lied to my Taiwanese students and told them I didn't speak Chinese. Here's how it backfired
-
Now you seafood, now you don't: 10 foods climate change could soon eradicate
-
My neighbor from hell
-
"I should be among the dead": Young, white, and economically advantaged, I was hungry for meaning and found heroin instead
-
Teen Beat ruined me: Rob Lowe, Duran Duran and my sexy, screwed-up Gen X adolescence
-
"Any body—every body—is a bikini body": Women’s Health bans the phrases “Bikini Body” and “Drop Two Sizes” from its covers for good
-
Bill Cosby still wins
-
Carrie Fisher shuts down the ageist haters as only Carrie Fisher can
-
Bill Cosby to be charged in sexual assault case: Reports
Featured Slide Shows
- Share on Twitter
- Share on Facebook
- 1 of 13
- Close
- Fullscreen
- Thumbnails
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
Recent Slide Shows
-
Blood moon magic: 17 amazing images of the supermoon around the world
-
"Dick Cheney watches television": The four previously unseen 9/11 photos that will make you hate the evil VP all over again
-
Heartbreaking images from Sandra Bland's funeral
-
Must-see photos: Never-before seen images inside the White House on September 11
-
The best series finales ever
-
When marriage is an act of political protest
-
Photos from the Happy Ending Salon
-
Make Summer More Poetic with These 10 International Works
Related Videos
Most Read
From Around the Web
Presented by Zergnet
-
HUFFPOLLSTER: Here’s What You Need To Know About The First Republican Primaries As 2016 Begins
-
Reported Rapes Go Through The Roof On Game Day At Big Football Schools
-
Wall Street Got Burned In Washington This Year, For Once
-
Here's Where Donald Trump Could Take The GOP In 2016
-
The WorldPost's 10 Must-Read Interviews Of 2015
-
Do one thing a day in the first week of 2016 to be a better person environmentally.
-
5 things you can do to catch up if you overspent on the holidays.
-
Meet the student fighting for his country's native language. He's great.
-
France figured out how to make its grocery stores feed even more people.
-
Bad weeks don't seem so rough when you apply this perspective to life. Here's how.





Comments
0 Comments