Help keep Salon independent

Vance and Welker exchange sparks dueling narratives online

Interview showcased divide between Trump’s allies and critics over diplomacy, and the media’s role in the fight

Weekend Editor

Published

Vice President JD Vance continues to push the Trump diplomatic agenda. After an interview, social media takes sides with very different views of who won. (Andrew Harnik / Getty Images)
Vice President JD Vance continues to push the Trump diplomatic agenda. After an interview, social media takes sides with very different views of who won. (Andrew Harnik / Getty Images)

Vice President J.D. Vance’s appearance Sunday on NBC’s Meet the Press drew as much attention for the exchanges with moderator Kristen Welker as for his message on Ukraine and former President Donald Trump’s foreign policy.

Vance expressed optimism that the war in Ukraine could be nearing an end, saying “significant concessions” had been made by both sides and predicting a possible deal within weeks. He credited Trump’s “energetic diplomacy” and economic pressure on Russia, contrasting it with President Joe Biden’s approach.

But the sharpest moments came when Welker pressed him on whether Moscow was “stringing Trump along” in peace talks and on reports that Trump ordered a raid on former national security adviser John Bolton. Vance avoided specifics on the Bolton matter, redirecting to Trump’s record, while repeating that negotiations would depend on Kyiv and Moscow agreeing to terms.

The interview quickly became a flashpoint online. Conservative commentators cast Vance as having “steamrolled” Welker, praising his discipline under questioning. Progressive voices countered that Welker had pinned him down, particularly on the Bolton raid, with some calling it her toughest test yet as moderator. A few even pointed out Vance’s inaccurate history facts.

The divided reaction underscored the high stakes for both Vance and Welker. For the vice president, the exchange was an opportunity to project loyalty and optimism as Trump pushes for a Ukraine deal. For Welker, it highlighted the challenge of cutting through partisan filters as she seeks to establish her authority on one of Washington’s marquee Sunday shows.

By CK Smith

CK Smith is Salon's weekend editor.

MORE FROM CK Smith

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

Related Articles