Sean Hannity believes this selectively edited video proves that Muslims hate America: “You see it on the tape!”

"Jaywalking" worked for Leno, why not for Islamophobes like Hannity too?

By Scott Eric Kaufman
June 3, 2015 5:44PM (UTC)
main article image

On Tuesday night's episode of "Hannity," the Fox News host interviewed documentary filmmaker Ami Horowitz, who tooled around Minneapolis doing a conservative version of Jay Leno's old "Jaywalking" routine -- only involving uninformed Muslims.

Hannity played a clip of Horowitz asking young, black Minnesotans whether they would rather live under American or Shariah law, and to a man they all answered that they would rather live under Shariah. "Sure," one man answered, "if you're a Muslim." Needless to say, no clips of a Muslim answering that he would rather live in a constitutional democracy made it into the segment -- but then again, Leno never included footage of ordinary Americans answering science questions correctly in his "Jaywalking" bit either.


Still, based on the "disturbing" footage Horowitz presented, Hannity brought on Robert Spencer -- Pam Geller's cohort -- and Imam Muhammad Ali Elahi of the Islamic House of Wisdom in Deerborn, Michigan to discuss the threat that these "jaywalking" Muslims pose to America.

Hannity asked Elahi why, if Muslims hate America and want to live under Shariah law, they're so eager to become American. "First let me say," the imam answered, "that it hurts me that as mainstream Muslims, we're caught between two forces of Islamophobia -- ignorance on one side, ISIS and the Taliban and extremism on the other." He likened these forces to "two tsunamis" that are providing victory for one another, but making it impossible for moderate Muslims to live in peace.

"Sean, please show some understanding," Elahi pleaded. "All this propaganda and exaggeration and generalization and assumptions!"


"But you see it on the tape!" Hannity shot back, before asking Spencer whether the United States should force immigrants to "assimilate, agree with American laws and American values."

"Absolutely," Spencer replied. "This used to be taken for granted among immigrants as a matter of course." He cited statistics that 80 percent of members of mosques in the United States believe that Shariah law is superior to American -- but he didn't provide similar statistics about the number of devout Christians, for example, who would prefer biblical law to constitutional governance.

When Elahi attempted to bring that to Spencer's attention, the founder of Jihad Watch just started shouting about "the grim realities of what happens in mosques," and pointed to the video played at the beginning of the segment as proof.


Watch the entire segment via Fox News below.

Scott Eric Kaufman

Scott Eric Kaufman is an assistant editor at Salon. He taught at a university, but then thought better of it. Follow him at @scottekaufman or email him at

MORE FROM Scott Eric KaufmanFOLLOW scottekaufmanLIKE Scott Eric Kaufman

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Ami Horowitz Islamaphobia Sean Hannity Video