War Room

The path to "The Path to 9/11"

The New York Times reveals today that Cyrus Nowrasteh, the writer of the embattled ABC "docudrama" "The Path to 9/11," was hired after the executive producer and director of the project read his script for the 2001 Showtime movie "The Day Reagan Was Shot."

If that's true, they might have wanted to do a little more research. "The Day Reagan Was Shot" -- which was, ironically, produced by Oliver Stone -- was plagued with the same kind of substantive factual errors that riddled "The Path to 9/11." In both movies, administration officials were portrayed as dangerously incompetent, bringing the United States to the brink of disaster. In "The Path to 9/11," it is National Security Advisor Sandy Berger and Secretary of State Madeleine Albright who come in for the harshest, and most disputed, treatment. In "The Day Reagan Was Shot," it was Secretary of State Al Haig whose reputation was impugned. He was portrayed as bringing the country to the verge of nuclear war with the Soviet Union.

In December 2001, when "The Day Reagan Was Shot" premiered, Richard Allen, formerly the national security advisor under Reagan, took to the pages of the Wall Street Journal to castigate the film's creators, calling the movie's portrayal of the events inside the White House that day "fictional."

"How do I know it is fictional? Because I was there. Oh, and I had a tape recorder ...

"Situation Room meetings are rarely tape-recorded, but because we were dealing with a national emergency that afternoon, I placed my own small recorder in the center of the table. I captured the entire proceedings, about six hours. Written versions of these events have appeared since, some mostly accurate, others mostly inaccurate, but none has approached 'The Day Reagan Was Shot' for brazen distortion ...

"The film places generals in the Situation Room when they were not there; introduces conversations that never occurred; claims that a 'red alert from NORAD' was in progress (there is no such thing) and that a Soviet 'wolf pack' was off our coast with malign intent. (It wasn't: There were more Soviet subs than usual because it was the end-of-the-month changeover day, as we figured out within 20 minutes.) ...

"Messrs. Stone and Nowrasteh had completed their shoot by the time I wrote an account of the March 1981 events in the Atlantic Monthly, on the 20th anniversary. They then had a problem: They needed to validate their version and had not known about my tapes. I insisted on seeing the film before talking with Mr. Stone's people, and after I did, Mr. Nowrasteh had the temerity to say that the tapes 'corroborate our movie.' They do no such thing ...

"Maybe the whole thing was meant as a comedy. If not, it is simply a swindle."

McAuliffe's choice for veep not Clinton?
The former chairman of Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign seems to say he wants someone else to be Barack Obama's running mate.
Quote of the day
Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones
McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama
The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

18:56 EDT, July 24, 2008
McAuliffe's choice for veep not Clinton? The former chairman of Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign seems to say he wants someone else to be Barack Obama's running mate.
War Room
18
18:40 EDT, July 24, 2008
Quote of the day Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
War Room
17:39 EDT, July 24, 2008
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
War Room
7
16:57 EDT, July 24, 2008
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.
War Room
40
15:50 EDT, July 24, 2008
Obama had cheering Germans; McCain had German sausage With their choice of counterprogramming for Obama's Berlin speech, Republicans try to portray McCain as more focused on the U.S. than Obama is.
War Room
9

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones
McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama
The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!