War Room

The Supreme Court slams right, but Scalia wants more

With today’s 5-4 decisions on school integration, price restraints and the death penalty, John Roberts’ Supreme Court has reached something of a dubious milestone: By at least one count, the court has decided a higher percentage of its cases by 5-4 votes this term than in any term in the last 10 years.

This year’s percentage of 5-4 decisions — more than 30 percent — is similar to the percentage from the court’s 2004 term. But as SCOTUSblog’s Ben Winograd explains, the percentage of 5-4 decisions doesn’t tell the full story. In 2004, the court’s liberal-leaning justices picked up the swing votes they needed to win one-third of the 5-4 decisions. This term — with Samuel Alito on the bench in place of Sandra Day O’Connor — the liberals’ winning percentage has dropped to roughly 25 percent.

As the New York Times’ Linda Greenhouse notes today, that’s still not good enough for Associate Justice Antonin Scalia. Although Roberts has voted with Scalia in all but two of the court’s 5-4 decisions this year, Scalia took the chief justice to task twice earlier this week for not going further than he did in decisions that swung to the right. In one case on campaign finance law and another on the government promotion of religion, Scalia accused Roberts of engaging in “faux judicial modesty” and making “meaningless and disingenuous distinctions” in order to avoid explicitly overruling precedent that Scalia would like to see gone.

Scalia has no need for such harsh words today. The court handed down three decisions in the final session of the term, and Robert, Alito, Scalia and Clarence Thomas were in complete accord on all three.

Palin booed at Flyers game
Philadelphia fans played to type, raising the question — again — of why the McCain camp thought it would be a good idea for Sarah Palin to drop the ceremonial puck.
Has Rezko started talking?
The real estate developer, who was closely tied to Barack Obama, was convicted this summer — he’s likely talking about other politicians, however.
John Lewis: McCain, Palin “sowing seeds of hatred and division”
Discussing the Republican campaign, the civil rights icon invokes the memory of George Wallace’s rallies.
McCain camp responds to Troopergate report
Sarah Palin denies that she abused her power, while a campaign spokeswoman derides the investigation as partisan.

Current Salon Politics Stories

  • Meet Sarah Palin’s radical right-wing pals

    Extremists Mark Chryson and Steve Stoll helped launch Palin’s political career in Alaska, and in return had influence over policy. “Her door was open,” says Chryson — and still is.

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Has Rezko started talking?
The real estate developer, who was closely tied to Barack Obama, was convicted this summer — he’s likely talking about other politicians, however.
John Lewis: McCain, Palin “sowing seeds of hatred and division”
Discussing the Republican campaign, the civil rights icon invokes the memory of George Wallace’s rallies.
McCain camp responds to Troopergate report
Sarah Palin denies that she abused her power, while a campaign spokeswoman derides the investigation as partisan.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

October 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.