In the past three years, I have had a great deal of loss. My father, both grandmothers and my 36-year-old brother died. My mother had breast cancer and I had a miscarriage. Plus, two of our family pets passed. It has been a great deal to absorb, especially when the onslaught of loss kept going and going.
When a family member grew ill, or near the end, I relied on my mother-in-law to fly in to help my husband with our kids. She is retired, well off, and visited us often. Most visits with her tended to involve her taking us out for meals and taking us shopping. When I was a stay-at-home mom, I appreciated all the gifts and meals out as a diversion from our otherwise tight budget. Holidays were over the top; she even took our family on two Mexican vacations. We didn't ask for money, or trips, but we did accept them gratefully.
When my last family member grew ill, I traveled across the country and my mother-in law came to stay with my family. The trip ended up being longer than originally planned because I decided to stay for the funeral. When I asked my mother-in-law to change her plans and stay one more day, she said she had a dentist appointment to attend. Furthermore, she asked if the funeral date could be changed or could someone else bring the ashes home. I was aghast. My grandmother's funeral didn't take precedence over a dentist appointment?
When I called my husband later that night, he told me that his mother had been concerned over our finances. She was urging him to look for a better job and asking when I was returning to work. She had been talking finances with him the whole time I had been gone, knowing full well that I handle the money in our family. She talked about feeling unappreciated. She had never brought up any of these topics with me, and to do so while I was gone and in such a dire emotional place, just seemed wildly inappropriate to me. I think she was acting needy when I was in a time of actual need.
In the end, my husband took time off work and sent his mother home in time for her appointment. On a layover, on the way home from the funeral, I called my in-laws and told them that I was canceling our next planned vacation to Disneyland. In part, I was angry over my losses and didn't feel like "business as usual" after hearing her bemoan our finances. I thought, "Fine, if you're suddenly worried about my money then I won't spend any more of yours." I have since returned to work and it's been the silent (or martyr) treatment from her for almost a year now.
After licking my many wounds for many months, I realize that what family I have left is small and that I want to be close again, at the very least for the sake of my kids. I am at an impasse with my mother-in-law that I'd like to be resolved, but I don't feel like groveling or apologizing. I miss our old relationship, when we were close and things were fun, but realize that ship has sailed. What should I do?
Mother of All Mother-in-Law Issues
Dear Mother of all Mother-in-Law Issues,
What should you do?
Grovel and apologize.
It will feel great.
It's not that the groveling and apologizing will feel great. But when you finally become willing to grovel and apologize, you will have achieved a spiritual victory. You will be free of your wounded pride.
Before you feel free of your pride, you need to grieve. If you feel you can't grieve because your mother-in-law has withdrawn her support, then you may well feel angry. Your pride may be hurt. If you are used to being the one who handles the money and someone comes in and starts giving advice, your pride is hurt. When our pride is hurt we want to strike out. When we feel threatened we want to strike out.
But you need to take care of yourself. You have "licked your wounds" but you have not allowed your grief the kindness of time. You may feel that grieving is a luxury, that before you can grieve, somebody has to step in and take care of things and make sure everything is running smoothly. So when your mother-in-law tried to take care of her own needs, you felt panic. How can you grieve, how can you get through this, if there isn't someone making sure everything runs smoothly?
Well, as you know, death changes all that. Death doesn't wait for us to clean up the house. It comes and plunges us into grief and certain things just have to wait.
The way we live our lives today, we don't plan for difficulty. When overwhelming feelings arrive, as well they will, when grief arrives, and it will, when sadness comes, and it will, when the life cycle turns, we haven't made room for it. We haven't prepared the house for this new visitor.
So forgive those around you, and accept your own grief. Maybe the house will get messy. Maybe the kids won't be perfectly taken care of. Maybe a little sheen will come off the glossy finish. That's OK. It's nothing to be ashamed of. Have some compassion for yourself. You've been hurt. You've been through hell. You've been through hell and haven't given yourself credit. Possibly others haven't given you credit either. So give yourself credit. Let yourself feel this. You've been beaten down. People you love have been taken from you. You lost a baby, for heaven's sake! Life has taken loved ones from you. You've been torn apart. Let yourself feel this. Give yourself love.
How to repair your feelings toward your mother-in-law? One way is to list all the things you are grateful to your mother-in-law for. List all the things she has done for you, the gifts, the visits, the dinners. Just list all the things you are grateful for. Think of what you would miss if she were gone. And thank her for all these things.
When your mother-in-law said she had to go back, isn't it possible that she lied, that it wasn't about the dentist, that she had emotional reasons of her own for getting back home? People do things to meet their own needs. They don't necessarily understand consciously what all their needs are, or how they're meeting them, so they say things like they have a dental appointment because they think that's what they're supposed to do. So sometimes it comes out sounding pretty lame. And offensive. But it's very hard in most families for someone to just say what they're feeling.
And perhaps you need to grovel -- not for your mother-in-law but for yourself. Maybe something in you is calling you to grovel, for it is an oft-observed truth that in what we most resist lies a deep attraction. So go ahead and get down on the ground and feel the ground. Grovel and let out your grief. Let yourself do this. A part of you wants to. Your prideful ego wants to maintain its appearance as the completely together entity who's in charge of the finances and knows what to do in every instance. But it is your prideful ego that stands between you and relief. So let your ego blab on about its resentments and its anger and its refusal to grovel and refusal to apologize.
You don't need to be afraid. Death comes. The ego doesn't want to die or accept the fact of death, and so it stands between us and true grieving. In reality we decay. We lose people. Things fall apart. We leave the stage. We make room for more. That's how it goes. Every life is full of constant leaving. It tears us apart but that's how it is.
Just let it go, all this stuff. Let yourself break down. Let yourself fall to your knees. You've had enough. You've held it all together long enough. Let it go.
Let your tears fall. Let your tears fall into the ocean of tears that have fallen for all the departed for all the years that we have been saying goodbye to souls old and young. Let your tears fall into the river of souls. Let yourself fall to your knees and grieve for all the souls that have passed by us. Empty yourself of this grief. Empty yourself. Empty yourself and make room for all the new souls coming into the world.
Welcome all the new souls coming into the world. Make room for the life to come.
What? You want more advice?
- Read more Cary Tennis in the Since You Asked directory.
- See what others are saying and/or join the conversation in the Table Talk forum.
- Ask for advice. Letter writers: Please think carefully! By sending a letter to firstname.lastname@example.org, you are giving Salon permission to publish it. Once you submit it, it may not be possible to rescind it. So be sure. If you are not sure, sleep on it. You can always send tomorrow. Ready? OK, Submit your letter for publication.
- Or, just make a comment to Cary Tennis not for publication.
- Or, send a letter to Salon's editors not for publication.