War Room

The AP says Obama thinks genocide is no biggie

Philip Elliott and the headline writers at the Associated Press have done a real job on Barack Obama with this story, headlined "Obama: Don't Stay in Iraq Over Genocide." The article claims that Obama says that genocide isn't a "good enough reason," when in fact he simply makes the observation that we don't make military decisions on that basis or we would currently be in the Congo, Sudan and Darfur. Not quite the same thing.

But the truly puzzling assertion in the article is this one: "Obama, a first-term senator from Illinois, said it's likely there would be increased bloodshed if U.S. forces left Iraq." That would not be a particularly shocking assessment unless it had been preceded by the inaccurate headline and lead that imply Obama doesn't give a damn about genocidal bloodshed. But it's just plain misleading when you see what Obama actually said:

"Nobody is proposing we leave precipitously. There are still going to be U.S. forces in the region that could intercede, with an international force, on an emergency basis," Obama said between stops on the first of two days scheduled on the New Hampshire campaign trail.

"There's no doubt there are risks of increased bloodshed in Iraq without a continuing U.S. presence there."

The greater risk is staying in Iraq, Obama said.

"It is my assessment that those risks are even greater if we continue to occupy Iraq and serve as a magnet for not only terrorist activity but also irresponsible behavior by Iraqi factions," he said.

He didn't say that we shouldn't care about the risk of bloodshed if we leave; he said he's more worried about the risk of even more bloodshed if we stay. (It's a testament to the horrible array of options we have before us in Iraq that the question of which genocide scenario is preferable is an issue in the presidential campaign.)

A headline like that should be carefully considered before it's published. Obama is not an uncaring person who doesn't care if massive numbers of Iraqis die, and his words simply do not match the assertions in that article. It's terribly unfair to be sloppy or cute with loaded terms like genocide and the AP should be more careful.

Obama takes superdelegate lead?
Barack Obama had a big day Friday -- some outlets report that he now has more superdelegate support than Hillary Clinton does.
McCain defends comments about Hamas, Obama
John McCain justifies his statement that Hamas wants Barack Obama to be president by saying he's only discussing what's of interest to voters.
Clinton makes another electability argument
In a presentation sent to superdelegates, the Clinton camp says that Hillary can help Democrats in Congress in November.
Double, double toil and trouble in Berkeley
Code Pink witches take on the U.S. Marines Corps, and broomsticks fly.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

08:40 EDT, May 12, 2008
McCain campaign baits Obama on Clinton slurs It's hard to believe the faux outrage at sexism after McCain chuckled at the B-word, but Obama has to discourage Kennedy-style disrespect for Clinton as the battle winds down.
Joan Walsh
43
07:10 EDT, May 10, 2008
What should Hillary Clinton do now? If she stays in the race she should focus on her strengths, not Obama's flaws.
Joan Walsh
1099
18:04 EDT, May 9, 2008
Obama takes superdelegate lead? Barack Obama had a big day Friday -- some outlets report that he now has more superdelegate support than Hillary Clinton does.
War Room
49
14:46 EDT, May 9, 2008
Economics 101: Obama vs. McCain And then there were two. In a speech delivered by Obama in Oregon, Hillary Clinton is yesterday's news
How The World Works
23
14:19 EDT, May 9, 2008
Kennedy dismisses idea of joint ticket In an interview with Bloomberg, Obama supporter Sen. Ted Kennedy says he doesn't think a presidential ticket involving both candidates would be possible.
War Room
32

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

McCain defends comments about Hamas, Obama
John McCain justifies his statement that Hamas wants Barack Obama to be president by saying he's only discussing what's of interest to voters.
Clinton makes another electability argument
In a presentation sent to superdelegates, the Clinton camp says that Hillary can help Democrats in Congress in November.
Double, double toil and trouble in Berkeley
Code Pink witches take on the U.S. Marines Corps, and broomsticks fly.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

May 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!