Broadsheet

Did Maureen Dowd go too far?

It's interesting that the media, more than two weeks after Hillary Clinton conceded, is now taking a step back and actively assessing its sexism. Not that it's a bad thing; it's just, perhaps, a late thing. As Rebecca Traister writes in a story about ticked-off Clinton voters in Salon Monday, "It is painfully obvious that this was a conversation that could only be had once Clinton stopped threatening Obama's prospects, or men generally. This is really depressing."

Now it's the New York Times' turn to answer for itself on the issue. In one of those dry, wonkish reads -- the media equivalent of that awkward moment when students are asked to grade their own performance -- Clark Hoyt, public editor for the Times, examines the question of sexism and Clinton in the paper of record. Hoyt asks an intern to do an archive search for terms like "shrill" and "strident" -- those trusty old female dismissals -- or references to Clinton's appearance and ultimately finds Times reporters were "on the careful end" of the spectrum when it came to their portrayal of Clinton. Nice. The Times rewards itself with a solid B.

But -- and this is where it gets interesting -- the paper's feisty columnist Maureen Dowd doesn't fare as well. We've discussed the divisive and difficult Dowd here many times before, and now, Hoyt turns the spotlight on her and asks not merely if her treatment of Clinton was sexist but also if her salty columns, with their breathless depictions of Clinton's suffocating presence and references to Hillary as a "female victim," would have been published were she a man. Ooh, interesting. Dowd's editor, Andrew Rosenthal, says she would have. He would have. Whatever.

But Hoyt begs to differ! In his understated way, of course. In his conclusion he offers a chaste slap on the wrist: "Of course, there is no such man, and I do not think another one could have used Dowd's language. Even she, I think, by assailing Clinton in gender-heavy terms in column after column, went over the top this election season."

Over the top? Maureen Dowd? Tell me when she has ever been anything but. (And we haven't even discussed her truly offensive use of puns!) Still, I think Dowd has seen her final grade for this season: Needs improvement.

Posted in: Media

Shacking up, not settling down
Horrors! Young couples are moving in together without plans for marriage
Slipped through the cracks
Roundup: Is porn ditching narrative? Plus romance novels, eating placenta and more
Pope tries to school Obama on abortion
The two meet for the first time in Vatican City and get straight to business
A slap in the face to fat girls
Beth Ditto may be a hip plus-size icon, but her new clothing line feels like an insulting throwback to a 1985 Kmart

Recent Posts

Slipped through the cracks
Roundup: Is porn ditching narrative? Plus romance novels, eating placenta and more
Pope tries to school Obama on abortion
The two meet for the first time in Vatican City and get straight to business
A slap in the face to fat girls
Beth Ditto may be a hip plus-size icon, but her new clothing line feels like an insulting throwback to a 1985 Kmart

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2009
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

Tips or Comments?

E-mail us at broadsheet@salon.com.