I'm a 30-year-old, intelligent, funny, independent, beautiful woman -- or so I hear. I'm bisexual, but have been predominantly involved with women for the past 10 years.
I've known this great guy, an acquaintance from work, for several years now and he's always attracted me in many ways. Good-looking, intelligent, extremely witty, charming, sensitive, an intellectual, the works. Oh, and married too. For his part I've always felt that he, too, was very attracted to me. He always made sure I knew it very clearly.
Fast-forward to last November, when we allowed ourselves to let it happen. We went out for dinner and a maddeningly passionate night followed. We've been seeing each other regularly and avidly, me trying not to fall completely in love with him, him wrestling with his guilt demons. Everything is unspoken between us. We act like friends, or rather fuck-buddies, but we have a really special and rare connection.
Fast-forward again to last Saturday. We were chatting online and the subject of my bisexuality came up (I have been totally open about this with him since Minute 1). He said that despite his earlier attraction to me the fact that I slept with women too had sparked his interest even more. OK, tell me something new; all men in this galaxy get all giddy when faced with a bi woman. The problem is that he added that this not only drew him more toward me, but that it also made him feel "less guilty about cheating on his wife," because it's not like he is with a typical woman, "it's a whole different world."
This crushed me. I really care about this guy, but I couldn't help feeling like he saw me as some sort of a lesser woman, or a scientific experiment, or a circus freak. Why is it that men will do anything to have a bisexual lover but never know how to handle it? Should I withhold this fact from my future guy lovers for a while so that they feel they can really connect to me as a regular human being? Or am I overreacting?
Princess Turned to Frog
You may be overreacting a little, but that's pretty dumb and insensitive what he said. I wonder why he said it. People sometimes say dumb and insensitive things when they are under enormous pressure, or when they are struggling with inner conflict. He must feel a fair amount of guilt and fear, however much he's trying to act casual.
He has probably rehearsed in his head what he would say to his wife, should she discover his unfaithfulness. But imagine his telling her that it's OK because you're bisexual! That would be funny if it weren't so bizarre. Any attempt to spin the situation would only deepen the wound. But the mind, writhing in moral dissonance, produces just such ghastly fantasies. It's crazy and weird but true. I guess it's how we try in vain to protect ourselves from the truth. I mean, it's much easier for him to tell himself that it's OK because you're bisexual than it would be to tell himself that he's betraying his wife.
It's less painful, I guess, to pretend. I doubt that he sees you as a circus freak. He no doubt likes you a whole lot. But if there is a grain of revelation in what he said, it's that, because you have mostly been with women, he doesn't see you as the kind who would want to marry him and take him away from his wife. In his mental harem you're probably the eternal temptress.
Also because you have not been married, you may have a blind spot about what a monumental struggle he is going through. I'm not saying this out of sympathy for him, but to help you see how distorted and crazy his behavior may become as he attempts to not deal with the situation. He faces the possibility of losing his wife if she finds out, plus he probably believes that because you are bisexual, he could never completely own you. You'll always have that Sapphic option, both titillating and terrifying: While bisexual women attract men, they also frighten them, because the one thing a man has got they don't really need.
There are larger questions here. If you are falling in love with him, and he is married, you're pretty much guaranteed to bring some unhappiness into the world. Somebody's going to get screwed. So here's an idea for doing your part to create a sustainable erosphere. Go and make more happiness to combat the unhappiness you create. Do some good, selfless, joyful things. Call in sick and take a kid to the movies. Give money to beggars. Go to the beach and buy some cotton candy. Call your parents and tell them you love them. Make rainbows with a hose on the front lawn. And think up some better things than these.
- - - - - - - - - - - -
Want more advice from Cary? Read yesterday's column.