Bolsonaro's out: But now Lula faces a divided Brazil with a damaged economy

Leftist ex-president wins Brazil's hotly contested election — but the really hard part will be governing

Published November 1, 2022 5:30AM (EDT)

Brazilian former President (2003-2010) and candidate for the leftist Workers Party (PT) Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva waves at supporters while leaving the polling station, during the presidential run-off election, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on October 30, 2022. (CARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images)
Brazilian former President (2003-2010) and candidate for the leftist Workers Party (PT) Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva waves at supporters while leaving the polling station, during the presidential run-off election, in Sao Paulo, Brazil, on October 30, 2022. (CARL DE SOUZA/AFP via Getty Images)

This article was originally published on The Conversation.

Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has achieved a remarkable political comeback by regaining the presidency of Brazil. His narrow victory, in the second round runoff, was the closest margin of victory in an election since Brazil reverted to democracy in the late 1980s. The result was 50.9% for Lula and 49.1% for incumbent President Jair Bolsonaro — a difference of little more than 2 million votes out of almost 119 million valid votes cast.

Lula is now set for a third term, 12 years after ending his second term as an unusually popular president who achieved both economic growth and social inclusion between 2003 and 2010.

During the campaign the two contenders slugged it out over some familiar themes: Bolsonaro reminded voters of the corruption uncovered concerning several members of Lula's administration. For his part, Lula criticised Bolsonaro for his poor handling of the COVID crisis, in which Brazil recorded the second-highest national death toll behind the United States.

But unlike in 2018, when Lula was ruled ineligible to run because of his 2017 conviction on corruption charges (since annulled) and Bolsonaro beat the inexperienced and relatively unknown Fernando Haddad, this was not an election in which corruption was a central issue.

Instead, the economy seemed to be the main concern of most voters. The core of Lula's support is concentrated most heavily in Brazil's impoverished northeast. Bolsonaro's support is particularly strong within better-off households of the south, southeast and center-west.

Lula's coalition of 10 parties was a broad coalition ranging from the left to the center-right. The campaign brought together two political forces that had been enemies in the 2000s: Lula's Workers' Party (Partido dos Trabalhadores, or PT) and politicians who had been or still were members of the center-right Social Democratic Party (Partido da Social Democracia Brasileira, or PSDB) and the Brazilian Democratic Movement (Movimento Democrático Brasileiro, or MDB).

Lula's vice presidential running mate was Geraldo Alckmin, a conservative Catholic and former member of the PSDB. MDB member Simone Tebet, a presidential candidate in the first round, campaigned for Lula in the second round and will probably be offered a place in Lula's cabinet.

One of the keys to the future Lula government is whether this coalition can stay together. It remained united during the campaign, when it had the shared goal of defeating Bolsonaro. Whether it will retain its unity in government is another question.

Fissures could appear when the administration has to make difficult choices about the management of the economy and the challenge of rebuilding state capacity in those areas most damaged by Bolsonaro's administration. The damage is particularly evident in the environment, public health, education, human rights and foreign policy.

Bolsonaro backlash?

Bolsonaro has yet to make a pronouncement about the election result, either to concede or allege fraud. The coming days will offer a test of his character and the nature of the movement that brought him to the presidency.

That movement is sometimes characterized as a hard-right alliance of beef (agribusiness), Bible (evangelical Protestants) and bullets (parts of the police and military, as well as the newly enlarged ranks of gun owners).

Want a daily wrap-up of all the news and commentary Salon has to offer? Subscribe to our morning newsletter, Crash Course.

Bolsonaro could reprise what he said after the final debate ("Whoever has the most votes takes the election") and concede defeat. But he could also emulate his hero and mentor Donald Trump and attempt to propagate a narrative about fraud, refuse to accept the legitimacy of Lula's electoral victory and become the leader of a disloyal opposition to the new government.

Lula has defeated Bolsonaro, and the outgoing president will ultimately have to accept that. But his political movement, Bolsonarismo, isn't going anywhere.

Under Brazilian law he has the right to contest the result by making a case to the supreme electoral court, as did the losing candidate in 2014, Aecio Neves of the PSDB. But he would have to submit compelling evidence. The result would probably be similar to the outcome after the 2014 election, when the court eventually ruled against Neves.

Lula reached out to the opposition in his acceptance speech on Sunday evening. He said something that Bolsonaro never said after his 2018 victory, nor at any time since: "I will govern for 215 million Brazilians, and not only those who voted for me."

He also set out some of the goals of his future government. The most pressing are reducing hunger and poverty, accelerating economic growth and strengthening the industrial sector. Importantly, Lula also stressed the need to cooperate with international partners to slow down the rate of deforestation in the Amazon.

Challenges ahead

His government will have an uphill battle. Government coffers are emptier than they were when Lula was last president. Large increases in the minimum wage, which Lula appeared to commit to during the campaign, are likely to push up inflation, currently running at around 7%. Productivity remains stagnant and industry — which has shrunk as a share of the overall economy — is internationally uncompetitive in many sectors.

But Lula's biggest challenge will probably be political. Bolsonaro may have lost the presidency, but many of his allies have won powerful political positions around the country. Five of Bolsonaro's former ministers won places in the Senate, where Bolsonaro's Liberal Party (PL) has the biggest bloc of seats. Three of Bolsonaro's ex-cabinet members won places in the lower house of the national Congress, where the PL is also the largest party.

In the states, candidates aligned with Bolsonaro won 11 of 27 state governorships, while candidates aligned with Lula won only eight. More importantly, the three biggest and most important states in Brazil — Minas Gerais, Rio de Janeiro, and Sao Paulo – will be governed by pro-Bolsonaro governors from 2023.

Bolsonaro may be due to leave the presidency — but Bolsonarismo is not going anywhere.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

By Anthony Pereira

Anthony Pereira is director of the Kimberly Green Latin American and Caribbean Center at Florida International University, as well as a visiting professor in the School of Global Affairs at King's College London. His latest books are "Understanding Contemporary Brazil" (with Jeff Garmany, 2018) and "Modern Brazil: A Very Short Introduction" (2020).

MORE FROM Anthony Pereira

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Analysis Brazil Elections Jair Bolsonaro Lula The Conversation