Britney Spears
Can Britney pass the Paula Abdul test?
Wait, we're supposed to be the one judging the one-time pop princess. She'll try and turn the tables on "X-Factor"
Britney Spears (Credit: AP/Evan Agostini) Rumors have been swirling for weeks that Britney Spears would join Fox’s “X-Factor” as a new judge, and yesterday it became official. At the Fox upfront, the annual presentations underway this week in which the major networks sell their new shows to advertisers, and then ply them with alcohol and vast buffets, Britney and Demi Lovato were introduced as the reality competition’s new judges, joining L.A. Reid and Simon Cowell, who appeared on the show last year. Lovato, the 19-year-old former tween star who has already had her own public difficulties with drugs and eating disorders, excitedly told the crowd she was “psyched” to be joining the show. Spears, in a smokier voice than the one she used to have, also expressed her excitement, capably delivering the line that had been written for her. Spears was onstage for all of two minutes, but it was enough to spark my imagination: What is an entire season of Britney Spears talking going to be like?
Thanks to Paula Abdul, the bar for speaking coherently as a judge has been set remarkably low. Paula was one of the original judges when “American Idol” began 10 years ago, and she made the jump with Cowell to “X Factor” last year, where she continued to vend her particular brand of addled kindness, never saying anything mean or insightful, and often saying it in spacey and strange ways. Spears is, of course, way more famous than Paula Abdul, and if she sits on the panel and says nice, meaningless things to the contestants each and every show, she will have earned her money. (It’s basically what the booted Nicole Scherzinger did all last season of “X Factor,” and just by virtue of being Britney Spears, Britney will be better at it.)
“X Factor” doesn’t need a hyper-articulate ballbuster to do this job and do it well. The time of sharp, critical insight on the singing shows — which initially seemed so crucial to “Idol’s” massive success — has passed. If viewers regularly lament how dull and plodding the judging rounds are now that even Cowell has tempered his honesty, “Idol” remains the biggest show on television with a judging panel that consists of Steven Tyler, Jennifer Lopez and Randy Jackson, a group as likely to insult a singer as call a newborn baby ugly.
But even if all that’s required of Spears is a season’s worth of banal compliments, that will add up to more sustained speaking than Spears has ever publicly done before. Rarely, if ever, has there been a person as famous as Britney Spears who talks so infrequently. Her most famous moments are all gestural — dancing in music videos, performing on the stage at some MTV awards show, shaving her head, bashing a window. Long before her breakdown, she displayed an uncanny tendency to speak in linguistic white noise, to say sentences that contained almost no content, just lots of y’alls and “you knows” and “oh my goshes” and a basic mood of sweetness, excitement, gratitude, eventually disconnect, and more recently, in her conservatorship years, anxiety and discomfort.
If this doesn’t make Spears a perfect judge for “X Factor” it should make her a perfect character for “X Factor.” The drama of Britney — how she will be, what she will say, and how she will hold up — is a story line at least as compelling as the one that will play out with the performers, if not far more so. We’ve been watching her for 13 years, not merely half a TV season. It’s possible “X Factor” will be as good for her career as “Idol” has been for Jennifer Lopez’s, but it’s more likely it will be uncomfortable and upsetting, a full season of watching a zonked-out Spears nervously navigate a live TV show. But we Americans owe Britney Spears a pension and worker’s comp for pain and suffering risked for our entertainment, and I’m happy a major corporation is paying it out (to the tune of $15 million). However “X-Factor” goes for Britney, I can’t wait to see what she says.
Willa Paskin is Salon's staff TV writer. More Willa Paskin.
Today’s must-see viral videos
Watch: Britney Spears' new clip, "Footloose" remake trailer, Tom Hanks' strange TV appearance, and more
Charlie Day on "Jimmy Fallon" 1. Tom Hanks stops by Univision to dance with Spanish weather girl
Fun bonus fact: Outside of America, Chet Haze is kind of a big deal.
Tom Hanks en Univision ‘Despierta America’ (34)… by jenpokro
Drew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
Dissecting Britney Spears’ “Hold It Against Me”
The fallen pop star returns with "Hold It Against Me." Lady Gaga only wishes she'd thought of IV paint drips
Britney is crazy for you Lindsay Lohan would do well to look at Britney Spears for a role model. Only four years ago, Britney was attacking cars with an umbrella during a nasty divorce battle with Kevin Federline. Every day brought news of her recent exploits: letting her baby drive the car, rehab, hit and run charges.
Continue Reading CloseDrew Grant is a staff writer for Salon. Follow her on Twitter at @videodrew. More Drew Grant.
Can Britney come back?
Her new single storms the charts -- but does her image make sense in a post-Gaga world?
What’s the insistent thumping sound coming from the radio? What’s that “Love Boat” double entendre doing at the top of the charts? It can only mean one thing — like a disco beat snowstorm, Britney’s back, blanketing our winter with metallic purrs and owwwwwws.
Her much ballyhooed new single, “Hold It Against Me” (as in that time-honored request, “If I said I want your body now, would you hold it against me?”), dropped Tuesday and promptly rocketed to the top of the iTunes chart. It’s already 16th on the Billboard radio play chart, which means that if you haven’t heard it yet, don’t worry, you will by dinnertime.
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
“Glee” creator reveals season 2 secrets
Ryan Murphy talks about which pop star and knighted rock 'n' roller get their own episodes
FILE- In this file publicity image released by Fox, from left, Lea Michele, Jenna Ushkowitz, Amber Riley, Heather Morris, Dianna Agron and Naya Rivera perform in "The Power of Madonna" episode of "Glee". (AP Photo/Fox, Michael Yarish, FILE) NO SALES(Credit: AP) Spoiler Alert for all you “Glee” fans!
Ryan Murphy, the mastermind behind Fox’s musical comedy series, gave several juicy tidbits about the show’s second season at the Television Critics Association press tour. Drawing the most attention was the confirmation of an episode dedicated to Britney Spears.
“All the kids on the show, many of them went into singing and dancing because of her,” Murphy said. But inspiration for the episode came from the pop star herself. “It was [Spears'] idea,” Murphy said. “I think she loves what the show’s about.”
Continue Reading CloseBritney Spears wins, Twitter loses
The pop star's robotic tweets make her the most followed celeb. It's a defeat for Ashton Kutcher -- and humanity
Teen pop queen Britney Spears has delayed the start of her U.S. concert
tour by one day, due to unspecified production delays, her record label
announced October 30, 2001. Spears, pictured September 6 at the MTV
Music Awards in New York, will launch her North American tour November
1 in Columbus, Ohio, instead of October 31, Halloween night, in
Washington. REUTERS/Gary Hershorn/File
BK/HB(Credit: © Reuters Photographer / Reuters) Surrender, humans — the bots have won. In case you needed confirmation that corporeal existence is rapidly becoming optional, consider the story of a sad, sudden Twitter vanquishment.
Not so very long ago, Ashton Kutcher ruled unchallenged, an unstoppable Twitter force and the first person to acquire a million followers (a number that, by the way, seems downright quaint just a year later). And he did it the old-fashioned way: one quirky, personal tweet at a time. Sure, Kutcher will gladly use the medium to remind you that he has a new movie coming out in June, or when he’s doing Letterman, but he also sets the bar for celebrities on how to shill oneself while giving something back. Whatever you think of the guy as an actor, his tweets are a sweet, enthusiastic and authentic means of communication with his fans and critics. Kutcher’s the guy who will tell you what he had for breakfast (it might be a milkshake), post a backstage photo, and politely agree to disagree with a follower over violence in video games.
Continue Reading Close
Mary Elizabeth Williams is a staff writer for Salon and the author of "Gimme Shelter: My Three Years Searching for the American Dream." Follow her on Twitter: @embeedub. More Mary Elizabeth Williams.
Page 1 of 40 in Britney Spears