My sister, who is 34 to my 30, has been dating a man in his early 40s on and off for the past 10 years. To give you some background on his character, when she first met him, he was in his early 30s and dating a 17-year-old girl (statutory rape where we come from). My sister began dating him shortly thereafter. Over the years he has cheated on her, dumped her because he felt she was socially inferior to him, and been caught in many, many lies. He has a child with another woman that he has completely abandoned. He has worn -- in public and in photos online -- vintage war pieces that are emblazoned with swastikas (he states that he is a war enthusiast and not a Nazi, but I and others have heard him make racist comments before). He was and currently is a teacher and has been accused by at least one female student of inappropriate sexual conduct.
For all of these reasons, he and my sister have broken up several times, sometimes for a year or longer, but they always end up back together. Each time they break up, my sister inundates our family with the kind of information about him I've mentioned above, yet when they get back together, little explanation is given and we are all expected to just accept him back with open arms. I have complied with this expectation three times now, but I reached my breaking point two years ago after they'd separated for a year and then got back together. This was after he was accused of sexual misconduct with his student. I asked many times and no explanation was given for her forgiveness of him, other than that the student had made the whole thing up. Given his track record, I am not willing to accept that.
For two years, I have asked that he be kept away from me. The other members of our family have made their peace with him and accepted him back into their lives, but I'm the lone holdout. Holidays and other family gatherings are awkward as we work in "shifts" -- my husband and I spend the morning at my parents' house and in the afternoon we leave so my sister's boyfriend can come over. Well, now things have changed. Over Thanksgiving they got engaged. No one in my family told me (I live in a different city now) and I read about it on Facebook the next day. I am now faced with a choice of accepting this person -- my sister's future husband -- back into my life so that I can be involved in their wedding, or of continuing to maintain my distance from him, thereby severing my relationship with my sister.
This situation has become polarizing and it has left me extremely depressed. I dearly miss my sister and the relationship we used to have, but this has affected us so much. She feels that I am judging her and her choices and that I do not love her "unconditionally." She has dismissed most of the accusations that have been made against him over the years as misunderstandings. She says it is not her place to defend him to me and that if I have further questions I need to ask him. But the thought of even sitting down to have a conversation with this man makes me very uncomfortable. He is extremely intelligent and manipulative and I feel in many ways, he's dangerous. I spent eight years getting to know him and I came to the conclusion that he's just not a good person. My family has said that he's changed and has been attending counseling sessions, but in my opinion if he hasn't even admitted to the things it seems obvious he's done, then how much can he have changed?
I am flying home for Christmas, but she wrote and said she would not be seeing me because if I do not accept him, I do not accept her. I don't feel this is true as I love my sister very much. She is an intelligent and caring person, but for the life of me I don't understand why she has chosen to spend her life with this man. I know I can't choose her mate for her or tell her what to do, but I also don't feel that I should be forced to accept someone like him into my life.
I don't want to lose my sister over this. Should I suck it up for the sake of the family and have a discussion with him, or am I right to stand my ground?
Scared and Depressed
Dear Scared and Depressed,
Your sister has made a choice that places her beyond your reach. The relationship you remember having with her is gone for now. It might come back but it is gone for now.
There may be many reasons for this. There may be things in her personality, or her life journey, that require her to be with this man. There may be things in her nature that blind her to his obvious flaws. You may have to accept the possibility that in her way she is just as messed up as he is.
What that means in practical terms is that you have to protect yourself. You cannot protect your sister. So you protect yourself.
That is a terrible thing to realize, that you cannot protect your sister. Yet you know it's true. You have tried to protect your sister and she has again and again shaken off your protection and has gone to be with this man who is obviously a danger.
So in a way, you have lost your sister. That is hard to accept. Such a thing is heart-rending. Such a thing grinds away at one's happiness. But the sooner you accept it the sooner you can begin living with it. Living with the truth is better than grinding away in fruitless battle.
Your sister gets something that she needs from this man. We don't know what that is. We wish that she would get into therapy and discover her reasons for returning to him, and we wish that, having discovered those reasons, she would find alternatives that enrich rather than impoverish her. We wish she would find the unacknowledged needs that are driving her to make poor decisions. We can wish this. But we must also know that she is a free being, and she will make choices, and we have no power over those choices.
It's a terrible thing, freedom. Freedom of choice is nice when people make choices we approve of, but when they make bad choices we want to yank that freedom away from them and make their choices for them. But that's another price of freedom: People get to mess up their lives terribly all on their own, and we have to stand by and watch.
Your only reasonable choice is to keep this man out of your own life. If that means some separation from your sister, that is a necessary price.
You do not have to go to her wedding. You do not have to be a party to this. You can tell your sister what you believe and tell her why you are not participating in the wedding and let her go.
For now at least, she is lost to you.
What? You want more advice?
- Read more Cary Tennis in the Since You Asked directory.
- See what others are saying and/or join the conversation in the Table Talk forum.
- Ask for advice. Letter writers: Please think carefully! By sending a letter to email@example.com, you are giving Salon permission to publish it. Once you submit it, it may not be possible to rescind it. So be sure. If you are not sure, sleep on it. You can always send tomorrow. Ready? OK, Submit your letter for publication.
- Or, just make a comment to Cary Tennis not for publication.
- Or, send a letter to Salon's editors not for publication.