The sad case of Amanda Bynes: Why we should be kinder to child stars

Her latest tweets should offer a rude awakening

Published October 10, 2014 7:40PM (EDT)


Last night, I was sitting in possibly the most depressing place -- a harshly bright bar in the Times Square TGIF with a few friends (I have no valid excuse) -- when an older woman behind us fell to the ground, hard. We heard her before we saw her, and just as we turned, two other people came rushing to help her. She was conscious, her mobility was not impaired, and two others were supporting her. She seemed okay, just embarrassed. I looked on for a moment too long until I realized the most helpful thing I could was to turn away and let her get on with her night.

This is what former Nickelodeon star Amanda Bynes -- who has stayed in the news not because of her exciting acting projects or a blossoming fashion and music career, but because she's become associated with erratic and belligerent behavior -- is asking the media and the public to do for her. Perhaps it's time for us to respect that.

Bynes, whose Twitter feed has been a running meta commentary on her mental state and the twisted ways in which magazines profit from her downward spiral, on Thursday issued her most disturbing and devastating tweet yet: That she was verbally, physically, and sexually abused by her father as a child. She issued multiple tweets and went into graphic detail, saying that he allegedly fondled himself in front of her and asked her for sex.

And then, with a single tweet, she took it all back, writing, "My dad never did any of those things The microchip in my brain made me say those things but he's the one that ordered them to microchip me."

Was Bynes abused as a child? We don't know, and it's possible that we might never know. I hope that Bynes seeks legal and mental help, regardless, as does her family. But the media will play no role in brokering any of those things -- all we will do, all we an can do, is report on the events as they unfold and create an environment that makes it easier for people to come forward with stories about abuse. I cannot imagine how hard it must be for Bynes to navigate the current gossip-driven media climate around her, and it's obviously taken a toll on her.

Bynes is 28, but her troubling behavior can be traced back to her early 20s, just when she was starting her transition into adulthood. Kudos to the teenagers with great support systems who seemed to figure out how to be a star and come into adulthood relatively grounded, like Elijah Wood, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and yes, even Miley Cyrus. And kudos to the ones who retire early, like "Mrs. Doubtfire" star Mara Wilson. It's reductive, of course, to attribute all of Bynes's current hardships to her child star status, especially when so many others have turned out well-adjusted. But there's a reason that successful child stars are seen as the exception, not the norm. Who could reasonably expect Britney Spears to be a functional adult when at 16 she was the world's No. 1 sex symbol?

Bynes's recent tweets are a reminder that we should apply some restraint when we too-enthusiastically write about the nasty meltdowns of other child stars "gone bad" because, as any Internet writer knows, reading the comments result in real pain. Pain that can make a troubled person far more troubled. Now imagine when those commenters aren't anonymous Internet trolls, but prominent media names, and the targets are impressionable kids. We were too hard on Amanda Bynes, but maybe we can be kinder to the next generation of child stars.

By Prachi Gupta

Prachi Gupta is an Assistant News Editor for Salon, focusing on pop culture. Follow her on Twitter at @prachigu or email her at

MORE FROM Prachi Gupta

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Amanda Bynes Child Stars Twitter