I had a really boring suburban life for a long time, wishing that something would make it interesting. I had a good relationship with my family and I thought that my parents would stay together forever.
Then we got hit with a hurricane.
After the hurricane I spent a lot more time talking to my father. We talked before but this seemed different, like how I thought the father-son deep(ish) discussions were supposed to go. He didn't seem as happy as I had previously thought, but I assumed that was due to having 5 feet of water wash through our house, which makes for a somewhat more stressful existence. A lot of the time we spent after the storm was gutting the entire first floor, talking about his childhood and mine and what my plans for the future were. During our discussions I got the impression that my parents' marriage wouldn't last forever, so I steeled myself for the inevitable to occur.
Flash forward to a week after my 18th birthday in 2006, and I come home to my father packing up a U-Haul and leaving my mother. He left her a note (that I probably shouldn't have read, but I think most people would have in my situation) saying that he felt that after I was born most of my mother's love went to me and he felt left out; it was basically a page and a half of selfishness.
He showed me the apartment he was supposed to be living in (I called it a "small studio" but others might call it "I can go from my bed to my toilet in less than 10 steps! How convenient!"). I later found out that he had been cheating on my mother for years ... multiple women with other kids, swinger parties, basically everything I thought he was above as a person. He is now remarried and his new wife has two kids and I can never really forgive him for what he did, but I do my best.
Last year, when I was stationed overseas, the day after my birthday I posted a Facebook message thanking everyone for their kind wishes and he left me a reply saying, "I knew there was something special about yesterday," and this year ... nothing. I don't think he did it on purpose but no phone call, no text, no communication whatsoever. I don't even know exactly how I felt, but I think I could best describe it as numb, though I don't know if it is a numbness to him in general, or if it affected me even more than I thought it did at the time. It has been five days since my birthday and I still haven't talked to him and I don't know how to bring it up. On the one hand I want to call him out on this, but if I do that I don't know if I will be able to stop myself and I will finally get up the nerve to ask him how long he was philandering and if he thinks I deserve an apology for cheating on my mother.
She was his wife, but she is still my damn mom.
Honestly, I don't really have a specific question regarding this situation, I could just use some advice on what to do from here because I know I am going to have to talk to him eventually and I don't really know how slighted I am supposed to feel about this situation. After reading that letter I don't want me getting pissed about him missing multiple birthdays to be construed as being as selfish as he turned out to be. I guess I just would like to know how much anger I am warranted to feel toward him after everything that he has done. I feel emotionally conflicted and like I said before ...
I remember my father's series of small apartments after he left my mother. I remember the meagerness and poverty, his effects strewn about, the boxes on the floor, the absence of furniture, the absence of a life. It was devastating, actually -- that he had chosen this over us. I remember trying to be encouraging and upbeat. "Wow, this isn't so bad. It's kind of a nice place. Look out this window!" Yet it seemed bleak and incompetent. It was such a fall. Those dismal apartments, one after the other. That one in Miami on Biscayne Blvd., kind of a swingers pad, with a pool and I'll always remember that smell of newly delivered furniture, cooking oil, eggs recently scrambled or made omelet-style, the simple food smells of a man cooking for himself, living a strange little life that was supposed to be exciting and carefree but which seemed lonely and pointless.
Yeah, I remember that. I remember wondering how I'm supposed to feel about all this. That tiny, damp little "studio" in the back of an old woman's concrete block house near the University of Miami with the room air conditioner. I lived there for a summer jazz session while he ... where was he? Was he at his mother's? I think he was in his mother's house on Mary Street, that house that later became the object of so much conflict when he sold it while my brother was still living in it.
I don't completely recall how those various strange abodes came into his possession, but there he was, with his entourage of cardboard boxes and his war medals, evicted, divorced, moving on. Why? It seemed so stupid. It would have been simpler for him to stay in the house. But no, they couldn't get along.
What was I feeling? Wanting to be supportive yet actually angry, puzzled and hurt, ashamed that he seemed diminished, no longer Dad, head of household, man of the house, reduced to man of the tiny studio apartment trying to get chicks at the pool to come up to see his "digs."
It's not something you want to see your dad do. And yeah, it was around the time I turned 18 that he first moved out. It's a big letdown, a big hole in the gut; it's not like anything you've experienced thus far.
And if your dad wants you to go see a therapist to help you deal with the divorce, well, that's just creepy. Maybe you want to punch him but you don't want to go to therapy especially at his suggestion because you're not the one with the problem, and you didn't make this problem, he made it by moving out, so why should you have to go to some creepy therapist and talk about your feelings when your feelings should really be directed at your dad?
Which is the point, really. That he fucked up and you're angry with him and that's a really, really hard thing to confront with a parent. I never did tell my dad how angry and hurt I was for him getting divorced like that. I believed at the time that the adult thing to do was to understand, not to be angry about it and certainly not to blame my parents, but to understand. Well, there's a difference between blaming your parents for your lot in life and being angry at them for making boneheaded moves. So yes, I was angry at my father for years, but fighting to retain my love for him, and so dancing gingerly around the issues, pretending to be encouraging and charmed by his chosen existence when really it made me sick to see it. It made me sick to see my father and his two brothers all leave their wives and begin a dicey and peripatetic existence going from apartment to apartment and girlfriend to girlfriend or wife to wife. It was confusing and alienating and I didn't like it but I was afraid to confront them because they were the elder men.
This fear of the elder men in the family goes deep. I had no idea how much power it had until years later. I had no idea how paralyzed I was. But I am not alone. Many men are afraid of their fathers. We do not know where they get this power over us so we pretend that they do not really have this power over us but, Oh, they have it. They have it in spades. Even my father, wiry, bespectacled, diminutive and professorial in manner: Oh, I feared him mightily! We may be angry but afraid to say we are angry for fear of violence. The father holds that violent edge, that family privilege, the nuclear option. You never know. My father was a strangely elusive but explosive man, given to surprising outbursts. And you never knew what was going on in his head.
He's dead now.
I never confronted him. I never had that epic battle that sons and fathers sometimes have, where they finally let out that mixture of anger and tenderness, rage and pity that characterizes the relationship.
So what kind of conversation with my dad would I have wanted? If he were here today, I would like to hear him say that he did it for himself. He'd had it with living for others. He wanted to live for himself. Right or wrong, it was his decision to begin living for himself, and he did that, and it would have been helpful to hear him say that forthrightly.
Instead, when the subject of the divorce arose, we heard his painful self-recrimination and regret.
So if I could do it differently, or if I were in your shoes, what would I do? I would be frank and open about my feelings whatever they are. That doesn't mean necessarily confronting family members about it. It more means being frank with yourself and those close to you about what you actually feel. Don't try to figure it out. Accept it. Accept what you feel. You may feel impulses that morality prevents you from acting on. That's OK to feel.
I can say with certainty that there is no correct way to feel. We men seem to think that if we want to be a certain kind of man, we may feel only a certain way. But a good man feels what he feels.
By feeling what we feel, we come to know ourselves. Then our true nature arises serenely and almost without notice. Then we need do nothing but trust our instincts. We become authentic.
And how does this vaunted authenticity come about? Slowly if at all. We keep going over it and over it, like sanding wood. More is revealed with every pass.
As to the numbness: I suspect you fear the torrent of tears that would erupt were you to say how you feel. You may need someone to yank it out of you. Like it's stuck down there in your throat and a professional has to use his slim jim.
That's one way to think of psychotherapists. They get inside the locked vehicle of your psyche, but with your permission.
It took me years before I could trust another man to listen to me cry. Are you kidding? I know. It's icky. But eventually it was a matter of either let these feelings of shame and anger and outrage and humiliation and pitiful hurt show, cry them out in front of someone, demonstrate to someone just how deeply I was hurting, by way of saying, OK, this is me, this awful shambles you see before you, this sobbing shambles of a man, this is me, this is my state, this is what I've come to ... or who knows what I would come to, walking around numb, as you say, from a lifetime habit of not feeling.
If you want to stop being numb you have to start feeling.
Basically, whatever you feel is appropriate.
We men have a code. We are supposed to feel certain things in certain situations. But the truth is, we feel what we feel. Even though that sounds dumb.
The stereotypical "sensitive male" is easy to ridicule. There was a lot of bogus "showing your feelings" in the 1970s. You don't have to "show your feelings." You just have to feel them and know what they are.
In my 20s I thought, If you are a real man, you will feel this way about this and that way about that. You will have learned the code. But you never really do.
This is what we men go through.
What do our fathers want from us and for us? What is expected? What are we supposed to do and feel?
We never really know. We just feel what we feel. We try to stay true to ourselves and to the ones we love. That's all we can do.
Makes a great gift. Can be personalized for the giftee of your choice. Signed first editions on sale now.
What? You want more advice?
- Read more Cary Tennis in the Since You Asked directory.
- See what others are saying and/or join the conversation in the Table Talk forum.
- Ask for advice. Letter writers: Please think carefully! By sending a letter to email@example.com, you are giving Salon permission to publish it. Once you submit it, it may not be possible to rescind it. So be sure. If you are not sure, sleep on it. You can always send tomorrow. Ready? OK, Submit your letter for publication.
- Or, just make a comment to Cary Tennis not for publication.
- Or, send a letter to Salon's editors not for publication.