Win Ben Stein's bizarre healthcare analysis

On CNN, former GOP speechwriter claims Republicans more likely to pay taxes than Democrats

By Emily Holleman
February 26, 2010 4:15AM (UTC)
main article image
Comedian and actor Ben Stein addresses the Family Research Council "Values Voter Summit" in Washington, October 19, 2007. REUTERS/Hyungwon Kang (UNITED STATES) (Reuters)

Over the course of its coverage of Thursday’s healthcare summit, CNN made the always questionable decision of turning to Ben Stein, a former Republican speechwriter turned comedian turned game show host turned truly terrible economic commentator.

Stein, who frequently makes absurd remarks on a wide range of subjects, provided this explanation of why Democrats favor what he termed “government interference in the healthcare system” and Republicans don’t:


I think the answer is that a much higher percentage of Republicans are taxpayers than Democrats. And the Republicans are the people who are going to be paying for it and the Democrats are the people who are going to be receiving it .… As a general matter, Republicans as a group pay income tax at a much higher rate than Democrats.

The comment left a baffled Donna Brazile repeating, over frequent interruptions from Stein, "That's patently untrue." Anchor Wolf Blitzer decided to return to his panel of experts rather than address whether Stein's argument had any basis in reality.

Of course, the claim is virtually unprovable one way or the other. The Internal Revenue Service, the only organization that would have direct access to this information, does not collect data on political affiliations. So you have to wonder where this information is coming from.

Using people who pay federal income taxes as a proxy for "taxpayers," as Stein and other conservatives love to do, is disingenous, because income taxes isn't the only federal tax that we all pay. The fact is that most Americans pay more in payroll taxes -- things like Social Security and Medicare -- than they do in income tax.

Emily Holleman

Emily Holleman is the editor of Open Salon.

MORE FROM Emily HollemanFOLLOW emilyjholleman

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Cnn Healthcare Reform War Room