Things keep going wrong for Shell's Arctic drilling plans

In the latest development, crew members discovered a hole in the hull of one of the oil giant's vessels

By Lindsay Abrams
Published July 7, 2015 11:30PM (UTC)
main article image
This aerial image provided by the U.S. Coast Guard shows the Royal Dutch Shell drilling rig Kulluk aground off a small island near Kodiak Island Tuesday, Jan. 1, 2013. No leak has been seen from the drilling ship that grounded off the island during a storm, officials said, as opponents criticized the growing race to explore the Arctic for energy resources. (AP Photo/U.S. Coast Guard)

Shell's Big Awesome Billion Dollar Arctic Drilling Adventure is not, so far, going exactly as planned. Crew members Friday discovered a hole -- 39 inches long, a bit less than half an inch thick -- in the hull of an ice-breaking vessel meant to protect its operations in the Chukchi Sea.

It's unclear what caused the damage -- NOAA is sending out a ship this week to the area where it was discovered to evaluate whether it encountered uncharted shallow water. It's not known, either, what the damage will mean for the oil giant's summer plans. The vessel in question, the MSV Fennica, is just one of the company's 29-boat fleet, but it's carrying a pretty vital piece of equipment: a capping stack that would be used to contain a spill in the event of a well blowout. (We all know from experience how important being prepared for that is.)

“Any impact to our season will ultimately depend on the extent of the damage,” said Shell spokesman Curtis Smith, adding that he doesn't believe operations will be delayed. But according to FuelFix, if the Fennica misses this season's brief drilling window, Shell will probably have to apply for a new permit with regulators at the Interior Department.

This isn't the only trouble Shell's run into as it prepares for the dangerous mission of drilling in Arctic waters -- and that's not even counting the falling price of oil or the Seattle activists protesting its every move. Last week, the federal government informed the company that its plan to drill two simultaneous exploratory wells in the Chukchi rain afoul of environmental protections for Pacific walruses and polar bears, meaning it'll have to cut down its activity by half. And while Shell's already committed about $1 billion to the project, it's still waiting on more federal permit to give it the final go-ahead.

Small mishaps aren't necessarily the making of an Arctic disaster: although the hole poses “an unfortunate potential setback,” Smith was at pains to emphasize, it “in no way does it characterize the preparations we have made to operate exceptionally well.” Heck, most of Shell's notorious 2012 catastrophe -- for which it was recently found to be entirely at fault -- was nowhere near as bad as it could have been. But incidents like this sure don't inspire confidence. As journalist McKenzie Funk, who wrote an e-book about the whole debacle, told Salon, the lessen to be learned from that is that in an environment as high-stakes as the Arctic, each little thing that goes wrong has the potential to escalate quickly to a situation that not even the most well-prepared contingency plan can account for. The drilling season may be short, but it's sure going to feel long from the perspective of those holding their breath.

Lindsay Abrams

MORE FROM Lindsay AbramsFOLLOW readingirl

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Arctic Drilling Oil And Gas Shell