Sunny Hostin schools "View" co-host Abby Huntsman: The US "has pillaged and raped Puerto Rico"

"It's sad to me that a natural disaster has to get political," the former Fox News personality said before Hostin

By Rachel Leah
Published September 13, 2018 3:52PM (EDT)
Sunny Hostin; Abby Huntsman (ABC/Paula Lobo)
Sunny Hostin; Abby Huntsman (ABC/Paula Lobo)

President Donald Trump sank to a new low when he disputed independent research that determined that nearly 3,000 people died in the aftermath to Hurricane Maria in Puerto Rico. That is what he wrote Thursday morning on Twitter Thursday as he in turn blamed Democrats for inflating the death toll for political gain.

Many have attributed the disturbingly high fatalities to the inadequate response from the Trump administration to the disaster. In this way, the president's tweets were a means of continuing to shirk responsibility.

Trump's tweets and his administration's general lackluster response to the hurricane were the subject of a "Hot Topics" segment Thursday on "The View." "Even if you haven't lost someone in Puerto Rico – if you're just an American citizen, if you're just a human and have any empathy for anyone else – you should feel that this is grotesque," Sunny Hostin, a co-host of the ABC morning show said. "A true leader would offer his condolences to the people of Puerto Rico. A true leader would offer his condolences to the United States citizens and vow to never let something like that happen again."

As Hurricane Florence prepares to assault the Carolinas, how the Trump administration will respond is indeed on the minds of Americans. "I think these statements make him illegitimate as the president of the United States," Hostin continued. "If you are a United States citizen, you should be disgusted by this."

Co-host Abby Huntsman, who recently left Fox News for ABC, begged to differ. "It's sad to me that a natural disaster has to get political," she said. "And, right now, you're having the blame game, where locals on the ground are blaming FEMA. FEMA is blaming locals. I don't think President Trump is solely to blame for what happened. Puerto Rico had a number of their own problems before Maria even hit."

Hostin, who is of Puerto Rican descent, interjected to teach Huntsman the history of the island. "The United States government has pillaged and raped Puerto Rico since the very beginning of time," she fired back, alluding to a dynamic that has come to define America, where the U.S. politically or militarily intervenes in a region — like the Middle East or central and South America — yet wants to absolve responsibility once that same place is in crisis.

"The United States has used Puerto Rico as a bank account," Hostin continued, referencing the Jones Act, "and now turns around and says, 'Well, Puerto Rico was really screwed up.' Well, no, thank you. I'm from Puerto Rico, and Puerto Rico was not screwed up."

Although Hostin spoke from a placed of lived experience, Huntsman refused to back down. "I don't think that's fair," she said, bemoaning Hostin's previous comparison of Trump to a dictator.

"That's comparing him to a Hitler," Huntsman charged. "You think that President Trump was in the Oval Office saying how can we make it worse for Puerto Ricans, how can we make it so more people die? You think that was actually happening in the White House?"

Highlighting the difference between malice and negligence, Hostin responded, "This president did not care enough. At the time that this was happening, he was more concerned with NFL athletes protesting and kneeling than he was concerned about what’s going on in the United States."

"When you see someone, the president, letting his own citizens die – and then turning it around, and saying that they didn’t really die – I think that that’s very similar to the acts of a dictator," she said, adding that she would never liken anyone to Hitler.

As far as the comparison to a dictator, Hostin concluded: "I stand by that and I would say it again!"

Puerto Rico is being ignored. But what's the cause?

How did racism play a role in President Trump's response to Puerto Rico?

Rachel Leah

MORE FROM Rachel Leah

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Abby Huntsman Donald Trump Hurricane Relief Hurricane Florence Hurricane Maria Puerto Rico Racism The View