"Please don't patronize me": Watch Rep. Katie Porter tear into an oil executive

The oil executive tried to claim that his industry doesn't get special tax breaks

By Jake Johnson
March 10, 2021 8:12PM (UTC)
main article image
Rep. Katie Porter, D-Calif., attends the House Financial Services Committee hearing titled The End of Affordable Housing? A Review of the Trump Administrations Plans to Change Housing Finance in America, in Rayburn Building on Tuesday, October 22, 2019. (Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)

This article originally appeared at Common Dreams. It is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 License. Feel free to republish and share widely.

Congresswoman Katie Porter took a fossil fuel industry executive to task for falsely suggesting during a House hearing on Tuesday that oil and gas companies don't receive special treatment in the U.S. tax code, a claim that the California Democrat quickly refuted—while also offering to eliminate the tax breaks.

Asked by Porter to explain how much of his company's intangible drilling costs is tax deductible, Mark Murphy of Strata Production—a New Mexico-based oil and gas exploration company—responded that "we get to deduct all of those just like any other business."

Advertisement:

"There seems to be a misconception out there that you're operating from that somehow the oil and gas industry benefits from some special sort of tax structure," said Murphy, the president of Strata Production. "We don't."

Porter, a second-term congresswoman who has developed a reputation for her incisive grilling of corporate executives and government officials, swiftly undercut Murphy's narrative, explaining: "You do benefit from special rules. There's a special tax rule for intangible drilling costs that does not apply to other kinds of expenses that businesses have."

"You get to deduct 70% of your costs immediately, and other businesses have to amortize their expenses over their entire profit stream," Porter added. "So please don't patronize me by telling me that the oil and gas industry doesn't have any special tax provisions. Because if you would like that to be the rule, I would be happy to have Congress deliver."

Advertisement:

Watch the exchange:

Environmentalist Bill McKibben, co-founder of 350.org, was among those who applauded Porter's debunking of the fossil fuel executive's false claim.

"The wonderful Rep. Katie Porter provides a signal moment in congressional history," McKibben tweeted. "And it's a sign of the weakening position of the oil industry—no deference to these liars any longer."

Advertisement:

Porter is the lead sponsor of Ending Taxpayer Welfare for Oil and Gas Companies Act, legislation introduced last week that would—according to a summary from the California congresswoman's office—"raise royalties, rental rates, inspection fees, and penalties on oil and gas companies that extract resources from public lands."

"Public lands are a collective national treasure that belong to the American people—polluters that want to extract energy on these lands owe taxpayers a fair price," Porter said in a statement. "We haven't raised the rental rate for mining on public lands since I was in junior high, and we've been charging oil and gas companies the same royalty rate for over 100 years. My Ending Taxpayer Welfare for Oil and Gas Companies Act would protect taxpayers and give these prices a decades-overdue update."

Advertisement:

Following Tuesday's hearing, Rep. Earl Blumenauer (D-Ore.) welcomed Porter to sign on to his bill with Rep. Sean Casten (D-Ill.) calling for the elimination of nearly a dozen tax provisions that "unfairly benefit oil and gas companies."

"Count me in!" Porter responded.


Jake Johnson

MORE FROM Jake Johnson


Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Climate Change Common Dreams Fossil Fuels Katie Porter