Are you a Peggy or a Joan?

A clever promotional site allows you to play dress-up in the "Mad Men" closet

Tracy Clark-Flory
July 30, 2009 2:30PM (UTC)


Clockwise from top left: Sarah Hepola, Lynn Harris, Rebecca Traister, Judy Berman, Mary Elizabeth Williams, Amy Benfer, Kate Harding, Page Rockwell, Tracy Clark-Flory and Katharine Mieszkowski.

The marketers behind AMC's "Mad Men" -- as in, the ones who actually sell the show, not the ad execs starring in the series -- have brought the Broadsheet staff an inordinate amount of joy with a clever promotional Web site: Mad Men Yourself. A snazzy flash widget allows you to create a virtual paper doll of yourself and then play dress up in a closet full of 1960s fashions. (See our results above.) Oh, the delightful dilemmas that arise! To go with bangs and a buoyant ponytail, à la Peggy, or Joan's va-va-voom coiffure? A curve-rocking, bright-red dress or a modest neck-to-knee frock? Accessorize with a martini or a cup o' Joe (and why isn't Don Draper an option)?


But, wait a tic, why is this group of brassy feminists so eager for some retro role-playing?

Well, I happen to think there's plenty of room within feminism for personal contradiction -- or, as I prefer to call it, evolutionary growing pains. That said, you don't have to be a psychologist to recognize that a large part of the satisfaction derived from this kind of silly exercise comes from simple self-identification. It's the "oh, I'm that type" recognition that people get from personality tests -- whether it's Myers-Briggs or the "Sex and the City" character quiz. In the "Mad Men" world, choices are pretty limited: Peggy or Joan? Jackie O. or Marilyn? Or, put in timeless terms: Wife or whore?

There's something satisfying about seeing yourself absurdly caricatured within that familiar -- and let's not kid ourselves, enduring -- framework. It hits you over the head with its limitations: You look like a Peggy but feel like an undercover Joan or you're a Joan at the office, but a Peggy at home -- and so on and so forth. The show itself revels in that contradiction -- after all, it's Peggy the Prude, not Joan the Vamp, who ends up with an unwanted pregnancy.

So, Broadsheet readers, I invite you to pigeonhole yourselves just for kicks. And a word of advice for the ladies: When presented with the first choice of "suit" or "skirt," don't make the mistake I did and choose the former, because, duh, that isn't how this game is played -- pants are for men only.

Tracy Clark-Flory

MORE FROM Tracy Clark-FloryFOLLOW TracyClarkFloryLIKE Tracy Clark-Flory

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Broadsheet Mad Men


Read Now, Pay Later - no upfront
registration for 1-Hour Access

Click Here
7-Day Access and Monthly
Subscriptions also available
No tracking or personal data collection
beyond name and email address


Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •