Texas Suit Against J&J Over Drug To Go To Trial

By Salon Staff
January 10, 2012 2:09PM (UTC)
main article image

AUSTIN, Texas (AP) — Texas prosecutors want jurors to award the state $1 billion in a lawsuit that accuses Johnson & Johnson of overstating the safety of an anti-psychotic drug and influencing its use in the state's Medicaid program.

The company, facing similar accusations in other states, is promising to vigorously defend itself when both sides lay out their cases during opening statements Tuesday.


The lawsuit accuses Johnson & Johnson and several of its subsidiaries of fraud by making false or misleading statements about Risperdal, including about its safety, cost effectiveness and superiority in the 1990s in order to convince Texas officials to use it to treat patients. Risperdal is a pill for schizophrenia and bipolar disorder.

The suit is among of dozens of pending state and federal cases alleging illegal marketing practices and kickbacks in an effort to boost Risperdal over competing drugs. Last year, a South Carolina judge ruled the company must pay a $327 million civil penalty after a jury found it guilty of overstating the safety and effectiveness of Risperdal. In 2010, a jury found that the company violated Louisiana's Medicaid Fraud Act and was fined about $258 million in damages.

Johnson & Johnson has denied the claims in Texas's lawsuit and said it follows Federal Drug Administration rules.


"We are committed to ethical business practices, and have policies in place to ensure that our products are only promoted for their FDA-approved indication. If questions are raised about adherence to our marketing and promotion policies, we act quickly to investigate the situation and take appropriate disciplinary action," the New Brunswick, N.J.-based company and its subsidiaries said in a statement.

The suit was originally filed in 2004 by whistle-blower Allen Jones, a former employee with the Office of Inspector General in Pennsylvania, and Texas later joined the case. Jones has said he learned of Johnson & Johnson's actions in Texas while investigating similar claims in Pennsylvania.

Jones' attorney and Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott's office, which is representing the state, declined comment before the trial began.


Risperdal and similar antipsychotic drugs have been linked to increased risk of strokes and death in elderly dementia patients, seizures, major weight gain, onset of diabetes and potentially fatal high blood sugar.

Jones accuses several doctors who were state officials in Texas' mental health department of giving Risperdal preference over other antipsychotic drugs. One is accused of accepting honoraria from Johnson & Johnson to urge doctors in other states' Medicaid and mental health programs to use Risperdal.


The drug company and its subsidiaries are also accused of promoting misleading interpretations of research studies and paying millions of dollars — much of it to decision-makers — to influence the creation of state mental health medication guidelines favoring Risperdal. The company also is accused of falsely saying the drug was safe to use with children and other populations when federal regulators had not approved its use with these groups.

Salon Staff

MORE FROM Salon Staff

Related Topics ------------------------------------------