Why I quit the mainstream media
Journalism must break the chains of objectivity and report truth -- and the Occupy movement led me to do just that
Natasha Lennard FollowTopics: Occupy Wall Street, Media Criticism, Life News, News, Politics News
Protesters sit with arms linked on New York's Brooklyn Bridge before police began making arrests on Oct. 1 and author Natasha Lennard. I was in complete agreement when, last month, the triumvirate of right-wing firebrands Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck and Andrew Breitbart all condemned me for being more than just a journalist. They are correct, and I agree with every pundit who argues that I have no place in the mainstream media.
On Oct. 14, I appeared on a panel at the radical, feminist Blue Stockings bookstore in New York’s Lower East Side. Hosted by Jacobin Magazine, the discussion addressed left-wing politics and strategy. During the event, I criticized old-left styles of organizing and praised — with some ardor — the experimental nature of Occupy Wall Street. I also dropped “F-bombs” in abundance.
Stumbling out of the bookstore onto Allen Street after the debate, I hugged an old friend, who has been heavily committed to Occupy activities in New York. “I think I just watched you lose your job,” he said.
“I know,” I replied, with a smile.
The job he was referring to was a sporadic freelance gig with the New York Times. I had contributed in previous weeks to its Occupy Wall Street coverage and, notably, I had been arrested while reporting on the Brooklyn Bridge.
A video of my appearance on the panel was picked up by a reporter at Andrew Breitbart’s Big Government, and the fallout led to the Times publicly stating that they had “no plans” to use me for future OWS coverage. (Although I had already pulled away from reporting for the Times on the issue, having decided only days before the debate that I would rather take an opinionated stance.)
As the Times publicly noted, they found no problem with any of the reporting I had done for them on OWS. Indeed, a court hearing upheld that I had been on the Brooklyn Bridge as a professional journalist and as such, deserved to have the disorderly conduct charge against me dismissed. The only reason I was on the Brooklyn Bridge that day was as a reporter, gathering and relaying information on what I saw, and nothing else. However, as has become clear, if I — or any other journalist — want to express a strong opinion on a political matter, I cannot contemporaneously report for a mainstream publication.
In my view, it now makes little sense to be objective about Occupy Wall Street and its various, amorphous iterations across the country. As Matt Taibbi wrote recently in Rolling Stone about learning to love OWS: “People don’t know exactly what they want, but as one friend of mine put it, they know one thing: FUCK THIS SHIT! We want something different: a different life, with different values, or at least a chance at different values.”
You Might Also Like
If the diffuse and experimental disruptions, discussions, assemblies, occupations, strikes, marches, chants and more that constitute OWS are primarily coherent only in so far as they agree that the current status quo, rife with inequity and cruelty, is wrong — I cannot but consider myself in agreement. As such, it would be disingenuous to play the “objective reporter.”
I am incredibly lucky to have interned and worked for institutions like the New York Times and Politico; the training, exposure and practice that these publications offer are in many ways unparalleled. But it is also with some pride that I have stopped writing for publications that aim for journalistic objectivity.
There is a loose analogy here with how Occupy Wall Street’s structure stands at odds with mainstream, electoral politics. Many of those involved in Occupy Wall Street have, with excellent cause, expressed dissatisfaction with representative politics in this country. In response, occupiers have sought new political spaces and interactions; they have taken politics into their own hands.
Similarly, if the mainstream media prides itself on reporting the facts, I have found too many problems with what does or does not get to be a fact — or what rises to the level of a fact they believe to be worth reporting — to be part of such a machine. Going forward, I want to take responsibility for my voice and the facts that I choose and relay. I want them to instigate change.
Breitbart, Beck and friends are correct in saying I’m more than just a journalist. They are wrong in saying I’m an activist – that means something specific, in my mind. But if by “more” they mean I am a journalist in agreement with those across the country who think “Fuck this shit” when it comes to a system upholding inequality and alienation for all but a few, then they are right. This — and my proclivity for dropping “F-bombs,” once again — is the reason the mainstream media and I have parted ways.
You Might Also Like
More Related Stories
-
How not to say "I'm sorry": 2016 is already full of weak apologies, from the dumbest answer to #WheresRey to "sometimes we can get it wrong"
-
Obama breaks twenty-year lull on gun legislation: A look back at gun control history
-
Justin Bieber wasn't the first and he won't be the last: White celebrities just can't stop getting cornrows
-
Clinton marriage mystique: How their partnership went from liability to asset — especially for younger voters
-
Still coddling the "affluenza teen": Ethan Couch's team confuses human rights with comfort
-
Jaden Smith and his gender fluid style slay in the latest Louis Vuitton ad
-
Chemistry geeks, rejoice! 4 new elements were just added to the periodic table
-
“Would we even be here if Julian Acox was white?” Race, self-defense and making of a murder charge
-
The NRA is backing terrorism: Wingnuts and "patriots" are the real safety threat we should fear
-
"Tequila crazy" and "martini maudlin": Do different kinds of alcohol give us a different buzz?
-
The psychopath in your office: How ruthlessness, risk and narcissism pay off at work
-
"He is the man you thought you knew": Will Camille Cosby continue to defend husband Bill Cosby under oath?
-
"My career and life do not deserve to be taken away": A comedian responds to abuse allegations from women — and makes it all about him
-
You really can't peel yourself away from "Making a Murderer": The twisted psychology behind binge-watching
-
Bill Cosby’s arrest is just the beginning: Prosecuting rape and the long, difficult road to justice
-
5 insane ways female sexual desire was once suppressed
-
#YallQaeda and #VanillaISIS: When can we call the Oregon standoff domestic terrorism?
-
NYC subway ad icon Dr. Zizmor retires: In the YouTube era, the local pitchman inches closer to extinction
-
Camille Cosby's denial: How long can she continue to stand by her man?
-
Donald Trump has made us all a**holes: How 2016 has coarsened us all into Fox News jerks
-
DuPont's deadly deceit: The decades-long cover-up behind the "world's most slippery material"
Featured Slide Shows
- Share on Twitter
- Share on Facebook
- 1 of 13
- Close
- Fullscreen
- Thumbnails
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
- Previous
- Next
-
Recent Slide Shows
-
Blood moon magic: 17 amazing images of the supermoon around the world
-
"Dick Cheney watches television": The four previously unseen 9/11 photos that will make you hate the evil VP all over again
-
Heartbreaking images from Sandra Bland's funeral
-
Must-see photos: Never-before seen images inside the White House on September 11
-
The best series finales ever
-
When marriage is an act of political protest
-
Photos from the Happy Ending Salon
-
Make Summer More Poetic with These 10 International Works
Related Videos
Most Read
From Around the Web
Presented by Zergnet
-
Professor Threatened With Firing Says Wheaton College Is Changing The Rules
-
More Than 100 Lawyers Tell The Supreme Court Why Their Abortions Mattered
-
There's Something Critical Missing In The Fight For A $15 Minimum Wage
-
Congress Votes Yet Again To Defund Planned Parenthood
-
The Bigger the Lie the More People Believe It
-
Tennis legend Andre Agassi is trying to teach kids to read in a new, very fascinating way.
-
How a year of storms and drought has changed one child's education.
-
Sharks. Living inside a volcano. If this was a movie, it'd be 'Shark-cano.' But it's real.
-
Melissa Harris-Perry has a great point about Oprah’s new weight loss ad.
-
Does some anxiety stem from greater intelligence?




Comments
0 Comments