Broadsheet

Reading your way to a Y chromosome

A list of 100 books on "How to Be a Man" is heavy on the Vonnegut, light on the female authors.

When I was younger, I looked to literature to show me how to become all kinds of things I wasn't: the beats for how to be cool, Waugh and Wodehouse for how to be British, Capote for how to be fabulous. And now, thanks to the Art of Manliness blog, I am provided with a reading list that will instruct me in "How to Be a Man"!

As it turns out, reading my way to manhood is a lot like my 11th-grade curriculum ("Moby-Dick," "A Farewell to Arms," "Self-Reliance," "The Federalist Papers"), and apparently, also crucial to one's masculine development are Theodore Roosevelt, political philosophy from hundreds or even thousands of years ago (Plato's "Republic," "Leviathan," "The Prince") and World War II.

What isn't manly? Well, women, naturally. Books by female authors occupy three slots on the list of 100 titles -- the same number as biographies of Teddy Roosevelt. Of these, we have Mary Shelley and Harper Lee, both famous for two things -- producing a single work of fiction and having the provenance of that work consistently (if unfairly) questioned -- and Ayn Rand, who is to traditionally female attributes like empathy and interpersonal relationships what Grover Norquist is to functioning government. Jews don't make the cut either -- despite his status as our greatest living author and his landmark contributions to the field of masturbation, Philip Roth didn't make it onto the list. (Norman Mailer and Joseph Heller squeaked by, but only in their WWII incarnations.) And certainly not blacks -- not a single African-American author appears on the list. James Baldwin? Not manly. Kurt Vonnegut? Very, very manly. In fact, if his prominence here is any indication, cracking open "Slaughterhouse-Five" is the literary equivalent of a double oophorectomy, or years of testosterone therapy.

Thank God for Oscar Wilde's "The Picture of Dorian Gray" -- "a guide for how to live a life of pure decadence" -- or I'd think being a man was all about sober responsibility, reluctantly killing people and sleeping outside on a rock. Which prompts the question: If that's what men need to know, what about women? What would you put on a women's reading list? Would we have Jane Austen after Jane Austen, or is it possible that maybe, just maybe, "The Great Gatsby" has something to say to women, too?

Feminism in the news

Loading...

Currently in Salon

  • From Balloon Boy to Sarah Palin's death panels, the media chased a lot of hoaxes in 2009 and called them news
  • Special ho-ho-ho-infused, not-quite-gift-guide edition: MST3K, Wenders, film noir, wine snobs and more
  • Grab a partner. You have some cooking to do. Plus: Last week's winners
  • From cash-strapped polygamists to rogue lawn mowers at Sterling Cooper, the greatest shows dared to provoke
  • Sex scandals, swine flu, tea parties, Michele Bachmann -- and that's just the first half of 2009
  • What the Democrats can learn from the Republicans about managing the ménage à trois within the party
  • At least, I was until now. Because in my circle, nothing is more embarrassing than being religious
  • Jacob Hacker breaks with fellow progressives, comes out in favor of the Senate's proposal
  • She never became Hollywood's It girl, but she was as daffy and heartbreaking as her A-list contemporaries
  • An extraordinary new memoir by a college jock whose brain began to bleed

Other News