Help keep Salon independent

American Eagle defends “Great Jeans” campaign after backlash

American Eagle says its "Great Jeans" ad is about denim, not genetics, after a week of online controversy

Weekend Editor

Published

An American Eagle store window features the brand’s “Great Jeans” campaign with Sydney Sweeney, which has drawn both praise and criticism online. (Michael M. Santiago / Getty Images)
An American Eagle store window features the brand’s “Great Jeans” campaign with Sydney Sweeney, which has drawn both praise and criticism online. (Michael M. Santiago / Getty Images)

American Eagle is standing by its fall denim campaign starring Euphoria and Anyone But You star Sydney Sweeney after a wave of criticism accused the ads of leaning into racially coded language and imagery.

The campaign hinges on a pun: Sweeney talks about inherited traits before a male voiceover says, “Sydney Sweeney has great jeans.”

In some ads, “genes” is crossed out and replaced with “jeans.” What AE framed as playful wordplay struck a nerve with critics, who argued it echoed historic eugenics rhetoric, particularly given the ad’s focus on her physical appearance like her blond hair and blue eyes.

Social media reaction was swift, with detractors calling it “tone‑deaf” and “Nazi‑coded,” while supporters, especially conservative commentators, praised the joke and dismissed the outrage as performative.

On Friday, American Eagle posted a statement to Instagram defending the campaign: “This is about the jeans. Her jeans. Her story,” the company wrote, adding, “Great jeans look good on everyone.” The retailer noted that proceeds from Sweeney’s campaign will go to Crisis Text Line to help victims of domestic violence.

Sweeney herself has stayed silent. Still, the uproar has boosted visibility for the brand, driving spikes in online engagement and even a reported uptick in AE’s stock price — suggesting that in the culture‑war economy, controversy can be as valuable as the clothes themselves.

By CK Smith

CK Smith is Salon's weekend editor.

MORE FROM CK Smith

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Related Articles