Ask Pablo

Let's talk freight: Is it better to ship by train, truck or plane?


Pablo Plastic
November 24, 2008 4:30PM (UTC)

Dear Pablo,

I recently heard a radio ad by a freight train company, claiming that it moves 1 ton of goods 422 miles on 1 gallon of fuel. Can this be true? And how does it compare to my car's fuel economy?

The freight company is CSX and its exact claim is, "Trains can move a ton of freight more than 423 miles on a single gallon of fuel." While this number sounds astounding, and the freight company cites it to show off its "environmental stewardship," the metric used is quite different than the "miles per gallon" we use with passenger cars.

Advertisement:

In reality, it is going to be difficult to make a comparison between a train that carries freight and a personal automobile, which carries passengers (actually it's usually only one passenger). But let me see if I can make the numbers make sense, and find a transportation lesson in there somewhere.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, the average car weighs 4,142 pounds, or over 2 tons. The fuel economy standard for passenger cars is 27.5 miles per gallon, set to increase to 31 in 2011. This means that 1 gallon of fuel in your car will move a ton only 13.3 miles, or a fraction of the freight train's distance.

But as I stated above, this is not a fair comparison, as the purpose of an automobile is to move a passenger. But if we wanted to use the same metric that CSX does -- ton miles per gallon -- we could come up with a comparison. If we assume the average passenger weighs 190 pounds (the average U.S. male adult weight), or almost 0.1 tons, then we could say that a car actually moves 1 ton by 2.75 miles per gallon.

But again, people are not freight, so let's look at an 18-wheeler instead. A semi might have a gross weight of 40 tons and get about 7 miles per gallon. This comes out to 280 ton miles per gallon, again using CSX's metric. Surprisingly this result is comparable to that of the passenger car.

Now let's look at jets. A Boeing 747 cargo aircraft has a maximum cargo capacity of 124 tons. Its maximum range is 4,445 miles, and its maximum fuel capacity is 53,765 gallons of fuel. This is equivalent to 0.08 miles per gallon! So air cargo gets a disappointing 10.25 ton miles per gallon (compared to CSX’s 423 miles per gallon), which shows why overnight air shipping is so expensive, and also emphasizes the relative impact on climate change.

So what have we learned about freight transportation? Rail-based transportation is more efficient than highway-based transportation, whether it's goods or people. When sending a package always consider shipping by ground rather than by air. You will save a few bucks and a whole bunch of greenhouse gas emissions as well. And when you go to visit grandma, consider taking the train instead of driving. At least then you can really enjoy the scenery, challenge your companion to a game of Scrabble, or visit the lavatory, all without pulling over.

Advertisement:

P.S.: Over the past year, I have been honored by your readership of this column, your excellent questions and thoughtful feedback. I have enjoyed using my engineering and sustainability background to contribute to the conversation around the future of our planet and society. We are all familiar with Chaucer's proverb "All good things must come to an end," and so too, the Ask Pablo column on Salon is coming to an end, as Salon tightens its budget. However, all is not lost. In the near future my column will return to its roots at Triplepundit.com, AskPablo.org and probably Open Salon. I hope to see you there and look forward to answering many great questions.

 


Pablo Plastic

Got a question about the environment? Ask Pablo at AskPablo@Salon.com.

MORE FROM Pablo Plastic

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Environment Global Warming

BROWSE SALON.COM
COMPLETELY AD FREE,
FOR THE NEXT HOUR

Read Now, Pay Later - no upfront
registration for 1-Hour Access

Click Here
7-Day Access and Monthly
Subscriptions also available
No tracking or personal data collection
beyond name and email address

•••


Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •