Basketball
Donaghy sentencing: The NBA still snoozes
The league should use the "rogue" ref as an opportunity to overhaul its officiating. But the commissioner says everything's fine.
Update: Tim Donaghy was sentenced Tuesday to 15 months in prison for taking money from gamblers in exchange for inside information about games. U.S. District Court Judge Carol Amon could have sentenced him to a maximum of 33 months.
Some fans will probably be shocked at what they’ll perceive to be such a short sentence. Coverage of the Donaghy scandal made it seem like the crime of the century, but in the scheme of things, Donaghy’s little gambling ring was pretty small stuff.
This happens with sports scandals. People were shocked at the seemingly light sentence BALCO founder Victor Conte got because saturation coverage of the affair made it seem like Conte was Pablo Escobar and Al Capone rolled into one when he was really just a small-time hustler with a famous clientele.
There will no doubt be much talk of how Donaghy’s sentencing — which follows by a few days the shipping off of his codefendants, James Battista and Thomas Martino, for a little over a year — closes a sad chapter for the NBA. The NBA will probably be doing most of that talking. Let’s all hurry up and forget about Tim Donaghy, everybody.
Commissioner David Stern has insisted from the beginning that Donaghy was a rogue bad guy, that NBA officials are the most scrutinized employees on the planet and that there are no systemic problems with NBA officiating.
That’s something NBA fans can believe if they choose, or they can believe their lying eyes.
ESPN legal analyst Lester Munson made an excellent point in a Monday column, writing that “the NBA must be concerned about the incredible success” Donaghy had in predicting the outcome of NBA games — he hit 37 out of 47 — with the inside information he had as a referee.
That’s because that inside information, according to prosecutors, was limited to the identities of the officiating crews, the relationships between those officials and players on the teams and some information about players’ physical condition.
Maybe it’s a small sample size and Donaghy got lucky. And maybe an expert can say, “Tell me who’s officiating the game and I can tell you which team will win four times out of five,” which is a pretty good prediction rate. Pick 47 games next year and try it yourself.
Stern and the NBA should treat Donaghy’s sentencing as a beginning, not an ending. The league should use the end of the Donaghy affair as an opportunity to completely overhaul its officiating. Everything should be on the table. How officials are hired, trained, evaluated, assigned, rewarded and punished. How the rule book is written and interpreted. How the league deals with officiating controversies.
There should be more openness and more clarity. Officials should be made available to the press to answer for their calls after games. Coaches shouldn’t be fined for daring to criticize the refs. The rules should be simplified or changed as necessary to remove the elements that create the perception that there are different standards for different players, or that enforcement of the rules is essentially random. That way it should be easier to see if a referee is slanting his calls toward one team or the other.
The NBA has been pretending for too long that it doesn’t have a problem here, that its real problems have been so-called thuggish behavior or too much hip-hop style. Tim Donaghy should be a wake-up call. Any comments by Stern or his lieutenants that it’s time to put this scandal behind us and move on are a sign that the NBA is still sleeping.
King Kaufman is a senior writer for Salon. You can e-mail him at king at salon dot com. Facebook / Twitter / Tumblr More King Kaufman.
The futile search for meaning in “Linsanity”
Real fans aren't shocked at the sight of an Asian-American star. The hype is just New York being New York
(Credit: Reuters/Eduardo Munoz) About two weeks ago, my son asked me how a team with an imposing lineup like the New York Knicks could possibly have a losing record. “Because they have no point guard,” I said. They played like strangers. Either nobody wanted the ball or everybody did. Long intervals would pass without the Knicks putting up a decent shot — although being NBA players they often made enough bad ones to stay close.
Well, as the world knows, they have a point guard now. The feel-good story of Jeremy Lin, the underdog Chinese-American player from Harvard, has made NBA fans of millions who scarcely know the 24-second clock from a goaltending call. Here’s hoping they stick around, because it’s a heck of a show. Meanwhile, how about if we dialed down the ethnic sensitivity meter until the kid settles in?
Continue Reading CloseArkansas Times columnist Gene Lyons is a National Magazine Award winner and co-author of "The Hunting of the President" (St. Martin's Press, 2000). You can e-mail Lyons at eugenelyons2@yahoo.com. More Gene Lyons.
What everyone gets wrong about Jeremy Lin
The NBA star does not transcend race. Instead of upending stereotypes, he owns them -- unapologetically
Jeremy Lin (Credit: Reuters/Adam Hunger) Last week, I wrote a Salon essay about my experiences with racial bullying growing up in northern Minnesota; particularly, a pair of girls who decided to sing “ching-ching-a-ling” and pull their eyes into slits when they saw me in seventh-grade gym class. It was painful to write, and — from the responses I received — pretty painful to read, especially by anyone who had experienced bullying. Thus, it felt almost as if counteracting forces in the universe were acting to promote Jeremy Lin’s farm-team-to-bench-to-global-superstar ascent in the basketball world. Finally! Being Asian American was cool, not something to be bullied over.
Continue Reading CloseMarie Myung-Ok Lee’s essays have appeared in The New York Times, The Atlantic, The Guardian, The Washington Post, and she is regular contributor to Slate. She is the author of the novel Somebody’s Daughter and teaches creative writing at Brown University. Find her on Twitter @MarieMyungOkLee and on Facebook. More Marie Myung-Ok Lee.
David Brooks: “I have heard of Jeremy Lin”
Is it an "anomaly" for a professional athlete to be religious? (No)
David Brooks David Brooks had to write a column about something, and his deadline was fast approaching, so he glanced at the sports page and saw something about New York Knicks phenom Jeremy Lin, and he was like, yeah, that works. Next stop, most-emailed list!
Lin is a point guard who rocketed to near-instant celebrity when he came off the bench and had a series of monster games, dragging the Knicks to a .500 record while their two biggest superstars were sitting out games. His celebrity then became a “mania” in part because he’s Asian-American and a Harvard graduate, two rarities in the NBA. It also obviously doesn’t hurt that he plays for the dominant team in the nation’s biggest media market (also it’s the fallow period between football and baseball). That’s basically the whole deal, and if you’d like to learn more read Andrew Leonard’s account of the early social media explosion and Alexander Chee’s take on Lin and Asian-American identity. Whatever you do, don’t read David Brooks’ take on the Lin phenomenon, because David Brooks doesn’t understand basketball or social media or race or religion or American society in general.
Continue Reading Close
Alex Pareene writes about politics for Salon and is the author of "The Rude Guide to Mitt." Email him at apareene@salon.com and follow him on Twitter @pareene More Alex Pareene.
Rooting for your own kind
Jeremy Lin shows that we like to cheer for people who look like us -- and there's nothing wrong with that
Why so excited? (Credit: Reuters/Mike Cassese) Lin-sanity has broken out all over the world. The kid nobody in the NBA wanted, from an ethnic group about as associated with the NBA as bullfighters are with People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, had just broken Shaquille O’Neal’s league record for the most points in his first five games as a starter. Adoring fans are holding up signs saying “To Lin-finity and beyond.” The Lin-ternet has broken under the strain of millions of tweets, many of them featuring even worse puns than “Lin-ternet.” Sports Illustrated put him on its cover.
Continue Reading CloseGary Kamiya is a Salon contributing writer. More Gary Kamiya.
The Jeremy Lin show
America's conversation about race has been mostly black and white. An amazing Knicks point guard changed that
Fans of Jeremy Lin hold up signs during the second half of the New York Knicks/Toronto Raptors game on Tuesday. (Credit: Reuters/Mike Cassese) I have never cared about basketball, ever. Not once. Yet inside of the last two weeks I have learned what a point guard is, what he does and why it matters. I had a roller-coaster night Saturday, when I wanted to watch a New York Knicks game for the first time, then learned that a squabble between Madison Square Garden and Time Warner has left about 1 million fans without MSG Channel (including me). I didn’t even know how to start finding a bar with the game on — something I’ve previously resented, in fact — so I contented myself by watching the video diaries on Lin’s YouTube channel.
Alexander Chee's essays have appeared at The Paris Review Daily, The Morning News, n+1 and Granta. He is the author of the novel Edinburgh and the forthcoming The Queen of the Night. Find him on Twitter @alexanderchee, on Facebook, or at his blog, Koreanish. More Alexander Chee.
Page 1 of 42 in Basketball
