The Olympic Games are a time for Americans to get together and cheer on the red, white and blue. And, in true unifying spirit, people online have united — a reaction to one sports reporter’s opinion that figure skating isn’t a sport.
“I have the utmost respect for figure skaters, only a few people in the universe can do it and they deserve my praise” tweeted Edward Egros, a weekend sports reporter in Dallas for KDFW-TV, Monday. “But it’s not a sport.”
THANK YOU! I have the utmost respect for figure skaters, only a few people in the universe can do it and they deserve my praise.
But it’s not a sport. https://t.co/SGw3KwGr7n
— Edward Egros (@EdWithSports) February 12, 2018
Egros, trying to clarify, described the sport as too “subjective,” saying instead it was an “art form.” Still, he added, it was “really hard.”
Those sports have quantifiable metrics that determine a winner. Figure skating is too subjective to have such things, so it’s an art form, not a sport. Still, figure skating is really hard
— Edward Egros (@EdWithSports) February 12, 2018
Olympians from various eras chimed in, including Team USA’s youngest member this Olympics, Vincent Zhou. The 17-year-old suggested Egros not comment on figure skating anymore since, you know, he’s a sports reporter and it’s apparently not a sport.
Your job is to be a sports reporter. Figure skating is not a sport to you. Stick to reporting on "real sports", do your job, and we'll do ours. https://t.co/y5IHypOC8h
— Vincent Zhou (@govincentzhou) February 13, 2018
Teammate Chris Knierim agreed.
You tell him Vincent!! pic.twitter.com/BWSm9tFCQ0
— Chris Knierim (@ChrisKnierim) February 13, 2018
And Gracie Gold, who competed with Team USA in the 2014 Games in Sochi, Russia, posted the definition of “sport” to dispel Egros’ claim. “Seems like skating is the definition of sport,” she said, “try to keep up.”
Seems like skating is the definition of sport. Athletes in this sport have to compete while looking hot af. Try to keep up 😘 pic.twitter.com/vqgV38sNy0
— Gracie Gold (@GraceEGold) February 13, 2018
But it wasn’t just U.S. Olympians. Canadian figure skater Jeffrey Buttle, who won bronze at the Olympics in Italy in 2006, questioned if this logic applied to all sports that “include any degree of subjectivity.” It’s an important question, as the legitimacy of figure skating is often signaled out, but not sports like diving, or as Buttle says, any sport that features decision-makers.
Does that logic apply to all of the “sports” that include any degree of subjectivity. Any sport with an umpire, a ref, or an adjudicator. I have seen so many bad calls, many result-impacting in hockey, soccer, American football, boxing, etc. Ur opinion is urs, I disagree w it.
— Jeffrey Buttle (@J_Butt) February 13, 2018
Egros doubled down and deflected.
You want some people to react vociferously on #Twitter without discussing controversial political takes?
Say figure skating isn’t a sport.
— Edward Egros (@EdWithSports) February 13, 2018
Rather than an apology, he added that he’s said far “worst things.”
That doesn’t even rank in the Top 10,000 of worst things I’ve said/done https://t.co/Zat8TRE2L4
— Edward Egros (@EdWithSports) February 13, 2018
Judges?