War Room

New York Times editorial scolds Clinton

The lead editorial in Wednesday's New York Times, "The Low Road to Victory," blasts Sen. Hillary Clinton for going negative in her campaign for the Democratic nomination: "It is past time for Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton to acknowledge that the negativity, for which she is mostly responsible, does nothing but harm to her, her opponent, her party and the 2008 election." It argues that Clinton's harsh campaign "ended up squandering a good part of what was once a 20-point lead."

But did Clinton ever really have a 20-point lead in Pennsylvania to squander? Not likely, according to Jerome Armstrong, writing on MyDD.com. Averaging various polls put Clinton up by 9.5 in February, 12.9 in March and 6.4 in April. As Armstrong points out in the comments on that blog post, the 20-point lead figure is based on a single, widely quoted poll taken in January, rather than monthly averages of many polls. No matter, by 10:27 p.m. Eastern time, the Obama campaign was already blasting out e-mailed excerpts from the blistering Times editorial to the press (judiciously leaving out the digs that the editorial gets in at Obama for taking Clinton's bait, of course).

The Times editorial is notable not only for its vehemence but for its characterization of Clinton's victory as not a "big win." After all, the lead story about the election in the very same newspaper called Clinton's showing in Pennsylvania a "decisive victory." That could be because the Times editorial was already declaring the night not "the big win in Pennsylvania she needed to challenge the calculus of the Democratic race" before the results had been settled. Obviously, the Times editorial closed before some Pennsylvania precincts had reported and Clinton's margin of victory had widened; that's abundantly clear from the time stamp on the e-mail from the Obama campaign trumpeting the editorial to reporters. Or, maybe Clinton would have had to have won by 20 points for the Times editorial writers to consider her margin of victory sufficient enough to "challenge the calculus of the Democratic race."

In any case, the piece raises the broader question that everyone will be debating on Wednesday: How exactly does one define Clinton's Pennsylvania victory in this wild race?

Posted in: 2008 Election, Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton

McAuliffe's choice for veep not Clinton?
The former chairman of Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign seems to say he wants someone else to be Barack Obama's running mate.
Quote of the day
Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones
McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama
The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

18:56 EDT, July 24, 2008
McAuliffe's choice for veep not Clinton? The former chairman of Hillary Clinton's presidential campaign seems to say he wants someone else to be Barack Obama's running mate.
War Room
21
18:40 EDT, July 24, 2008
Quote of the day Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
War Room
17:39 EDT, July 24, 2008
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
War Room
7
16:57 EDT, July 24, 2008
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.
War Room
40
15:50 EDT, July 24, 2008
Obama had cheering Germans; McCain had German sausage With their choice of counterprogramming for Obama's Berlin speech, Republicans try to portray McCain as more focused on the U.S. than Obama is.
War Room
9

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Quote of the day
Chuck Hagel wants everyone to step back, take a deep breath and stop talking about the surge.
From a glass house, the straight talker throws stones
McCain's campaign is now criticizing Obama for having the temerity to make speeches outside the country -- of course, McCain did the same thing just a month ago.
Report: More than 200,000 watched Obama
The crowd for Barack Obama's speech in Berlin was reportedly his largest ever.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!