(Wikipedia/AP)

Newt's iffy claim: Iran hides nukes under mosques

Explosive charge appears to be pure speculation


Justin Elliott
December 15, 2011 1:00AM (UTC)

Is Iran hiding nuclear weapons facilities under mosques?

Newt Gingrich says yes – but experts say there is no evidence to back up the assertion.

Gingrich made the claim at a debate with Jon Huntsman in New Hampshire on Monday.  Here, via Michael Crowley, is the key moment:

Advertisement:

"They have huge underground facilities. Some of the underground facilities are under mosques," Gingrich said. "Some of them are in cities. The idea that you’re going to wage a bombing campaign that accurately takes out all the Iranian nuclear program I think is a fantasy."

That’s an extremely significant charge, one made by a man who now has a real shot at being the next president of the United States.

An extensive search of International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reports on Iran found no mentions of the terms “mosque” or “holy site.” We do know that some of Iran’s nuclear facilities are underground; but I found no media mentions of them being under mosques.

(Also worth noting: it’s not a given that Iran is pursuing nuclear weapons, rather than nuclear power. The question of Iran’s intentions is complex and remains unresolved.)

"There's no evidence [for that]," said David Albright, an expert on Iran's nuclear program and president of the Institute for Science and International Security, when asked about the mosques issue. "I don't know where Gingrich gets this, but it sounds like he is just repeating rumors."

Advertisement:

I also asked Ken Pollack, a Mideast specialist at the Brookings Institution, if he has heard of anything like Gingrich's mosques claim.

"Nope," Pollack said in an email. "Never heard that they have underground facilities beneath mosques.  They do have extensive tunnels at some sites, and I guess some of those tunnels may run under mosques, but I have never heard that they purposely built them under mosques as this seems to suggest."

Advertisement:

Gingrich’s spokesman did not immediately respond to an inquiry about his source for the claim.

It’s also at least a bit ironic that Gingrich made the iffy mosques assertion after specifically questioning the ability of the CIA to determine what the Iranians are doing.

“This idea that somehow we have magically accurate intelligence … is baloney,” he said.

Advertisement:

Justin Elliott

Justin Elliott is a reporter for ProPublica. You can follow him on Twitter @ElliottJustin

MORE FROM Justin ElliottFOLLOW elliottjustin


Related Topics ------------------------------------------

2012 Elections Iran Newt Gingrich Nuclear Power Nuclear Weapons War Room

Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •