Chris Hayes to replace Ed Schultz in prime-time slot

MSNBC announced their latest move as it struggles to dominate the 25 to 54 demographic

Published March 14, 2013 5:35PM (EDT)

Chris Hayes           (MSNBC)
Chris Hayes (MSNBC)

Chris Hayes is ready for his close-up.

The hip, bespectacled journalist is preparing to take over the covetable 8 p.m. time slot vacated by Ed Schultz's "The Ed Show" — network executives have moved Schultz to Saturday and Sunday evenings. Hayes has hosted "Up With Chris Hayes" since September 2011, and established quite a following in less than two years of carrying a show.

"Chris has done an amazing job creating a franchise on weekend morning," network president Phil Griffin said in a statement. "He’s an extraordinary talent and has made a strong connection with our audience. This is an exciting time for MSNBC."

Griffin is banking on Hayes -- and possible Hayes's morning slot replacement Ezra Klein -- to make MSNBC a household name. Well, a liberal household name, at least. “Our awareness level, people who can define who we are, is much lower than Fox and CNN,” Mr. Griffin told the New York Times. The network president has been building out a brand identity through the steady recruitment of ever-younger, ever-more progressive on-air talent. Of the network's gravitation to the left, former President Bill Clinton remarked, “Boy, it really has become our version of Fox.”

And what of Schultz in all of this? While his public comments imply he was a willing participant in the trade -- remarking, "I raised my hand for this assignment for a number of personal and professional reasons" -- the weekend bump is a clear demotion, insiders say. The 8 p.m. slot is the crown jewel of prime time, and while MSNBC has been beefing up its weekend programing, a Saturday slot remains minor leagues in comparison.

There may also be the problem of image: Schultz is part of the Old Left (somewhat literally, as he is one of the older hosts on the network). Populist in tone and heavy on labor politics, Schultz may no longer "fit" with the sleeker, academic and decidedly wonkier tone MSNBC has been cultivating with hosts like Rachel Maddow and Melissa Harris-Perry.

"Up With Chris Hayes" was also one of the network's most diverse weekend programs. As reported by Media Matters, it was "more diverse than any of the Sunday morning talk shows on the other networks, as a Media Matters examination of guests since January 1 demonstrates." The report continued:

Most tellingly, white men make up 41 percent of total guests on Up with Chris Hayes (according to data from the U.S. Census, white men make up roughly 39 percent of the U.S. population). In contrast, CBS' Face the Nation, Fox's Fox News Sunday, NBC's Meet the Press, CNN's State of the Union, and ABC's This Week host white men 66 percent, 64 percent, 64 percent, 67 percent, and 61 percent of the time, respectively.

Further, Up with Chris Hayes has more than double the proportion of African-American guests -- 21 percent -- as compared to each of the other programs. In all, 34 percent of guests on Up with Chris Hayes are non-white. Hayes also hosts more women -- 37 percent -- than any of the other networks' shows.

Hayes may have gotten a promotion for a job well done, but network executives will be watching closely to see if his brand of smart, un-blustery political commentary can match ratings with Fox's beloved blowhard, Bill O'Reilly.

Whether the ratings gamble will work, though, is anybody's bet.


By Katie McDonough

Katie McDonough is Salon's politics writer, focusing on gender, sexuality and reproductive justice. Follow her on Twitter @kmcdonovgh or email her at

MORE FROM Katie McDonough