War Room

Carville wants resignation cease-fire

You might think a man known -- not entirely affectionately -- as the "Ragin' Cajun" would have a high tolerance for almost all kinds of campaign tactics. But apparently not, as James Carville has just penned an Op-Ed for the Financial Times in which he says that the back-and-forth calls for resignations from the campaign staffs of both Democratic candidates need to stop.

"The problem is that calls for resignation are becoming cries of 'wolf' in US politics today. Every time one campaign's surrogate says something mildly offensive about the other candidate, resignation calls are swift," Carville writes. "This sort of hyper-sensitivity diminishes everyone who engages in it, both the candidates and the media. Politics is a rough and tumble business, and yet there seems to be an effort by the commentariat to sanitize American politics to some type of high-level Victorian debating society."

Interestingly enough for a man whose loyalties to the Clintons generally and in this cycle Hillary Clinton specifically are no secret, Carville takes as his prime example the recent resignation of former Barack Obama advisor Samantha Power, who left the Obama campaign after calling Clinton a "monster." Carville asks, "Have we really reached the point where you cannot call your opponent a monster (even if you think her one)?" and adds, "Ms. Power, come back to work."

Carville's larger point is that the kind of attack Power made is nothing new, but that the level of response to such attacks is. Referring to one moment in the 1992 campaign, during which he was Bill Clinton's campaign manager, Carville writes:

My then girlfriend and now wife Mary Matalin called my client "a philandering, pot-smoking draft dodger." Naturally, someone made a perfunctory call for her to resign which got nowhere, and we all got a good laugh and moved on ...

Some comments are within bounds, while some are not. But by whining about every little barb, candidates are trying to win the election through a war of staff resignation attrition and Americans are losing the ability to distinguish between what is fair game and what is not ... Our candidates need to buck up, toughen up and recognize that time spent whining and sniping is time not spent addressing the real concerns of the people.

And yes, if you're wondering, Carville does address the Geraldine Ferraro controversy, writing, "Rather than having to resign, as she has just done, she should have been dispatched to a cruise ship for a few weeks of sightseeing and spa treatments. I hear Antarctica is a popular destination this time of year."

Posted in: 2008 Election

VoteVets targets McCain with new ad
In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.

Current Salon Politics Stories

’08 Update

19:00 EDT, July 23, 2008
VoteVets targets McCain with new ad In the spot, a veteran of the Iraq war says, "'freedom' means when the Iraqi people and their Prime Minister ask us to make a plan to leave, we do."
War Room
13
17:41 EDT, July 23, 2008
Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now? Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
War Room
19
15:31 EDT, July 23, 2008
More bad news for McCain on Iraq A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
War Room
29
14:22 EDT, July 23, 2008
Republicans lose a major financial backer T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
War Room
28
12:37 EDT, July 23, 2008
Obama camp debuts Spanish-language radio ad Highlighting Obama's personal history, the spot concludes, "It's time we had a president who understands we all deserve a chance to make our own way."
War Room
7

Salon Politics Blogs

Recent Posts

Who'll be the Republicans' Obama now?
Bobby Jindal, who'd been discussed as a potential running mate for John McCain, says he doesn't want to be nominated for the vice presidency.
More bad news for McCain on Iraq
A new poll shows Americans favor a timeline for withdrawal, which McCain's campaign has argued against.
Republicans lose a major financial backer
T. Boone Pickens, who gave millions to support the Swift Boat Veterans, among other GOP causes, is now focusing on energy independence instead.
Previous Posts…

War Room RSS Feed

Posts by date

July 2008
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031

About War Room

War Room is written and edited by Alex Koppelman, with contributions from Salon reporters around the country.

Daily Newsletter

Get Salon in your mailbox!