Internet Culture
The case that could end cyberbullying
An ex-model wins the right to learn the identity of her YouTube trolls. What does this mean for Internet privacy?
Carla Franklin Hey, anonymous online bullies, you may not be as anonymous as you think. On Friday, a New York judge ordered Google to reveal the identity of the troll who called Carla Franklin a whore on YouTube. This development is, depending on how you view these things, likely either the end of privacy or a blow for accountability. Actually, it’s both.
Back in August, Franklin discovered that videos she appeared in while studying at Columbia Business School had made it to the university’s YouTube channel, where a commenter who went by “JoeBloom08,” JimmyJean008″ and “greyspector09″ repeatedly called her a whore and posted unauthorized clips from a movie she appeared in during her modeling days.
Franklin is far from the first person ever to get flamed on the Internet, but she’s among a small handful to fight back via the legal system. In 2009, model Liskula Cohen sued Google to reveal the identity of the person behind a “Skanks in NYC” blog that called her, among other things, an “old hag” and “a psychotic, lying whore” — and won. And Broadway actor Marty Thomas filed papers last week to demand Twitter reveal the person behind the @bwayanonymous gossip blog for saying he had picked up an STD from another performer.
Perhaps the most depressing aspect of all these stories is their familiarity. When I spoke last week at a New York Press Club panel, I mentioned how useful social media is for building a real community of conversation and collaboration. I also mentioned the death threats, rape threats, and regular torrent of insults and abuse I’ve become accustomed to as part and parcel of living a life online. And since I revealed my cancer diagnosis two months ago, I’ve received a deluge of love and support. I’ve also had a few incredibly explicit messages from people celebrating what they hope will be my imminent demise — at least one of which has involved necrophilia. Most of us who blog or have YouTube channels are used to this sort thing. And there’s something incredibly sad about how casually many of us take it for granted that the price of the Net nation is a fair share of ugly verbal abuse. So maybe it’s time for the people who aren’t bullies to stand up and say that’s unacceptable.
While Cohen’s and now Franklin’s victories may serve as a warning to other anonymous critics, it can be hard for a hater to change spots. When the Skanks in NYC creator was revealed to be FIT student Rosemary Port, Port told The Daily News, “By going to the press, she defamed herself. I feel my right to privacy has been violated.” She then announced her own plans to sue Google for breaching her privacy. Does Port have a point? After all, if you can’t anonymously call someone, by name, “a psychotic, lying whore” on the Internet, what is the Internet good for anyway? But even for those who don’t spend their days secretly trashing people online, the question of privacy – and exactly how easily Google or Facebook or Twitter might reveal our personal information — can be downright chilling.
The openness of online discussion, the freedom to ask questions, to express concerns, to air opinions that can’t be expressed anywhere else — these things are worth protecting. Conversely, bullies don’t always need to hide behind a cloak of secrecy. Before killing himself, Rutgers student Tyler Clementi almost assuredly posted anonymously for help on a gay support board. His roommate Dharun Ravi, meanwhile, felt no such need for disguise, freely using his real name Twitter account to mock Clementi.
Franklin has said she didn’t press her suit to make money – she did it to make a point. She says that she has been “been dealing with ongoing obsessive and harassing behavior since 2006.” Her lawyer has said they suspect they already know who is behind the posts, but need the evidence to move forward in stopping the abuse.
The National Conference of State Legislatures notes, “Forty-seven states now have laws that explicitly include electronic forms of communication within stalking or harassment laws.” Flaming isn’t always just good clean fun. It can escalate into the personal, specific and, subsequently, illegal and unprotected. And then, bullies, you’re on your own. As Franklin says, “The internet should not become an anonymous place for harassers to hide. Criminal behavior is not protected by the First Amendment.”
If you can’t tell the difference, maybe you should think twice before clicking the “send” button. Because the person you’re defaming from a comfortable spot behind a computer screen might just take a notion to ask Google to pull back the curtain. And if a court agrees, you’re in for a world of flaming yourself, pal.
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
“Tubes”: What the Internet is made of
If you think your data lives in the cloud and flies through the air, you're wrong
Andrew Blum The title of Andrew Blum’s “Tubes: A Journey to the Center of the Internet” is a ricocheting joke. When Alaskan Sen. Ted Stevens described the Internet as a “series of tubes” back in 2006, he was roundly mocked for not understanding the online world despite being chairman of the Commerce, Science and Transportation Committee and therefore instrumental in overseeing it. Stevens may not have known what he was talking about, Blum (a correspondent for Wired magazine) acknowledges, but he wasn’t wrong, either. In writing this account of “the Internet’s physical infrastructure,” Blum found that “one thing [the Internet] most certainly is, nearly everywhere, is, in fact, a series of tubes.”
Continue Reading Close
Laura Miller is a senior writer for Salon. She is the author of "The Magician's Book: A Skeptic's Adventures in Narnia" and has a Web site, magiciansbook.com. More Laura Miller.
Internet doomsday, explained
According to media reports, July 9 will be our online apocalypse. The better story is how this crazy rumor started
The apocalyptic story line was once reserved for truly apocalyptic events. Nuclear war. The return of Christ. Environmental or economic collapse. But it’s 2012, and the apocalypse has become the basis for everything from Super Bowl commercials to summer romantic comedies – and no media story is too small to have an apocalyptic moniker attached to it. (Remember Snowmageddon?) If you want to get the world’s attention, simply proclaim that the world will soon end — or the Internet. Just read coverage of the so-called Internet Doomsday virus, which will supposedly strike and shut down the Web on July 9.
Continue Reading CloseMathew Gross is considered one of America's top new-media strategists. Together with Mel Gilles he is the author of "The Last Myth". More Mathew Gross.
Mel Gilles is a writer and a former advocate for victims of domestic abuse. Her essay, "The Politics of Victimization," went viral in 2004, reaching more than 2 million readers. More Mel Gilles.
Nobody ever calls me anymore
I feel like the last person who still likes talking on the phone. Why did we give it up, and should we reconsider?
(Credit: Anatema via Shutterstock) As a teenager, my friend Jennifer used to sneak into her mother’s room after bedtime and steal the phone. She would call the boy she was dating, or “going with,” or whatever we called it back then, and they would talk all night, sometimes till 4 a.m.
But something shifted a few years ago. She became afraid of talking on the phone. Just hearing it ring could provoke panic. Maybe it was the suffocation of carrying her cellphone all day long. (“There are these tentacles in you all the time,” she said.) But she rarely answered the phone, preferring to text message, and the voice mail piled up like unopened bills dumped in a desk drawer – frightening and unknown and ever present — until she couldn’t bear it anymore, and in a rush of guilt she would delete dozens of messages that had been left for her without even listening to them.
Continue Reading CloseSarah Hepola is an editor at Salon. More Sarah Hepola.
Who owns the cloud?
Google claims users retain intellectual property rights, but the terms of service tell a more complex story
(Credit: winul via Shutterstock) When you hear the phrase “property rights,” you probably think of farmers fighting environmental regulators and homeowners arguing with oil drillers. But in the Information Age, you should also be thinking about your computer – and asking, how much of you is really yours? It’s not a navel-gazing rumination from a college Intro to Existentialism class – it’s an increasingly pressing question in the brave new world of social networking and cloud computing.
Last week’s big technology announcement spotlighted the thorny issue. As the Los Angeles Times reported, Google’s announcement of its “Google Drive” came with the promise that users will “retain ownership of any intellectual property rights that you hold in that content.” But when you save files to Google’s new hard-drive folder in the cloud, the terms of service you are required to agree to gives Google “a worldwide license to use, host, store, reproduce, modify, create derivative works, communicate, publish, publicly perform, publicly display and distribute (your) content” as the company sees fit.
Continue Reading Close
David Sirota is a best-selling author of the new book "Back to Our Future: How the 1980s Explain the World We Live In Now." He hosts the morning show on AM760 in Colorado. E-mail him at ds@davidsirota.com, follow him on Twitter @davidsirota or visit his website at www.davidsirota.com. More David Sirota.
Lessons of a baby bucket list
Avery Lynn Canahuati accomplished a lot in her six months of life. Imagine what the rest of us can do in a lifetime
Avery Lynn Canahuati (Credit: http://averycan.blogspot.com/) What have you accomplished since November? What dreams have you fulfilled? In that time, Avery Lynn Canahuati threw out the first pitch at a baseball game, got a letter from the president and dressed up like a troll doll. She experienced deep love, and changed the lives of her family and friends. And that’s just what Canahuati got done in the first six months of her life. They were also the last.
Canahuati was born in Texas on Nov. 11. This past Good Friday, she was diagnosed with spinal muscular atrophy (SMA), a group of rare neuromuscular diseases that, in her case, were terminal. “We asked our doctors specifically if there is anything. Is there trial drugs, anything out of the country?” her mother, Linda, told CNN this week. So after “sitting around for two days crying and being devastated, since there is no cure and there is nothing we can do,” her father, Mike, decided to make the most of what was left of his daughter’s cruelly brief expected lifespan. Writing in Avery’s voice, he created a blog — and set a few goals.
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
Page 1 of 55 in Internet Culture