Bill Donohue and I -- together at last!

It's Holy Thursday, and on "Scarborough Country" we're debating whether the media is persecuting Christians. Guess which side I'm on.


Joan Walsh
April 5, 2007 11:40PM (UTC)

I was invited to debate the Catholic League's Bill Donohue on "Scarborough Country" tonight, and even though I'm leaving to spend Easter weekend with my family, I couldn't resist (they pre-taped for Thursday night).

Pre-taping is odd; I have no idea how the segment will turn out. All I can tell you is that for a very long period of time, Joe stepped out of the middle and let Bill and me swing away. I only had to ask him not to yell at me once, I think.

Advertisement:

We talked for almost 40 minutes, so they'll have to trim it down to fit the show. We mostly disagreed, as you'd expect, but we reached a tiny bit of agreement in the end. Donohue said he thought the "South Park" episode this week in which Jesus returns as a ninja and cuts Donohue in half was "hilarious," and he disagrees with conservatives who've told him to sue Comedy Central. (Maybe Jesus spending last weekend praying for Donohue to be a bit more open-minded paid off?)

We found no such common ground on chocolate Jesus. They both tried to depict recent books by atheists and skeptics and scientists as a new assault on Christianity, but I said that at Salon we've put them into our popular series "Atoms and Eden: Conversations about Science and Faith," and that some of this wave of books are by scientists who've found that their work deepened their Christianity, rather than challenged it. I got to defend my girl Michelle Goldberg, whose "Kingdom Coming" wasn't a big Scarborough favorite, by reminding them -- I had to do this over and over -- that Goldberg and "American Fascists" author Chris Hedges aren't targeting all Christians, just the extremists who are trying to turn this into a Christian nation. Donohue also shared that he got support for his jihad against chocolate Jesus from a conservative Muslim, and I suggested that he think about that very carefully. Aren't we trying to fight fundamentalist Islam, the kind that wants to take our freedoms away? Anyway, it was exciting. We'll see if it makes good TV.

And with that the blog closes its doors so we can put up the Easter baskets and make sure everyone has a chocolate bunny or Jesus. Have a great weekend, everyone, and I'll see you Monday.


Joan Walsh

Joan Walsh is the author of "What's the Matter With White People: Finding Our Way in the Next America."

MORE FROM Joan WalshFOLLOW joanwalshLIKE Joan Walsh



Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •