at the Republican National Convention in St. Paul, Minn., Tuesday, Sept. 2, 2008. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya) (Paul Sancya)

Bill Kristol: Michele Bachmann, Constitution expert

The faux-intellectual explains how the Minnesota extremist is motivated by her deep respect for the Founders


Joan Walsh
April 13, 2010 8:14PM (UTC)

In the Crooks and Liars video below, the headline news is the hypocrisy of Weekly Standard editor and Fox News contributor Bill Kristol: He praises Elena Kagan as a respectable nominee for the Supreme Court, but says Republicans should oppose her, anyway. But Kristol's hypocrisy isn't news. What I found interesting is his praise for tea party activists and their champion, Michele "Barack Obama is un-American" Bachmann, for their commitment to constitutional conservatism. Here's what he says. I'm quoting a lot; let no one say I'm taking him out of context.

I think, for example, [Elena] Kagan would be a very respectable choice. But nonethelessI think most Republicans would oppose her and, honestly, should oppose her, with respect and with deference to her, you know, impressive academic credentials, because she will be a reliable liberal vote, and I think Republicans should want to have a serious debate on the Constitution.

I'm struck when you listen to the Tea Party activists. They often talk about we need to be constitutionalists, we need to be constitutional conservatives. I think Michele Bachmann used that phrase in talking with you just a couple of minutes ago.

And I think having a -- one thing that motivates conservatives today is the sense that the Constitution has become a nothing. I mean, it's no - - there's no constraint on government. It's just -- government does whatever it does.

And I think the notion that there's a kind of constitutionalist agenda on the right to oppose the progressive agenda on the left has actually gone further down into the populace, you know, than constitutional-type issues normally do.

Um, really?

Advertisement:

For Kristol to argue with a straight face that Michele Bachmann, who called for an investigation into un-American beliefs among Democrats in Congress, is a defender of the Constitution, is ludicrous. Kristol being ludicrous probably isn't news either; he was an early promoter of the Sarah Palin juggernaut. Still, I'm no fan of Palin's, but let's be honest: Bachmann makes Palin look like Hillary Clinton. I can imagine nothing more hilarious than a debate between Kagan and Bachmann on the Constitution.

It's all good fun, but Kristol's joining the mob shrieking that President Obama is violating the Constitution is only a little less disgusting than the cries from the right that Obama's laudable nuclear arms reduction moves are weakening the nation's defense "on purpose." Here's the video; thanks to Crooks and Liars:


Joan Walsh

Joan Walsh is the author of "What's the Matter With White People: Finding Our Way in the Next America."

MORE FROM Joan WalshFOLLOW joanwalshLIKE Joan Walsh


Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Michele Bachmann, R-minn.

Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •