The right’s healthcare “revolution” is a scam

Conservatives like to trumpet “consumer-driven” healthcare plans. Here’s what they’re not telling you about them

Topics: Health Care, The Right, Conservatives, Consumerism, the poor, Ralph Nader, ,

“The consumer-driven healthcare revolution,” trumpeted one conservative think tank a few years back, “has only just begun.”

Now, for anyone who has ever been inconvenienced by an encounter with the healthcare system – or even worse, been on the receiving end of poor quality care, a medical error or a misdiagnosis – a greater focus on “consumer” satisfaction might sound like just the right medicine for American healthcare.

So should we celebrate the recent rise of “consumer-driven” or “consumer-directed” healthcare plans?  The premise of CDHPs – essentially high-deductible plans, with an option for a health savings account – is straightforward enough: If you shop for services with your “own money,” you’ll use less healthcare and hunt for better bargains, in the process forcing providers to improve quality.

CDHPs have grown rapidly in recent years.  From a trivial 4 percent in 2006, CDHPs now account for a full 20 percent of all employer-based insurance plans.  The trend seems set to continue in 2014: A survey from the National Business Group on Health last month found that CDHPs were considered “the most effective tactic to control rising costs” by large employers, with 72 percent already offering a CDHP, and 22 percent planning to offer only CDHPs in 2014.

I’d wait to break out the bubbly, for, despite the utopian claims of its enthusiasts, CDHPs are more about cash than quality, more about cost shifting than consumer empowerment.

The “consumer-driven healthcare revolution,” it turns out, is likely to be neither revolutionary nor consumer-driven, but instead will only manage – somehow – to make the misfortune of getting sick an even worse experience.

One irony of the current craze with “consumer-driven” care is that its adherents seem surprisingly unaware that we already had an experiment with true market medicine in this country – in the 19th century.

“From the beginning,” argues the legal professor T. S. Jost in his critique of the consumer-driven movement, “Health Care at Risk,” “there was only consumer-directed health care in the United States.”  Patients paid out of pocket, there was no health insurance, and there were an impressive variety of equally ineffective practitioners, frequently engaged in brutal competition.

The system (if it can be called that) was basically a disaster, with the presence of a healthcare marketplace doing little to encourage “quality” in that golden age of quackery.  What ultimately did improve quality – at least to some extent – was good old-fashioned regulation: medical licensure laws, the closure of low-quality medical schools, the Pure Food and Drugs Act, and so on.

Meanwhile, the poor of that era were generally left at the mercy of scattered and frequently inadequate charitable facilities – if they were lucky.  In later years, hospitals would not infrequently reject or otherwise “dump” sick patients deemed poor financial investments, a notorious practice that wasn’t really addressed — again, with regulation – until the Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act of 1986.

The second irony of the current consumer-driven movement is the degree to which it diverges from the last major healthcare “consumerism” movement of the 1960s and 1970s, when progressive activists and consumer advocates like Ralph Nader sought to advance the rights of patients in an age when medical paternalism was the rule of the land.

“The major element in all of this activity,” commented an editorial in one medical journal in 1971,  “has been the unyielding insistence that the people who are to use the product or who are to be recipients of a service are entitled to an important voice in how that …  service is dispensed.”  Reforms to defend the mentally ill and disabled, to protect the privacy of health information, to open free clinics for the poor, and to increase the use of “informed consent” prior to medical interventions were achieved, in part, in the name of “consumer” rights.

If the current consumer movement sought similar goals – to give patients more of a voice in the healthcare system – who would be opposed?

Enter “Consumer-Driven Health Care.” Unfortunately, the current consumer-driven movement represents something altogether different from these earlier efforts to advance the rights of patients.

Consumer-driven healthcare arose from the ashes of yet another allegedly “consumer”-based model: “managed competition” among health maintenance organizations was at the heart of Bill Clinton’s healthcare plan.  The essence of such a type of plan – dubbed a “Consumer-Choice Health Plan” by the health economist Alain Enthoven in 1978 – was that competition among insurance companies for healthcare consumers would drive down costs and increase quality.  Clinton’s plan famously failed, but the HMO-model was rapidly ascendant – to the dismay of both patients and physicians, neither of whom appreciated profit-taking insurance companies dictating or denying care.

As the HMO paradigm began to disintegrate, a variety of academic, business and political thinkers began promoting a “consumer-driven” alternative.  Their ideas, it should be noted, were not particularly original.  At the center of the new ideology was the long-standing idea of healthcare “moral hazard,” which as I recently discussed, is the idea that because insurance makes our medical expenses “free,” we will use healthcare haphazardly and indiscriminately, without regard for cost (and apparently without regard for the fact that we are subjecting our bodies to unnecessary incisions and intrusions).

But it was only in the late 1990s that the term “consumer-driven healthcare” arrived on the scene, a coinage courtesy of Harvard Business School professor Regina Herzlinger, dubbed the “unofficial godmother” of the movement by Money magazine.  “In this system people would newly consider the costs of the health care products and services they use,” she wrote in her 1997 book, “Market-Driven Health Care.“  “A consumer-controlled system would allow Americans to decide how to spend their money … they would shop carefully for the health services for which they themselves paid.”  Herzlinger coupled this notion of a free healthcare marketplace, however, with a legal requirement that everybody buy catastrophic health insurance – i.e., an individual mandate, the initially conservative idea that today’s conservatives are oddly outraged by.

Herzlinger’s influence should not be underestimated.  The former CEO of Aetna called her ideas “the most important trend to hit health care – and Regi [as she is known] is a beacon for us practitioners.”  This was not idle talk, with Aetna being described in one policy journal as a “first mover” in the move toward consumer-driven health insurance.

The more-or-less same idea keeps popping up everywhere.  Rand Paul made the argument for market-medicine a few weeks back on “The Daily Show.” In the book “Catastrophic Care – How American Health Care Killed My Father,” published earlier this year, the business executive David Goldhill similarly argues that the only solution to quality problems in American healthcare is consumer-driven care, with universal catastrophic insurance for all, but with all other expenses paid for out-of-pocket.  “We are less likely to be skeptical of benefits when we are paying little or nothing for them,” Goldhill argues.  “So the plague of unnecessary cesarean deliveries, spinal fusion surgeries, and cardiac bypasses …”

Exactly. It would be simply foolish not to have your abdomen, spine and/or thoracic cavity surgically opened and unnecessarily manipulated, assuming – and this is crucial – that it was free.

The failure of such individuals to imagine that some things in life are not mere commodities underscores the inherent failure of the consumer-driven ideology.  But the ideology remains appealing to many because it promises things we all value – choice, quality, knowledge, respect, individualized-attention – with something that no one wants: skimpy, low-quality health insurance that pushes us to avoid needed care when we need it (sometimes even in emergencies), while leaving us at the end of the day with a big bill.

None of this is to deny that American healthcare has serious quality problems, that as physicians we need to be much more cognizant of the costs and utility of the interventions we prescribe, and that all healthcare providers need to work toward making the experience of healthcare more convenient and humane.

But let’s work to improve American healthcare in ways that actually have a basis in solid evidence, before selling it off to the highest bidder in the name of a market ideology better suited to the interests of industry than to the needs of the sick.

AG is a physician and writer in Massachusetts.  He blogs at and is on twitter at @awgaffney.

More Related Stories

Featured Slide Shows

  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Facebook
  • 1 of 11
  • Close
  • Fullscreen
  • Thumbnails

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Beautiful Darkness by Fabien Vehlmann & Kerascoët
    Kerascoët's lovely, delicate pen-and-watercolor art -- all intricate botanicals, big eyes and flowing hair -- gives this fairy story a deceptively pretty finish. You find out quickly, however, that these are the heartless and heedless fairies of folk legend, not the sentimental sprites beloved by the Victorians and Disney fans. A host of tiny hominid creatures must learn to survive in the forest after fleeing their former home -- a little girl who lies dead in the woods. The main character, Aurora, tries to organize the group into a community, but most of her cohort is too capricious, lazy and selfish to participate for long. There's no real moral to this story, which is refreshing in itself, beyond the perpetual lessons that life is hard and you have to be careful whom you trust. Never has ugly truth been given a prettier face.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Climate Changed: A Personal Journey Through the Science by Philippe Squarzoni
    Squarzoni is a French cartoonist who makes nonfiction graphic novels about contemporary issues and politics. While finishing up a book about France under Jacques Chirac, he realized that when it came to environmental policy, he didn't know what he was talking about. "Climate Changed" is the result of his efforts to understand what has been happening to the planet, a striking combination of memoir and data that ruminates on a notoriously elusive, difficult and even imponderable subject. Panels of talking heads dispensing information (or Squarzoni discussing the issues with his partner) are juxtaposed with detailed and meticulous yet lyrical scenes from the author's childhood, the countryside where he takes a holiday and a visit to New York. He uses his own unreachable past as a way to grasp the imminent transformation of the Earth. The result is both enlightening and unexpectedly moving.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Here by Richard McGuire
    A six-page version of this innovative work by a regular contributor to the New Yorker first appeared in RAW magazine 25 years ago. Each two-page spread depicts a single place, sometimes occupied by a corner of a room, over the course of 4 billion years. The oldest image is a blur of pink and purple gases; others depict hazmat-suited explorers from 300 years in the future. Inset images show the changing decor and inhabitants of the house throughout its existence: family photos, quarrels, kids in Halloween costumes, a woman reading a book, a cat walking across the floor. The cumulative effect is serene and ravishing, an intimation of the immensity of time and the wonder embodied in the humblest things.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Kill My Mother by Jules Feiffer
    The legendary Pulitzer Prize-winning cartoonist delivers his debut graphic novel at 85, a deliriously over-the-top blend of classic movie noir and melodrama that roams from chiaroscuro Bay City to Hollywood to a USO gig in the Pacific theater of World War II. There's a burnt-out drunk of a private eye, but the story is soon commandeered by a multigenerational collection of ferocious women, including a mysterious chanteuse who never speaks, a radio comedy writer who makes a childhood friend the butt of a hit series and a ruthless dame intent on making her whiny coward of a husband into a star. There are disguises, musical numbers and plenty of gunfights, but the drawing is the main attraction. Nobody convey's bodies in motion more thrillingly than Feiffer, whether they're dancing, running or duking it out. The kid has promise.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    The Motherless Oven by Rob Davis
    This is a weird one, but in the nervy surreal way that word-playful novels like "A Clockwork Orange" or "Ulysses" are weird. The main character, a teenage schoolboy named Scarper Lee, lives in a world where it rains knives and people make their own parents, contraptions that can be anything from a tiny figurine stashable in a pocket to biomorphic boiler-like entities that seem to have escaped from Dr. Seuss' nightmares. Their homes are crammed with gadgets they call gods and instead of TV they watch a hulu-hoop-size wheel of repeating images that changes with the day of the week. They also know their own "death day," and Scarper's is coming up fast. Maybe that's why he runs off with the new girl at school, a real troublemaker, and the obscurely dysfunctional Castro, whose mother is a cageful of talking parakeets. A solid towline of teenage angst holds this manically inventive vision together, and proves that some graphic novels can rival the text-only kind at their own game.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    NOBROW 9: It's Oh So Quiet
    For each issue, the anthology magazine put out by this adventurous U.K.-based publisher of independent graphic design, illustration and comics gives 45 artists a four-color palette and a theme. In the ninth issue, the theme is silence, and the results are magnificent and full of surprises. The comics, each told in images only, range from atmospheric to trippy to jokey to melancholy to epic to creepy. But the two-page illustrations are even more powerful, even if it's not always easy to see how they pertain to the overall concept of silence. Well, except perhaps for the fact that so many of them left me utterly dumbstruck with visual delight.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Over Easy by Mimi Pond
    When Pond was a broke art student in the 1970s, she took a job at a neighborhood breakfast spot in Oakland, a place with good food, splendid coffee and an endlessly entertaining crew of short-order cooks, waitresses, dishwashers and regular customers. This graphic memoir, influenced by the work of Pond's friend, Alison Bechdel, captures the funky ethos of the time, when hippies, punks and disco aficionados mingled in a Bay Area at the height of its eccentricity. The staff of the Imperial Cafe were forever swapping wisecracks and hopping in and out of each other's beds, which makes them more or less like every restaurant team in history. There's an intoxicating esprit de corps to a well-run everyday joint like the Imperial Cafe, and never has the delight in being part of it been more winningly portrayed.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    The Shadow Hero by Gene Luen Yang and Sonny Liew
    You don't have to be a superhero fan to be utterly charmed by Yang and Liew's revival of a little-known character created in the 1940s by the cartoonist Chu Hing. This version of the Green Turtle, however, is rich in characterization, comedy and luscious period detail from the Chinatown of "San Incendio" (a ringer for San Francisco). Hank, son of a mild-mannered grocer, would like to follow in his father's footsteps, but his restless mother (the book's best character and drawn with masterful nuance by Liew) has other ideas after her thrilling encounter with a superhero. Yang's story effortlessly folds pathos into humor without stooping to either slapstick or cheap "darkness." This is that rare tribute that far surpasses the thing it celebrates.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Shoplifter by Michael Cho
    Corinna Park, former English major, works, unhappily, in a Toronto advertising agency. When the dissatisfaction of the past five years begins to oppress her, she lets off steam by pilfering magazines from a local convenience store. Cho's moody character study is as much about city life as it is about Corinna. He depicts her falling asleep in front of the TV in her condo, brooding on the subway, roaming the crowded streets after a budding romance goes awry. Like a great short story, this is a simple tale of a young woman figuring out how to get her life back, but if feels as if it contains so much of contemporary existence -- its comforts, its loneliness, its self-deceptions -- suspended in wintery amber.

    Ten spectacular graphic novels from 2014

    Through the Woods by Emily Carroll
    This collection of archetypal horror, fairy and ghost stories, all about young girls, comes lushly decked in Carroll's inky black, snowy white and blood-scarlet art. A young bride hears her predecessor's bones singing from under the floorboards, two friends make the mistake of pretending to summon the spirits of the dead, a family of orphaned siblings disappears one by one into the winter nights. Carroll's color-saturated images can be jagged, ornate and gruesome, but she also knows how to chill with absence, shadows and a single staring eye. Literary readers who cherish the work of Kelly Link or the late Angela Carter's collection, "The Bloody Chamber," will adore the violent beauty on these pages.

  • Recent Slide Shows


Loading Comments...