War Room

The flag-burning vote: Republicans exploit, Democrats enable

Well, that didn't take long.

Even before the Senate took its designed-to-pander but destined-to-fail vote on a constitutional amendment on flag burning Tuesday, one Republican senator had already begun using the vote as a campaign issue for his 2006 reelection drive. As the Washington Post reports, Virginia Sen. George Allen issued a press release Tuesday in which he said his challenger's opposition to the flag-burning amendment put him "firmly on the side of John Kerry, Ted Kennedy and Charles Schumer."

Although Allen has often shown more of a fondness for the Confederate flag, it's no surprise that he has jumped on the flag-burning vote as a political tool. Polls have Democrat James Webb gaining ground fast against Allen, and the incumbent can't out-patriot his challenger in the usual ways. Allen, who turned 18 in 1970, never served in the U.S. military; Democrat James Webb saw combat in Vietnam and went on to become the secretary of the Navy under Ronald Reagan. The Senate vote on the flag-burning amendment was custom-designed for needy Republicans like Allen, and they'll use it to full effect.

The question, of course, is why so many Democrats felt the need to play along. Three Republicans -- Lincoln Chafee, Mitch McConnell and Robert Bennett -- had the courage to vote against the amendment. Fourteen Democrats did not; Max Baucus, Evan Bayh, Mark Dayton, Dianne Feinstein, Tim Johnson, Mary Landrieu, Blanche Lincoln, Bob Menendez, Ben Nelson, Bill Nelson, John Rockefeller, Ken Salazar and Debbie Stabenow joined Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid in voting in favor of the flag-burning amendment.

Why?

Maybe they really think that flag burning is so awful that the Constitution ought to be amended to allow its criminalization. But Sen. Reid, can you make a serious argument that with all the other problems facing the country, a flag-burning amendment was really worth a minute -- let alone two days -- of the Senate's time right now? Nope. "I think we have some misplaced priorities," Reid said at a press conference Tuesday. "I don't think it's the right time to bring up the issue ... I'll vote for it."

And what about you, Sen. Feinstein? If a Republican from Utah and a certain Democrat from Connecticut can find it in themselves to stand up to cheap political pandering by the right -- even Hillary Clinton managed to vote no, albeit in her typical have-it-both-ways style -- what in God's name were you doing out on there on the Senate floor with a picture of Iwo Jima?

As the majority leader, Bill Frist has every right to bring whatever he wants to the Senate floor. As a far-right extremist, Orrin Hatch has every right to argue that flag burning really is the No. 1 issue in America today. But Democrats in the Senate have rights, too, and among them is the right -- in a time of war, we'd call it a responsibility -- to walk out of the chamber in protest when the other party decides to spend its time playing cheap political games. You want to talk about honoring the sacrifice of veterans, Sen. Feinstein? Why don't you start by doing your job?

VoteVets targets McCain with new ad
In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

19:00 EDT, July 23, 2008
VoteVets targets McCain with new ad In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
War Room
13
17:41 EDT, July 23, 2008
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now? Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
War Room
19
15:31 EDT, July 23, 2008
More bad news for McCain on Iraq A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
War Room
29
14:22 EDT, July 23, 2008
Republicans lose a major financial backer T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
War Room
28
12:37 EDT, July 23, 2008
Obama camp debuts Spanish-language radio ad Highlighting Obama's personal history, the spot concludes, "It's time we had a president who understands we all deserve a chance to make our own way."
War Room
7

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!