War Room

"There is no magic formula"

The Iraq Study Group will release its report to the public this afternoon, but don't expect any silver bullet for solving the problem George W. Bush has created in Iraq. There isn't one, and that's the point on which just about everyone agrees.

The group's report will say that "there is no magic formula." Robert Gates, whose nomination to replace Donald Rumsfeld as secretary of defense cleared the Senate Armed Services Committee 24-0 Tuesday, said Tuesday that "there are no new ideas on Iraq," just maybe "a way to put pieces of those different proposals together in a way that provides a way forward." Sen. Barack Obama says: "We have no good options at this point. We have bad options and worse options." Al Gore: "There are no good outcomes."

At the White House, the president met with members of the Iraq Study Group this morning and thanked them for their work. "It is a report," he said, "that brings some really very interesting proposals, and we will take every proposal seriously and we will act in a timely fashion."

What does that mean now? The group's report reportedly says conditions in Iraq are "grave and deteriorating" and could cause "the collapse of Iraq's government and a humanitarian catastrophe." Group members have worried that their work may already be too late, that the war is already lost. Eighteen more U.S. soldiers have been killed in Iraq already this month; the U.S. death toll could pass 3,000 by the end of the year. But a White House that has used the report as cover for delaying any hard decisions on Iraq is now saying that it will be looking at "other ongoing studies within the administration," and it's urging Congress to do the same once the new year starts.

These studies, or "advice documents," as the president calls them, apparently include Donald Rumsfeld's laundry list of ideas for Iraq as well as a Pentagon plan to increase troop levels in whatever passes for the "short term" these days. That approach got a small bipartisan boost Tuesday when Rep. Silvestre Reyes, an early war opponent and the incoming Democratic chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, said he likes the idea of sending 20,000 or 30,000 more U.S. troops to Iraq in order to "take out the militias and stabilize Iraq."

We might all like the idea if it would actually work. But an incremental increase in troop levels isn't likely to be popular with an electorate that just sent a pretty clear signal that it would like to see less U.S. involvement in Iraq, nor is it part of the Iraq Study Group's agenda, at least as far as we know now. That said, we've heard so many different things about the group's proposals -- a phased withdrawal, a phased pullback, a switch from combat to training, diplomacy with Iran and Syria, benchmarks for progress by the Iraqi government and threats if it doesn't meet them -- that we're beginning to suspect that the final report is such a vague mishmash that it will offer something for everyone and yet nothing that could help attain any truly desirable result.

That's probably not the fault of the group's members; they're not the ones who decided to launch a war of choice with no real plan for winning it. We are where we are now, and there is no good way for this story to end.

VoteVets targets McCain with new ad
In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

19:00 EDT, July 23, 2008
VoteVets targets McCain with new ad In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
War Room
13
17:41 EDT, July 23, 2008
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now? Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
War Room
19
15:31 EDT, July 23, 2008
More bad news for McCain on Iraq A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
War Room
29
14:22 EDT, July 23, 2008
Republicans lose a major financial backer T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
War Room
28
12:37 EDT, July 23, 2008
Obama camp debuts Spanish-language radio ad Highlighting Obama's personal history, the spot concludes, "It's time we had a president who understands we all deserve a chance to make our own way."
War Room
7

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!