Star Wars
George Lucas loses Stormtrooper helmet battle
How one of the most litigious directors in Hollywood found himself on the wrong side of copyright law
A Stormtrooper helmet from "Star Wars." (Note: I am going to try to refrain from any “Star Wars” jokes, analogies, or metaphors during this piece. Let’s see if it works!)
George Lucas has held tightly to the merchandizing rights of his “Star Wars” franchise, making him both one of the savviest businessmen in sci-fi, as well as one of the most pesky. Seriously, his company Lucasfilm has no qualms over suing even the small fries for copyright infringement, setting a record for petty intellectual property cases while he’s at it. Juggernaut that it is, Lucasfilm usually wins. After all, the force … er … law is on their side: Lucas created the characters and the world they inhabit, and anyone who uses even a likeness of Yoda without his permission is technically in violation of intellectual property rights.
But he doesn’t always win: Even Lucas wasn’t able to convince the courts that Ronald Reagan’s Strategic Defense Initiative’s “Operation: Star Wars” counted as copyright infringement. They also lost a case in 2001 trying to prohibit the release of the porno film “Star Ballz” on the grounds that people would confuse the two films.
Today is another blow for Lucasfilm, as a British Supreme Court ruling has decided to give a former prop designer the rights to make and distribute replicas of the iconic Stormtrooper helmet. In 2004, Lucasfilm sued Andrew Ainsworth, who created the original item for the films, after one of his helmets sold for $60,000 at a Christie’s auction. George Lucas’ legal team claimed Ainsworth owed $20 million for making the replicas without holding the intellectual property rights, and a U.S. judge agreed.
Luckily for Ainsworth, he didn’t live in the U.S., and the case has taken five years to plod over to England to be re-tried. This time, the judges have not ruled in favor of the mighty emp …. of LucasFilm LTD., and today’s Supreme Court ruling allows Ainsworth to make his little white helmets in peace.
But don’t think that means you can start making money off your unauthorized “Star Wars” expanded universe comics just yet: the reason the British courts ruled in Ainsworth’s favor wasn’t because they thought George Lucas was being a jerk. It was an issue of art vs. function — if the helmets had been deemed to be an artistic sculpture, Lucas would have retained rights. But the Supreme Court upheld the lower courts’ rulings that the helmets were props, not art, the copyright laws for which expire 15 years from their marketing date.
Lucas and his supporters have called this ruling “an anomaly of British copyright law” and announced that they still plan to go after any fan who even thinks about making any money off the “Star Wars” franchise. But at least in this instance we can cheer the little guy who managed to win against Lucas’ Goliath and prove that it really is true what they say: “Size matters not.”
Damn! So, close.
Drew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
Trust me on this: “Star Wars”
A New York Mets all-star explains how he plans to pass the power of the Force on to his son. First in a new series
(Credit: Shutterstock/Salon) I saw “Star Wars” on VHS originally when I was 6. I was just captivated. I would come home every day after school, and before I would do my homework, I would pop it in and watch it, because I was largely alone. Both my parents worked. I remember the play button being green, the pause button was red, and the way the top would pop up and you’d slide the tape in and clank it down. And I remember knowing every line.
As I grew, I began to see “Star Wars” as a metaphor for so much – whether it was the natural depravity of man, or the redemption of man, or the relationship between a father and a son in Luke Skywalker and Darth Vader. That relationship can be broken and redeemed over the course of the trilogy. I really related and connected with it, and it encapsulated a lot of what I want to teach my children – people make mistakes, and they can ultimately be redeemed, even if those mistakes seem egregious, you know, in Darth Vader’s case. That there is a choice to be made between what side you choose in life. Our faith is a big part of our family, so the Force has special meaning for me. There’s just so many things that I think my son would get, that I hope my son would get.
Continue Reading CloseR.A. Dickey is a starting pitcher for the New York Mets and author of the memoir "Wherever I Wind Up: My Quest for Truth, Authenticity and the Perfect Knuckleball" More R.A. Dickey.
“Star Wars” like you’ve never seen it before
A new spin on a beloved classic finds its way onto YouTube -- and reminds us of the power of the Internet VIDEO
There are a few great universal truths. People love “Star Wars.” People love making videos. (Just ask the Star Wars Kid.) When in 2009, Vimeo developer Casey Pugh challenged fans to “remake ‘Star Wars: A New Hope’ into a fan film, 15 seconds at a time,” he got an outpouring of beautiful animated sequences, stop-motion extravaganzas, and a lot of people in their living rooms, wearing hoodies. So many hoodies. The final product became “Star Wars Uncut,” an addictively compelling low-fi reimagining of the classic that went on to win a 2010 Emmy for interactive media, besting websites for “Glee” and “Dexter.”
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
What Occupy can learn from the Hunger Games
A leaderless political movement still trying to find its place might look to heroes of dystopian fiction for ideas
(Credit: AP) “YOU CAN’T EVICT AN IDEA,” proclaim the banners fronting an otherwise dull building in east London, owned by banking giant UBS but inhabited and decorated by squatters from the Occupy movement. They’ve adapted the phrase from Alan Moore and David Lloyd’s graphic novel “V for Vendetta,” in which the titular terrorist explains his seeming immortality to a detective who has just shot him: “Ideas are bulletproof.” A poster of V’s trademark Guy Fawkes mask smiles eerily at all who walk into the foyer of 8 Sun Street, now dubbed “The Bank of Ideas” and used as a community center. The caption underneath reads, “We are the 99%, and so are you.”
Continue Reading CloseToday’s must-see viral videos
Watch: James Spader's first promo for "The Office," a "Star Wars" porn parody that's funny, and Lopez's monologue
A porn parody that's more parody than porn?
1. Paul Rudd is your bad marketing idea man:
Even though “My Idiot Brother” looks kind of terrible, I will watch Paul Rudd do basically anything.
Sorry America, the Rudd backlash hasn’t begun in my heart quite yet.
2. Chris Crocker needs your money for a documentary:
Come on, you guys remember Chris Crocker right? He’s the “Leave Britney alone!” guy. Anyway, here’s his Kickstarter project for a feature film.
Continue Reading CloseDrew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
“Star Wars” with street cred
Slide show: We talk to artist Nicholas Hyde about George Lucas' influence on contemporary graphics culture
Is there a law on the Internet that says that for every original idea, someone has probably done a “Star Wars” parody of it? There should be. For a story that’s been around for over 30 years, the iconic characters of George Lucas’ films always find ways to appear in the most unlikely of places: in musicals, riding bikes, even in rap music.
Continue Reading CloseDrew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
Page 1 of 16 in Star Wars