Ed Schultz

The 12 most absurdly leading "Ed Show" poll questions

Who says there aren't any 98-2 issues in American politics?

Maxwell Strachan
November 20, 2010 8:01PM (UTC)

When Ed Schultz, the exuberant progressive cheerleader who hosts a nightly MSNBC show, exhorts his viewers to "Get your cell phones out," brace yourself -- chances are a comically slanted question is coming.

Since its debut more than a year ago, "The Ed Show" has featured a text message poll. After a lengthy, often impassioned monologue from the host, viewers are asked to text their replies, with the results announced at the end of the hour. It's a harmless gimmick and "Ed" is hardly the first show to use it. But Ed's poll has a unique twist: More often than not, 85 percent or more of the audience will come down on the same side -- Ed's side.


That's what happens when you ask questions like Friday night's: "Do you think it's a good thing that President Obama is fighting harder against the Republicans?" Not surprisingly, 95 percent of the show's liberal audience -- which has been subject to countless hours of Ed pleading with the president to adopt a more assertive posture -- thought it was a good thing. The "Ed" show polls have all the suspense of a sham third-world election. It's enough to make us wonder: Why does anyone even bother replying?

Here are our 12 favorite ridiculously leading "Ed Show" poll questions of the last few months:

  1. "Do you trust Republicans to play by the rules with election money?" 5 percent yes; 95 percent no (Oct. 19).
  2. "Should reporters face arrest for asking tough questions?" 4 percent yes; 96 percent no (Oct. 18).
  3. "Are you in favor of abolishing the public school system?" 4 percent yes; 96 percent no (Oct. 14).
  4. "Do you think profitable U.S. companies have a patriotic responsibility to create American jobs?" 93 percent yes; 7 percent no (Oct. 7).
  5. "Do you think Republicans care more about saving money than educating kids?" 92 percent yes; 8 percent no (Sept. 29).
  6. "Do you believe Republican leadership has solutions for anything?" 11 percent yes; 89 percent no (Sept. 27).
  7. "Do you think the GOP and the righty talk show hosts are destroying the American dream?" 93 percent yes; 7 percent no (Sept. 21).
  8. "Do you think kids should need a parental permission slip to watch President Obama's speech?" 4 percent yes; 96 percent no (Sept. 14).
  9. "If Republicans win back the majority, do you believe that they would try to shut down the government and impeach President Obama?" 93 percent yes; 7 percent no (Sept. 2).
  10. "Do you think political candidates should be on the Fox News payroll?" 8 percent yes; 92  percent no (Aug. 17).
  11. "Do you think John Boehner cares more about playing golf or helping Americans?" 89 percent golf; 11 percent helping Americans (Aug. 9).
  12. "Do you believe big business wants to see President Obama fail?" 98 percent  yes; 2 percent no (Aug. 3).


Maxwell Strachan

MORE FROM Maxwell Strachan

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Msnbc War Room


Read Now, Pay Later - no upfront
registration for 1-Hour Access

Click Here
7-Day Access and Monthly
Subscriptions also available
No tracking or personal data collection
beyond name and email address


Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •