Read it on Salon
Join HULU, SEINFELD and SALON to celebrate Festivus!
Sponsored Post
Monday, Nov 23, 2015 10:28 PM UTC
Republicans just don’t get Stephen Colbert: Why the Fox News-watching, climate-change denying crowd can’t understand complex satire
Colbert's ratings are down. Republicans are crowing they won't watch him. Indeed, they are afraid to be challenged
Topics: Stephen Colbert, Jimmy Kimmel, Jimmy Fallon, TV, Television, Editor's Picks, Elections 2016, Innovation News, Entertainment News, News
When it was first announced that Stephen Colbert would take over for David Letterman as host of “The Late Show”—both the right and the left complained. The left worried that the end of “The Colbert Report” and his pundit persona would signal a huge loss for politically progressive satire. The right argued that the choice of Colbert signaled that CBS was, to quote Rush Limbaugh, at “war on the heartland of America.” “CBS executives made it clear” however, “that they expected Mr. Colbert to broaden his appeal when he moved to the medium of late night on a network.”
At least that was the idea.
We now have data that paint a different picture. First of all, despite a strong start, Colbert has now trailed behind his comedic competitors on ABC and NBC for two weeks running. That is good news for ABC’s Jimmy Kimmel, who had held the No. 3 spot since Colbert took over. NBC’s Jimmy Fallon remains comfortably No. 1 with approximately a half million more viewers than his closest competitor.
So what’s the catch? Why has Colbert dropped in ratings? Well, according to a poll published by The Hollywood Reporter, it seems that Colbert has a GOP problem. Only 17 percent of Colbert’s viewers are Republican compared to 31 percent for Fallon and 33 percent for Kimmel. While Kimmel is clearly the comedian that most appeals to Republican viewers, both he and Fallon have a fairly balanced split between parties. Colbert, in contrast, does not.
| Colbert | Fallon | Kimmel | |
| Democrat | 47% | 36% | 34% |
| Republican | 17% | 31% | 33% |
| Independent | 31% | 27% | 30% |
While late night viewers already skew Democratic, Colbert’s viewers lean much more to the left. When asked who they would vote for in an election between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton, 72 percent of Colbert’s viewers said they would vote Democratic. That’s a huge jump over Fallon’s 56 percent and Kimmel’s 52 percent. Even more revealing is the fact that 49 percent of Colbert’s viewers favor Bernie Sanders.
Now for those of you who actually watch Colbert, this has to come as big news. Colbert didn’t just shed his conservative blowhard pundit persona when he took over for Letterman—he also changed his comedy to fit in to the format. First of all, he moved far more towards the variety show comedy of Letterman. He has great musical talent on the show every night. He does silly jokes during his stand up every night. He gets a great menu of celebrity talent on every night.
Even within the format, Colbert made a number of shifts away from the comedy he did on “The Colbert Report” and towards the mainstream. Now many of his interviews are just opportunities for celebrities to shill their next project. And he softballs many of his political guests—as happened when he had Donald Trump on. He also has a significant amount of bits that are just pure entertainment – goofy jokes that have no connection to the political satire that made him famous.
But, here’s the catch. Colbert may have largely adapted to the genre, but he has also introduced elements into the genre that we have never seen before. He has hosted guests like Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer and Tesla founder Elon Musk. He had a heartfelt and intense interview with Joe Biden. And he did a biting interview with Ted Cruz where he refused to allow the Tea Party candidate to rewrite history and spout lies.
He has also held on to his sharp satirical edge. Besides continuing to do a very Colbert Report-like segment where he regularly critiques the news media, he has also included brilliant satirical bits like “The Hungry for Power Games” series where he takes on the persona of Stanley Tucci’s Caesar Flickerman and bids farewell to a presidential candidate exiting the race.
That series has given equal time –and mockery—to both Democrats and Republicans. Lincoln Chafee and Jim Webb each got their due. Colbert has also done great segments mocking the Democrats in general. In fact, there is ample evidence that he has effectively moved his satire into a more centrist mode.
So why don’t Republicans like him? According to Callum Borchers in the Washington Post, the problem is that Colbert takes positions that will enrage the GOP on topics like gay marriage and Syrian refugees. When he goes after these issues he tends to skewer the GOP, exposing the flaws to their logic, mocking their twisted so-called values, and revealing their penchant for re-writing history. Borcher tells us “Colbert knows how to bring down the house by painting conservatives as a bunch of backward xenophobes. He’s one of the best at it.”
Borchers is right, of course. But there’s more to the story. The real divide here is over the sort of comedy offered by Colbert on “The Late Show” and that offered by his counterparts on NBC and ABC. Even if he goes after positions held by the right and the left, he will still offer viewers a smart, incisive comedic view—one that is radically different from the goofy, frat boy humor of Kimmel and the charming, cool guy humor of Fallon.
Most Read
