War Room

What did Clinton do wrong?

With everyone pretty much declaring the Democratic nomination race over, the finger-pointing has begun, and people are beginning to examine why Hillary Clinton -- once considered the inevitable nominee -- has apparently lost her bid for the presidency.

Time magazine's Karen Tumulty has a good analysis of what went wrong. She lists five big mistakes: "She misjudged the mood," "she didn't master the rules," "she underestimated the caucus states," "she relied on old money" and "she never counted on a long haul."

As I said, it's a good analysis, made all the better by a very interesting if ultimately fairly minor scoop. Tumulty reports on a Clinton strategy session held last year:

As aides looked over the campaign calendar, chief strategist Mark Penn confidently predicted that an early win in California would put [Clinton] over the top because she would pick up all the state's 370 delegates. It sounded smart, but as every high school civics student now knows, Penn was wrong: Democrats, unlike the Republicans, apportion their delegates according to vote totals, rather than allowing any state to award them winner-take-all. Sitting nearby, veteran Democratic insider Harold M. Ickes, who had helped write those rules, was horrified -- and let Penn know it. "How can it possibly be," Ickes asked, "that the much vaunted chief strategist doesn't understand proportional allocation?" And yet the strategy remained the same, with the campaign making its bet on big-state victories.

I'd add one other thing to Tumulty's list. The Clinton campaign focused on making its candidate seem inevitable; it spent almost no energy making her seem human. There's still a lot of distaste for Clinton remaining from her husband's administration, a lot of it coming out of a sense that she's only a political creature, caring only about what will get her elected president. And the Clinton camp's strategy has played into that. Meanwhile, I know a few people who've spent time hating Clinton and who were swayed by a close encounter with her. She may not have the big-stage charm of her husband, but by all reports she's got charisma and warmth to spare. Her campaign never even made an effort to show that, and instead sent her out to say ridiculous things that made her look even more craven. The policy gaps between Obama and Clinton are not that wide, and the campaign had to be prepared for the race to come down to personal character -- Obama obviously had the advantage there, but still, the Clinton camp didn't need to play right into Obama's hands as it did.

One other interesting thing from Tumulty's story, by the way. Discussing why Clinton is still in the race, Tumulty reports, "Clinton's calculation is as much about history as it is about politics. As the first woman to have come this far, Clinton has told those close to her, she wants people who invested their hopes in her to see that she has given it her best."

Posted in: 2008 Election, Hillary Clinton

The Obama ad MoveOn didn't pick
More than 1,000 videos were submitted to MoveOn's "Obama in 30 Seconds" contest, only one was rejected -- now it's surfaced on the Internet, and the group is apologizing.
"Hardball": Barack Obama is no Neville Chamberlain
Those who don't learn from history will be humiliated on live television by Chris Matthews.
The California decision and the presidential campaign
There are few signs of a major electoral backlash against the California Supreme Court's decision legalizing gay marriage, but the court's opinion leaves Democrats exposed.
What's next for gay marriage in California?
If conservative organizations get their way, voters will have an opportunity this fall to overturn the state Supreme Court's ruling legalizing gay marriage.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

06:00 EDT, May 16, 2008
The Obama ad MoveOn didn't pick More than 1,000 videos were submitted to MoveOn's "Obama in 30 Seconds" contest, only one was rejected -- now it's surfaced on the Internet, and the group is apologizing.
War Room
18
19:46 EDT, May 15, 2008
"Hardball": Barack Obama is no Neville Chamberlain Those who don't learn from history will be humiliated on live television by Chris Matthews.
War Room
35
19:28 EDT, May 15, 2008
The California decision and the presidential campaign There are few signs of a major electoral backlash against the California Supreme Court's decision legalizing gay marriage, but the court's opinion leaves Democrats exposed.
War Room
11
13:33 EDT, May 15, 2008
California Supreme Court legalizes gay marriage The court says a ban on same-sex marriage is unconstitutional and civil unions are not an acceptable substitute; California becomes only the second state to permit gay marriage.
War Room
155
12:52 EDT, May 15, 2008
In new message, McCain tries on the hope mantle John McCain says that if he's elected president, by the end of his first term the Iraq war will be won and most U.S. troops will have left.
War Room
38

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

"Hardball": Barack Obama is no Neville Chamberlain
Those who don't learn from history will be humiliated on live television by Chris Matthews.
The California decision and the presidential campaign
There are few signs of a major electoral backlash against the California Supreme Court's decision legalizing gay marriage, but the court's opinion leaves Democrats exposed.
What's next for gay marriage in California?
If conservative organizations get their way, voters will have an opportunity this fall to overturn the state Supreme Court's ruling legalizing gay marriage.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

May 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!