Exploring two forms of devotion: Inside the secret life of a devout Christian dominatrix

On Saturday night I don latex and beat men with paddles. On Sunday morning I go to church. Are they much different?

By Sarah Francois
Published February 19, 2017 10:29PM (EST)
 (Illustrations by Kelsey Wroten)
(Illustrations by Kelsey Wroten)

This article originally appeared on Narratively.

Narratively When the worship music faded, I found myself in tears. I was certain that I didn’t belong in church. I sat in the balcony because I didn’t want to interact too much with other church members, lest they sense something was amiss. I wondered if anyone could tell from the hastiness of my dress that I’d spent the night before tying up dicks and caning men. I’d taken extra effort in changing. I so desperately wanted to avoid mixing my dominatrix clothes with my church clothes that I kept them in separate drawers. But they always seemed to tangle up. I was always at one place thinking about the other. My identity as a dominatrix was in conflict with my presence at a Sunday service. These things couldn’t stay separate in my mind.

Read more Narratively: "My Life Sentence of Shame"

A month before that Sunday, I had come across a matter-of-fact Craigslist ad that read “Koreatown Dungeon seeking dominatrix.” I was restless and uncomfortable in my skin, looking for something outside of myself, so I answered it. I was already a well-known submissive in BDSM circles from New York City to Colorado. I had spent nine months as a 24/7 sex slave in Colorado, submitting to a dominant married man who doted on me. My submission was a gift to both of us and it was almost a spiritual experience for me. I loved to give up control to my former master. I was proud to wear his collar — an actual jewelry-style chain that symbolized my devotion to him — and to be owned by him. He took good care of me. I needed to be taken care of at that time in my life and he was happy to take on the role.

Read more Narratively: "I Should’ve Swiped Left: Our Seven Best Stories About How Dating Is The Worst"

I’d recently flipped roles and started dabbling as a dominatrix as well, with a submissive of my own, and this experience gave me the confidence to respond to the ad. I’d even listed myself on Fetlife, the BDSM social network, as a switch (someone who could play both dominant and submissive roles).

Read more Narratively: "I Wanted to Be His Prized Possession"


When I arrived at the dungeon for my interview dressed from head-to-toe in faux leather, I was greeted by Amy, the office manager. She was wearing a T-shirt and dress pants, which surprised me — I’d expected a corset and heels, or something salacious. Instead, she looked plain, with shoulder length brown hair and an accent I couldn’t identify, maybe Russian. The place was listed in the building as a studio, but when I got to the floor there were two heavy wooden doors. When Amy gave me a tour, I saw that there were themed rooms. I really liked the room that was designed to look like a doctor’s workspace.

“What kind of things do you do with your submissive?” she asked.

“Impact play, sensual play,” I answered.

“What do you mean?”

“Spanking, nipple play.”

“Do you know how to do CBT?”

“No, I’m not really sure how to do cock and ball torture.”

“I guess we will show you. It’s fairly easy. We mostly use rope to tie the balls.”

The whole interview lasted no more than five questions. I was hired on the spot. Amy offered to introduce me to the other women, and the first thing I saw when I walked into the “Girls Lounging Room” was titties. One woman walked by me with her perky breasts out, in stockings and heels. She was headed to the full-length mirror that took up an entire wall of the room to apply makeup. When I recovered from the initial shock of the various states of undress around the room, I felt like I was home. My former master in Colorado was a nudist, and I’d spent most of my time at his home in the nude. When I saw the laid-back approach to nudity in the lounge, I knew I would like it there. Everyone was comfortable with their body. I struggled with my own body and it was a relief to see others so confident and uninhibited. If a woman with B-cups could walk around strutting her stuff, surely my triple-D’s could find some confidence. I had walked into a subculture I could call my own.

But my first week there, I worked four eight-hour shifts without a single client picking me, and four hours into another shift, around 1:10 a.m, I just started crying. Having several “meets,” which is what we called greeting clients, with not one of them choosing me, made me wonder if something was wrong with me. Amy reassured me that the first couple weeks were always rough. Clients came for the fantasy and sometimes their fantasies just didn’t include women of color. As a four-foot-ten black woman, my physical characteristics didn’t really scream dominatrix. But still, I was irritated that the white women had steady clients and the brown women were doing other work or sleeping in the lounging room just waiting for someone to be in the mood to pick them.

I took to being a dominatrix like it was a class. I gave myself homework. I took rope classes. I analyzed areas that I needed to work on. But I felt like I was a submissive in domme’s clothing. I wanted to be dominated, not to dominate. I realized I would much rather be the one being spanked than spanking. I had claimed to be a switch in the interview, but I am a submissive through and through. I am submissive even in my regular day-to-day activities; when the dental hygienist pulled my four wisdom teeth without anesthesia, I smiled because he said “good girl.” BDSM was a home for these feelings of wanting to worship other things and other people. I was on a deep search for meaning and I found it in the lifestyle. However, at work I was on the wrong side.

* * *

My friend Heidi is a churchgoer. One day after a particularly taxing shift at the dungeon I found a photo of her with her hands raised on Facebook. I was belligerent and angry about the Christian faith because of my upbringing; my father was a religious zealot and a pastor. I thought that church folk couldn’t possibly understand suffering, much less devotion. Heidi was 95 percent averse to me coming to church with her. The reluctance she showed was evident in her posture. I basically had to invite myself along because she knew I was sensitive and angry about church folk. I wanted to believe in something but I hated them – Christians, I mean. I cannot say what changed my mind about going to church. Like I was prone to switching in the lifestyle, perhaps I was just prone to changing my mind. Heidi was an amazing person and I trusted her. I felt like I could be honest with her about my life and she didn’t judge me. I figured if she could tolerate and embrace Christianity, surely I could give it a try.

I reached the threshold of this warehouse-like structure in Bushwick, Brooklyn, and I recoiled at all the smiling faces. The only indication that it was church and not a party was the folded sign on the floor in front of the warehouse that read “welcome.” I considered turning back, but it was too late. Heidi, the only woman there with a bright red Mohawk, had already spotted me and motioned for me to join her. The welcome team was in full socialization and greeting mode. The more people who said hi to me, the more I felt like nails were being driven into my skin. They didn’t know who I was. I couldn’t possibly belong there.

When people began to get up, jump up, dance and worship, I stood awkwardly with my hands at my sides. I couldn’t understand what I was doing at punk rock church. The strobe lights were in full swing and the words to the song “Grace Comes Like a Wave” were being projected onto the wall behind the band I refused to sing along to. At one point, I got tired of standing so I just sat down, which crystallized for those around me that I was definitely a visitor.

What finally got to me was a video of a member of the church telling her story. She told us about her struggles with heroin and how when she joined the church she felt unlovable, but Jesus changed her life. I remained skeptical, but then I noticed that the person on the screen was actually sitting in the row in front of me. She was doing that infernal smiling thing and she looked genuinely happy. She was white and had long curly hair, and when the official greeting time came she gave me a hug.

The devotion she showed in the video was something I could understand. I could understand worship; the idea of giving yourself entirely over to something. In the lifestyle, we had terms like foot worship and body worship, but the whole aspect of giving yourself up to another person just felt spiritual. As a submissive, I realized that my higher power was my dominant. This dominant became responsible for my wants and needs. In return, I gave the dominant my allegiance and my worship.


That first visit to church was not my last. I continued to go faithfully every Sunday. I enjoyed the laughter and the wholesome messages. I became a Christian. I was baptized by the pastor of this church at an evening service. I was being told that God wanted more for me and my life on a regular basis.

I also continued to work my shifts at the dungeon. My unhappiness with my work just ballooned because I was being told over and over, every Sunday, that I was the daughter of a king and deserved better. I also didn’t like the way I began to look at men. My job had changed my whole opinion of them. It warped my view. I saw all men as potential clients and I found it hard to respect them.

Could I reconcile my desires and my Christianity? I could still smell the fake leather and sweat from the night before when we, church members, hugged during service. I didn’t want to choose a side. Why couldn’t I be a Christian and a dominatrix? Surely, it could work. The sheer devotion that people show to Jesus as the lord of their life is comparable to the devotion I received as a dominatrix in the dungeon. It is the same devotion I show to a dominant I’m in service to. Devotion was what we had in common.

I still struggle with the question of to whom I should give my devotion. I gave up being a dominatrix but my submissive side is entrenched in my identity. Though some of these urges can be sublimated by church devotion, for me BDSM is unparalleled. I cannot simply take up jogging to get these needs met, nor pray harder. My Christianity interferes with my BDSM lifestyle but they still on some level coexist. I am devoted to submitting, whether to God or man I cannot say I know the difference. Someday, I hope I will.

Sarah Francois

MORE FROM Sarah Francois

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Christianity Dominatrix Narratively Religion Secret Life