Owen Wilson as Woody Allen surrogate in "Midnight in Paris"

For his latest Americans-in-Europe film, the New York auteur makes a strange casting call

Published March 28, 2011 9:56PM (EDT)

The butterscotch stallion as Allen.
The butterscotch stallion as Allen.

Ninety-nine percent of the time, Woody Allen comedies feature a protagonist that looks and sounds a hell of a lot like Woody Allen.* And though sometimes the odd, unconventional choice in Woody surrogates has paid off (Michael Caine, Kenneth Branagh, Sean Penn), the trailer for the director's most recent foray into European scenery, "Midnight in Paris," is a little worrisome on the protagonist front.

Look, I love the Butterscotch Stallion (the name bequeathed to Wilson sometime in the mid-aughts that remains funny to this day) as much as the next lady, but his character studies are not those of the people who populate Allen's world. Wes Anderson's, maybe, but for an Allen film, Owen would be better served playing the love interest/boss of our protagonist's wife.

For the lead of "Midnight," Woody would have been much better off with the British Michael Sheen (the bearded "pseudointellectual" in the preview), who has already proved his stuffy, bumbling comedic chops last season on "30 Rock." (Wesley Snipes, anyone?) Pitching this film around Wilson seems a misstep on the size of letting Scarlett Johansson run roughshod all over the terrible "Scoop," or giving the goyish Josh Brolin a similar philandering cuckold role as Wilson's in last year's "You Will Meet A Tall Dark Stranger."

It's hard to see the reasoning behind Woody's casting choices for some of his recent films, though of course his latest features really only have one breakout star: whichever European city he happens to be filming in.

 *Yes, this includes "Vicky Cristina Barcelona," where Rebecca Hall did a far more impressive job imitating Woody's trademark neurotically condescending writer than Larry David did in "Whatever Works," despite the fact that, in theory, at least, the "Curb Your Enthusiasm" star had a lot more in common with Allen than a beautiful 28-year-old actress.

By Drew Grant

Drew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew.

MORE FROM Drew Grant

Related Topics ------------------------------------------

France Movies Travel Woody Allen