No, Brazilian riots are not an “overreaction” to fare hikes

New York Magazine's Daily Intel grossly misses context of fighting back against neoliberal hegemony

Topics: New York Magazine, Brazil, Sao Paulo, Protests, Riots, fare hikes, neoliberalism, ,

If there are burning barricades, crowds amassing across cities hundreds of thousands-strong, fights with riot police that leave protesters hospitalized, eyes streaming with tear gas, I can promise you one thing: It’s never just “about” one thing.

For the past two weeks, Brazil — first Sao Paulo and now Rio too — has been ablaze with protest and riots, which both have everything and very little to do with the raising of public transportation fare from BRL 3.00 to BRL 3.20 which went into effect on June 6. Angry Paulistanos threatened to shut the city down — and they did.

Dan Amira —  a writer I usually like at New York’s Daily Intel — grossly patronized the Brazilian situation with a post showing images of Brazilians smashing windows and starting fires, titled “17 Photos of Brazilians Overreacting to a Nine-Cent Fare Hike.” Amira gives the Brazilians the credit to say that it’s not “just”about the fare hike but “the government’s priorities in general.” Here’s the paragraph that hit me like a police baton to the stomach:

We get it. That seems kind of annoying. Still, some Brazilians have gone beyond chanting and waving signs to outright rioting. Again, the impetus here was a nine-cent increase in the cost of a bus ticket. If New Yorkers responded like this every time the MTA raised fares, the city would be a smoldering pile of rubble by now.

You Might Also Like

Think of this, perhaps, Dan: Brazil’s military dictatorship only ended in 1985. It’s worth considering that the masses, pouring into Brazil’s streets and squares now, know creeping authoritarianism when they see it. Perhaps they know when enough is enough — when a fare hike is just another element tacked on through vectors like the World Cup and the Olympics — and neoliberal hegemony is taking hold. Perhaps it’s too late for us. Dan is right — New Yorkers do not respond this way when the MTA raises fares for the benefit of Wall Street (not MTA workers, as has been shown). We can look at Brazil and Turkey and ask why protesters are starting fires and enduring tear gas over a fare hike or some trees in a square. Or we could take seriously their and our context — our own lives, pains, fears, debts, constant surveilled communications and diminished liberties; our racist policing tactics, our overflowing private prisons. Amira might ask why the Brazilians are “overreacting.” I ask why we aren’t in the streets too? When, like in Occupy’s furious first flush we declared “Shit is Fucked Up and Bullshit,” will we take the streets again? Maybe we’ll just wait for the next MTA fare hike.

Natasha Lennard

Natasha Lennard is an assistant news editor at Salon, covering non-electoral politics, general news and rabble-rousing. Follow her on Twitter @natashalennard, email

More Related Stories

Featured Slide Shows

  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Facebook
  • 1 of 11
  • Close
  • Fullscreen
  • Thumbnails

    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 1

    Niagara Falls, U.S./Canada


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 2

    Sydney Opera House, Sydney, Australia


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 3

    Mount Rushmore, South Dakota, U.S.


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 4

    Eiffel Tower, Paris, France

    Robert R.,

    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 5

    Colosseum, Rome, Italy


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 6

    Taj Mahal, Agra, India

    Sergio Coelho,

    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 7

    Siena Cathedral, Siena, Italy


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 8

    Christ the Redeemer, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 9

    Arc de Triomphe, Paris, France


    Cities without landmarks

    Slide 10

    Lost City of Petra, Jordan

  • Recent Slide Shows



Comment Preview

Your name will appear as username ( settings | log out )

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href=""> <b> <em> <strong> <i> <blockquote>