House Ways and Means Committee Chair Rep. Kevin Brady (R-TX) (AP/Jacquelyn Martin)

Republican leader admits that the party’s major tax cut may not pay for itself after all

GOP leader who crafted the tax bill admits increased revenues may not actually pay for the cuts


Cody Fenwick
June 13, 2019 8:59AM (UTC)
This article originally appeared on AlterNet.
alternet-logo

Who could have ever seen this coming?

After spreading the message all over the news and across the country that the GOP tax bill will pay for itself by magically driving up revenues — even while doling out a massive giveaway to wealthy people and corporations — a top leader in the Republican Party is now admitting the law may not actually fund itself.

Advertisement:

“We will know in year 8, 9 or 10 what revenues it brought in to the government over time,” said Texas’s Rep. Kevin Brady, who helped craft the GOP’s tax bill. “So it’s way too early to tell,”

When he was directly asked about how much of the cuts would actually be paid for by increased revenues, Brady said “hard to know,” the Washington Post reported Tuesday citing comments at the Peterson Foundation’s Fiscal Summit.

Of course, Republicans didn’t think it was “hard to know” in 2017 when they rushed the bill through to President Donald Trump’s desk. They were sure it would pay for itself, and they sold the bill to the American people based on that promise. After all, they spent years fomenting outrage about the deficit under President Barack Obama — how could they pass a debt-increasing law under Trump?

Here’s just a sampling of what some Republicans said before the bill passed:

  • “The bottom line is we will be able to fill any deficit hole with additional revenues. And we basically saw the same during the Reagan tax cut, frankly the Kennedy tax cut. You can even go back to the Coolidge tax cut. We will be able to raise more revenues.” Rep. Ken Hensarling
  • “The tax plan will pay for itself with economic growth.” – Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin
  • “I am one who is convinced that if we reduce tax rates, eventually we will bring in more money into the Treasury.”  Rep. Ted Poe
  • “I not only don’t think it will increase the deficit, I think it will be beyond revenue neutral,” Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said of the bill. “In other words, I think it will produce more than enough to fill that gap.”

Those claims were ridiculous in 2017, based on history and analyses that were conducted at the time — not to mention common sense. Since then, it has only become more obvious how wrong the Republicans were in their case for the tax bill.

“Revenue fell, it didn’t rise, after the tax cuts,” Marc Goldwein, senior policy director for the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, explained to the Post about the law’s effects.

Advertisement:

Increasing the deficit isn’t always a bad thing, of course. It can be the right policy choice if you’re doing it for a good reason. But the GOP decided to add $1.5 trillion to the national debt while sending the vast bulk of the money to corporations and the wealthiest Americans, with little if any discernible benefit for the rest of the country.


Cody Fenwick

MORE FROM Cody Fenwick

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

All Salon Gop Gop Tax Bill Kevin Brady News & Politics Republican Party Republican Tax Bill




Fearless journalism
in your inbox every day

Sign up for our free newsletter

• • •