How the World Works

Class war and the Farm Bill

Another sign that growing income inequality in the United States is a political hot-button whose time has come. A television ad campaign currently running in Minnesota, New Hampshire and Washington, D.C., is attacking the Farm Bill on the grounds that it subsidizes layabout millionaires instead of good old bedrock family farmers. (Thanks to Trade Diversion for the link.)

This is flat-out class warfare: On one side, your down-to-earth tiller of the soil, dressed in plaid, jeans and scuffed up work boots, a bemused frown spreading across his face. On the other, a smirking, slick upper-class leech, nattily dressed right down to the tip of his gleaming patent-leather shoes. All he's missing is a top hat and a monocle.

The campaign, produced by Oxfam America, is predicated on one critical statistic: 10 percent of farmers collect 73 percent of all subsidies. Although a revised version of the Farm Bill that has already passed the House would prohibit individual farmers who make more than $1 million a year from receiving subsidies represents an improvement from the current cap of $2.5 million, Oxfam America and other groups endorsing the campaign say that it's still too easy for businesses and partnerships to evade any limits.

The goal of the ad campaign's creators is obviously to keep it simple. No mention of how removing subsidies altogether would help farmers in the developing world, who can't compete with the low prices for commodity goods that result from subsidized American overproduction. No mention of the challenge of figuring out what crops and agricultural practices should be encouraged by the Farm Bill, in place of the current system, which, for example, provides huge incentives for King Corn monoculture. No mention of the Farm Bill's huge influence on the American diet,

Just the simple equation: The Farm Bill disproportionately caters to the greedy rich. Not that there's anything wrong with pointing that out. Without a doubt, one won't get very far in Minnesota attacking corn, or arguing for trade liberalization of agricultural goods for the benefit of Mexican campesinos. But when the winds of economic inequality start blowing harder, going populist is always a good bet. Keep your eyes peeled: The politics of class warfare may be coming soon to a television near you.

Google vs. Microsoft: Haven't we seen this movie?
Shades of 1995: A Web-based upstart threatens to topple Windows from its throne
Is the Obama economic rescue plan a failure?
Swayed by GOP attacks, independent voters are abandoning ship. But the summer of stimulus love has hardly started
Are automaker woes skewing unemployment figures?
In the summer, the Big 3 usually idle factories and lay off workers. But this year, they're ahead of schedule
The Pope's liberal Christian values
Social justice, wealth redistribution, a new morality for Wall Street -- the pontiff throws down on capitalism

About How the World Works

A conversation about globalization.

Recent Posts

Is the Obama economic rescue plan a failure?
Swayed by GOP attacks, independent voters are abandoning ship. But the summer of stimulus love has hardly started
Are automaker woes skewing unemployment figures?
In the summer, the Big 3 usually idle factories and lay off workers. But this year, they're ahead of schedule
The Pope's liberal Christian values
Social justice, wealth redistribution, a new morality for Wall Street -- the pontiff throws down on capitalism

Full Archive

RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2009
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031

Comments?

You can e-mail me directly at aleonard@salon.com. But to join the conversation with your comments, please use our letters to the editor feature at the bottom of each article.